Showing posts with label PENSIONS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PENSIONS. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 5, 2023

RSN: Mort Rosenblum | Liberty, Sure; Fraternity, Sort Of; But Equality?

 

 

Reader Supported News
04 April 23

Live on the homepage now!
Reader Supported News

 

Police officers scuffle with protesters during a demonstration in Lyon, central France, March 23, 2023. (photo: Laurent Cipriani/AP)
RSN: Mort Rosenblum | Liberty, Sure; Fraternity, Sort Of; But Equality?
Mort Rosenblum, Reader Supported News
Rosenblum writes: "Those strikes and protests? Déjà vu. Paris isn't burning. Fractious France is mostly functioning as usual. But President Emmanuel Macron's retirement fiat has infuriated much of a nation that translates 'executive order' to 'I am the Sun King.' This might not end well."    


Those strikes and protests? Déjà vu. Paris isn’t burning. Fractious France is mostly functioning as usual. But President Emmanuel Macron’s retirement fiat has infuriated much of a nation that translates “executive order” to “I am the Sun King.” This might not end well.

With no legislative majority, Macron used a constitutional provision to raise the pension age by two years to 64. Germany and Italy just upped theirs to 67, based on similar math that shows longer lifespans and stalled population growth in Europe portend unmanageable future costs.

Options such as the Social Security system in America could let people retire early with reduced benefits or stay at jobs past 70 for a larger payout.

But this is France, where the idea is working to live rather than the other way around. “He has to understand that people also want to enjoy their lives,” Carl LeFrançois, a national labor union leader, told reporters. “We’re not here to die on the job.”

(Americans, please read on when you stop laughing. Retirement is only the surface issue.)

For me, “Mort à Macron” spraypainted on walls provokes a chuckle. But it’s not funny. Political deadlock cripples a crucial European leader with a nuclear arsenal, a globalist who takes climate collapse seriously, as Russia wages widening war to the east and China looms ever larger.

Opinion polls show two-thirds of the country agrees with LeFrançois. Many others who believe a delayed pension is a necessary sacrifice want a countrywide referendum if the National Assembly is deadlocked over a basic underpinning of French society.

And researchers at the prestigious National Center for Scientific Research (CNRS) see a troubling increase in violence by protesting students and young people who reject the old political processes that have kept Charles de Gaulle’s Fifth Republic from splitting at the seams.

Macron came to power in 2017, a flashy 39-year-old finance minister with solid ideas to get France back on track after François Hollande flamed out and left his Socialist Party in shambles. With a broad-based coalition of support, expectations were high across the board.

He helped Europe and NATO weather the Trump years. But he often failed to read the room at home. Efforts to curb generous social benefits rankled the middle-class. The rich got richer; the poor got desperate. Covid and Vladimir Putin’s Ukraine war cut deeply into joie de vivre.

Yann Sallet, an author friend with a keen eye, reflected a view echoed by others: “It’s like he functions in a bubble, sure of himself and isolated from realities, which strikes a lot of people as arrogant, detached. This latest move was a step too far.”

Macron was reelected last April, skunking Marine LePen of the far-right National Rally. But with no legislative majority, he is stymied by a leftwing coalition on one side and LePen’s France First partisans on the other. She demonizes immigrants, likes Putin and wants France out of NATO.

At first, he tried moderation. He fired his top security guard in 2018 for beating up a protester when off duty. Now a woman in northern France is on trial for calling him “filth” on Facebook, subject to a 12,000 euro fine. “Insulting the president” is illegal yet has been a national sport for generations.

With four years left and ineligible for a third term, Macron declares he intends to do what he thinks is right, like it or not. Failure to raise the retirement age, he told an interviewer, means “making our children pay because today you refuse to act with clarity and courage.”

Today, families struggle with the soaring prices that bedevil most of the world after Covid and the Ukraine war. Strikes disrupted transportation, and people took to the streets. Joblessness nears 20 percent among disaffected youth, who set fire to mounds of uncollected garbage.

As so often happens everywhere in today’s “breaking news” climate, parachute journalists and long-distance commentators made much of dramatic footage when the protests began. There was little analysis of the background or the big picture.

I left Miami for Paris on March 26 in war-reporter mode, prepared for the worst. A mass demonstration had gathered at the Place de la Concorde to march on the National Assembly just across the Seine. My Paris home is between the two, an old boat at the port just below.

I’ve covered countless such French manifs – manifestations – over the years, but these days they are different. Protesters are truffled with casseurs, apolitical a-holes who simply like to break stuff and torment riot police, who respond in kind. There was blood.

From an ocean away, Paris looked ugly. Elsewhere, cameras showed such isolated incidents as a fire at the façade of Bordeaux’s historic city hall. Then it was over. The French protest the way many of them work – with only measured zeal. I zipped home in a rental car and cancelled my backup hotel room.

The next round was days later and much smaller, a peaceable march from La Republique to La Nation – a symbolic route easily avoided. BBC’s Hugh Schofield, an old Paris hand, reported from the thick of it, calming down his anchor in London who pushed for details about mayhem.

Scattered demonstrations and strikes across a large country of 68 million people should not deter anyone’s brief holiday in France. Restoration specialists rebuilt Notre Dame after that massive accidental fire; they can handle a charred door in Bordeaux.

Cyril Hamon at the Alma Market in Paris typified interviews I did in the capital’s environs and, by phone, with trusted old friends elsewhere. He had his usual array of charcuterie, terrines and plats du jour he had lovingly simmered for hours.

“We just deal with this stuff, like grownups,” he said. “Sure, sometimes strikes and shortages are a pain in the ass, but all that is necessary to keep the government from getting out of hand.”

My hardware store lady, from India, was outraged by the uproar. King Charles III planned to make his first royal visit to Britain’s traditional friend-foe, with a full-bore banquet at Versailles. Unions announced they would snatch away the red carpet, and he went to Germany instead.

“I’m so ashamed,” she said of her adopted country, preferring not to be named. “What must the world think of us?” I reminded her I was from the United States.

The French reach exceptional extremes. The worst, world-class buttheads, include some union leaders whose sudden strikes often discomfit such victims as penurious grandmothers who save all year for Christmas family gatherings only to find planes and trains cancelled.

Near my Wild Olives redoubt in Provence, Eric Martin is at the other extreme: generous beyond description, hard-working beyond belief – as decent as human beings come. He is too busy to demonstrate, and that is not his thing, but he vehemently opposes a higher retirement age.

Eric’s Italian-born mother’s family escaped Mussolini. She married a French olive grower, and their kids went to work at 15. “After 47 years, that’s enough,” Eric said. I’d bet anything he’ll still be in the trees if he reaches his 90s, as his father was. But he has earned his pension.

Lots of others work a 35-hour week, with six-week vacations and 11 national holidays. Mothers get 16 weeks off after childbirth. Fathers get 25 days (32 for twins). Most transport and public service workers can retire in their mid-50s with sizeable pensions from ex-employers and the state.

Prime Minister Elisabeth Borne is meeting with unions and protest groups on April 6 to seek common ground. If the issue were only retirement age, she might get somewhere. But it isn’t.

The left-leaning weekly, Marianne, campaigns for a national referendum on Macron’s executive order. Comments it published suggests a long, bitter fight over what many see as Macron’s aloof manner and a cant that favors big business over traditional workers’ rights.

French intellectuals rank with rock stars, and Olivier Todd stands out. He edited Nouvel Observateur, then L’Express, and published a shelf full of books. He is still at it at 93. “Macron uses this incoherent, unjust and useless reform to demolish Frenchmen’s future security,” he wrote. “Macron sows disorder, he likes disorder, he governs by disorder.”

The president’s supporters disagree. He is an i-dotter who works with numbers. He has clear policies to confront climate change, ease international trade, box in Russia and co-exist with China, among others. But if one word describes the crisis at hand, it is disorder.

It is easy to sympathize with the French fascination with Asterix and Obelix, cartoon book characters in a feisty village of ancient Gauls who fight comically among themselves but close ranks against Romans who try to impose values they reject.

The left excoriates a society in which an Elon Musk or a Jeff Bezos can spit out long-time employees overnight like watermelon seeds via impersonal email lists with few, if any, benefits. They fear multinationals will muscle aside small business and artisans that make France French.

But today’s global crises transcend borders and societies. The far right targets “les immigrés,” a catchall of destitute war refugees, dissidents in danger of death by despot, people from ex-French colonies and undocumented migrants seeking a better life. “Terre d’Asile,” Land of Asylum, is not often heard these days.

Macron faces four more years of trying to stitch France back together, while playing a vital role in what remains of the “free world.” If an unleashed Trump 2.0 or an ideologue ignoramus like Ron DeSantis infests the White House, he will have to be a key player as Germany’s Angela Merkel was. For that, he needs a popular mandate at home.

For now, Paris is not burning. But smoldering anger seethes in the capital and across much of the country. It is anyone’s guess what might happen if Macron’s detractors from the left, right and center decide to toss matches.


READ MORE

 

Contribute to RSN

Follow us on facebook and twitter!

Update My Monthly Donation

PO Box 2043 / Citrus Heights, CA 95611







Tuesday, August 4, 2020

POLITICO Massachusetts Playbook: MARKEY apologizes to HENRY family — More TEACHERS want REMOTE school — Experts urge a REOPENING ROLLBACK — How a BAR fought the CITY and WON








Massachusetts Playbook logo
GOOD MORNING, MASSACHUSETTS.
MARKEY APOLOGIZES TO HENRY FAMILY — Sen. Ed Markey issued an apology to the family of Danroy "DJ" Henry on Monday, after Henry's father said he felt dismissed by Markey in the wake of his son's death.
Henry was killed by police when he was a student at Pace University in 2010. The officer who shot him, Aaron Hess, was never charged. Henry's family has pushed for the Department of Justice to reopen his case in the wake of George Floyd's death in Minneapolis this spring, drawing similarities between their cases. Celebrities including Beyoncé, JAY-Z and Rihanna have expressed support for reopening the case. Henry was from Easton and was killed in New York.
"My wife and I came to you 10 years ago as grieving parents asking for your help with our son's murder in upstate New York," Danroy Henry Sr. said in the video posted on Monday, addressed to Markey. The Henry family has met with a number of elected officials over the years. "You were the only one who didn't act. Not only did you not act in any way, we felt like you were just dismissing us using even the term 'colored' in the conversation."
"The only thing you offered us was lunch that day," Henry added. He was responding to a Markey television ad, which says the Malden Democrat is focused on justice.
Markey apologized to the Henry family on Monday afternoon, and expressed support for reopening Henry's case. Federal investigators declined to file charges in 2015.
"I strongly support the Henry family's efforts to reopen the case of the murder of their beloved son DJ Henry," Markey said in a statement. "I have reached out to the Henry family to offer my sincerest apologies, and to pledge to them my complete support to take action on this case. I am fully at their disposal, and hope to work with them."
Henry's parents have endorsed Rep. Joe Kennedy III in the Senate primary, and were Kennedy's guests at the State of the Union in 2015. Kennedy's campaign said the congressman remains "committed to doing everything he can to help them get the justice they deserve.”
IN THE MAIL — A new flier from a justice-focused political group landed in 12,000 mailboxes in Rep. Richard Neal's district over the weekend.
The Justice Collaborative is calling on Neal to support additional cash payments to Americans during the coronavirus pandemic. Officials in Washington, D.C. are negotiating another Covid-19 relief package this week, and advocates are encouraging Neal to back $2,000-a-month payments for the duration of the pandemic. The mailer.
Have a tip, story, suggestion, birthday, anniversary, new job, or any other nugget for the Playbook? Get in touch: smurray@politico.com.
TODAY — Sen. Ed Markey and Rep. Joe Kennedy III speak at a criminal justice forum hosted by WGBH. Congressional challengers Dr. Robbie Goldstein and Holyoke Mayor Alex Morse speak with former 2020 presidential candidate Andrew Yang about their campaigns.

HAPPENING TODAY - ECONOMIC RECOVERY IN THE MIDST OF A PANDEMIC: The coronavirus has caused a record-setting economic decline and tens millions of Americans have lost their jobs. Join POLITICO chief economic correspondent Ben White for an interview with LinkedIn chief economist Karin Kimbrough to discuss prospects for economic growth, the uptick in jobless claims after weeks of decline and how extending unemployment benefits could help in the economic recovery. REGISTER HERE.


THE LATEST NUMBERS
– “Massachusetts coronavirus deaths rise 10, positive test rate dips down,” by Rick Sobey, Boston Herald: “Massachusetts health officials on Monday reported 10 new coronavirus deaths and 165 new cases as the average positive test rate ticked down after gradually climbing for more than two weeks. The 10 new coronavirus deaths bring the state’s COVID-19 death toll to 8,648, the state Department of Public Health announced.”
DATELINE BEACON HILL
– “Here’s what opened in Phase 3 — and could potentially be at stake if Mass. reopening is rolled back,” by Martin Finucane and Jaclyn Reiss, Boston Globe: “Concerned about worrisome trends in the public health metrics, at least one prominent epidemiologist is advocating that Massachusetts return to Phase 2 of its reopening plan. The move from Phase 2 to Phase 3 happened less than a month ago, becoming effective July 6 statewide and July 13 in Boston. (Somerville has put Phase 3 of reopening on hold.)”
– “As COVID-19 rate rises, American Federation of Teachers Massachusetts calls for remote start to 2020-2021 school year,” by Steph Solis, MassLive.com: “Another Massachusetts teachers union is calling for school districts to start remotely, citing the slow rise of COVID-19 rates, testing delays and lack of proper ventilation in school buildings as red flags.”
– “Amid rise in COVID-19 cases, experts urge rollback of reopening in Mass.” by Dasia Moore and Kay Lazar, Boston Globe: “Daily counts of new COVID-19 cases continued to tick upward in Massachusetts over the weekend, approaching what some experts see as the threshold for rolling back the state’s reopening — an action at least one prominent epidemiologist says Governor Charlie Baker should take now to prevent a second surge in infections and deaths.”
– “Massachusetts Has Lost A Greater Share Of Revenue Than Most States Due To COVID-19,” by Mike Deehan, WGBH News: “Massachusetts lawmakers say they're still waiting for word from Washington, D.C., on whether states and local governments will receive more financial aid to deal with the economic fallout of the pandemic and the dire state of the 2021 fiscal year budget .”
– “As COVID-19 audits highlight flaws, MassHealth sends initial termination notices to 3 private nursing facilities,” by Steph Solis, MassLive.com: “Three Massachusetts nursing homes have received initial termination notices from MassHealth for failing to meet the state’s safety standards during the COVID-19 pandemic. Town and Country in Lowell, Hermitage Healthcare in Worcester and Wareham Healthcare in Wareham could be removed from the MassHealth program, according to the state Executive Office of Health and Human Services.
– “State bond bill includes $1M for Union Station cyber security initiative,” by Peter Goonan, Springfield Republican: “A state bond bill that passed the House and Senate last week includes $1 million for a collaborative cyber security initiative at Union Station. Mayor Domenic J. Sarno, in a prepared release, praised the Union Station funds and other earmarks for Springfield that were sponsored by state Rep. Angelo J. Puppolo Jr., under an Information Technology Bond Bill.”
– “Advocates Celebrate As Legislature Gets One Step Closer To Passing Environmental Justice Law,” by Miriam Wasser, WBUR: “María Belén Power, of the local nonprofit GreenRoots, was supposed to have a ‘date night’ with her husband Friday evening, but says she couldn’t stop checking her phone for updates on floor proceedings at the State House. The Massachusetts House of Representatives was working its way through more than 100 amendments attached to a sweeping climate bill known colloquially as the 2050 Roadmap.”
– “Massachusetts pensions keep bulging with state paying out $5.44B,” by Joe Dwinell, Boston Herald: “UMass retirees top the state’s $5.44 billion pension system, with the university’s former President William ‘Billy’ Bulger set to pocket nearly $272,000 this year, records show. The retirement fund — obtained by the Herald through a public records request — lists 1,540 pensioners who are set to earn six-figure payouts as the state struggles mightily during the coronavirus pandemic.”
– “Qualified Immunity Is Under Fire. Here's How The Legal Defense Has Played Out In Mass. Cases,” by Ally Jarmanning, WBUR: “When officers use excessive force and someone sues, police are not always held accountable in a civil lawsuit. That can be, in part, because of a controversial defense known as qualified immunity. Lawmakers at the State House this week are weighing a massive compromise police reform bill that could change that legal avenue.”
FROM THE HUB
– “Boston's Latest Racial Equity Push Isn't New,” by Adam Reilly, WGBH News: “For close observers of Boston politics, Mayor Marty Walsh’s recent announcement that he was forming an ‘equity and inclusion cabinet’ raised an obvious question: Haven’t we been here before? The cabinet, Walsh said in June, will be comprised of existing departments but led by a new ‘chief of equity’ and will put racial equity at the center of city policymaking.”
– “New effort aims to lift city’s valedictorians,” by Meghan E. Irons, Boston Globe: “Warren Tolman couldn’t get the story of Michael Blackwood out of his mind. Blackwood, a former valedictorian at The Engineering School in the Hyde Park Education Complex, received a full ride to Boston College in 2006. But part-way through that experience, his girlfriend got pregnant, and Blackwood decided to get a job and take classes part-time to take care of his child.”
– “Mass Technology Leadership Council calls on its members to double state’s Black, Latinx tech employees as part of ‘2030 Challenge,'” by Michael Bonner, MassLive.com: “Massachusetts’ largest group of tech companies is calling on its members to double the percentage of Black and Latinx employees in the state by the end of the decade. Introduced on Monday, the 2030 Challenge by the Mass Technology Leadership Council aims to push the percentage of Black employees at tech companies in Massachusetts to 10% and Latinx workers to 14%.”
– “City’s Black clergy express support for schools Superintendent Brenda Cassellius,” by Bianca Vázquez Toness, Boston Globe: “A prominent group of Black ministers on Monday said that they remain confident in Boston Superintendent Brenda Cassellius after a difficult first year on the job, arguing that the last thing the school district needs is more uncertainty amid a pandemic that is challenging educators and students as never before.”
– “Boston beer scene takes a hit: Somerville’s Slumbrew closes; Lord Hobo CEO speaks out on challenges restaurants face amid virus,” by Hayley Kaufman, Boston Globe: “‘I don’t know.’ That was the first line of an ominous Facebook post by Daniel Lanigan, CEO of Lord Hobo, who said that’s his only answer when people ask when his popular Cambridge bar and restaurant will reopen. In the post, Lanigan enumerates the litany of challenges he and so many others in the restaurant industry face in the COVID era.”
PRIMARY SOURCES
– FIRST IN PLAYBOOK: “Professor Cornell William Brooks, Former President And Ceo Of The NAACP, Endorses Alan Khazei, City Year Co-founder, For Congress In The 4th District Of Massachusetts,” from the Khazei campaign: “Professor and Reverend Cornell William Brooks, Former President and CEO of the NAACP, and Director of The William Monroe Trotter Collaborative for Social Justice at the Harvard Kennedy School is endorsing Alan Khazei for Congress in Massachusetts’ 4th Congressional District.”
– “Election 2020: Rep. Adam Schiff, Massachusetts native and chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, endorses Joe Kennedy III for Senate,” by Jackson Cote, MassLive.com: “Rep. Adam Schiff, a Massachusetts native and chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, endorsed Rep. Joe Kennedy III this week in the congressman’s bid to unseat Sen. Ed Markey in the Massachusetts Democratic primary.”
– “Kennedy Visits Pittsfield Encampment For Unhoused City Residents In Senate Campaign Swing,” by Josh Landes, WAMC: “Congressman Joe Kennedy campaigned in Pittsfield, Massachusetts this morning in his Democratic primary battle against incumbent Senator Ed Markey. Kennedy delivered supplies to unhoused city residents currently living in an encampment at Springside Park. Kennedy was joined by backers like Berkshire County District Attorney Andrea Harrington, State Senator Adam Hinds, and city councilors Dina Guiel Lampiasi, Yuki Cohen, and Pete White.”
– “Challengers take aim at Moulton in 6th District debate,” by Ethan Forman, The Salem News: “The first debate of the 6th District Congressional Democratic primary took place Sunday night as two candidates took aim at the incumbent U.S. Rep. Seth Moulton in a virtual Nahant Town Hall with Sept. 1 fast approaching.”
DAY IN COURT
– “Feds appeal ruling in Mashpee Wampanoag land case,” The Associated Press: “The Department of the Interior is appealing a federal judge’s ruling that blocked it from rescinding a reservation designation for land belonging to the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe in Massachusetts.”
WARREN REPORT
– “Elizabeth Warren Is Still Campaigning,” by Gabriel Debenedetti, New York Magazine: “Joe Biden and Elizabeth Warren didn’t know each other extremely well until March. They’d been crossing paths for well over a decade, most uncomfortably in 2005 at a Capitol Hill hearing, where they collided over bankruptcy law and the Delaware senator called the Harvard Law professor’s argument ‘very compelling and mildly demagogic,’ and most closely ten years later at Biden’s official residence in D.C.”
THE PRESSLEY PARTY
– “Rep. Ayanna Pressley: Preventing an ‘eviction tsunami’ is a matter of public health,” MSNBC: “Democratic Rep. Ayanna Pressley of Massachusetts says her proposed Housing Emergencies Lifeline Program, or HELP Act, will reduce transmission of coronavirus by keeping people in their homes.”
MARIJUANA IN MASSACHUSETTS
– “What will happen to 620,000 quarantined marijuana vapes?” by Shira Schoenberg, CommonWealth Magazine: “What does one do with 620,000 quarantined marijuana vapes? The answer, according to the state Cannabis Control Commission, is retest and resell them; use the material in another product; or destroy them. That answer was arrived at after the commission took the unusual step of acknowledging that it had no idea what to do with the quarantined vapes.”
ABOVE THE FOLD
— Herald: “ARE SCHOOLS READY?" "BULGING POCKETS,” — Globe: “Cities take initial steps in reparations over slavery," "Some experts urge rollback of reopening as COVID cases rise.”
FROM THE 413
– “Vicar general of Springfield diocese won’t accept reappointment, says he was ‘unfairly’ portrayed in Weldon report,” by Anne-Gerard Flynn, Springfield Republican: “Fallout continues in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Springfield as the diocesan vicar general, the Rev. Monsignor Christopher Connelly, will not seek reappointment, saying he was ‘unfairly and unfavorably portrayed’ in the recent report into allegations of sexual abuse by the late Bishop Christopher J. Weldon.”
– “Gunmaker Smith & Wesson’s board approves company split; two companies will be official Aug. 10,” by Jim Kinney, Springfield Republican: “Smith & Wesson, the historic Springfield-based gunmaker, said its board of directors has approved the long-planned split of the company into two: Smith & Wesson Brands which will include the firearms business and be headquartered in Springfield and American Outdoor Brands Inc. which will include the outdoor products and accessories business.”
– “Mask-less visitors violating state rules not challenged at Mass Pike shop in Lee,” by Caroline White, The Berkshire Eagle: “The crowd of men, about eight of them, hopped out of their vehicles and stood in a semicircle in the parking lot, talking and stretching. They then strode into the Massachusetts Turnpike Service Plaza in Lee — all without face masks.”
THE LOCAL ANGLE
– “Weston schools superintendent tests positive for coronavirus,” by Travis Andersen, Boston Globe: “Weston Public Schools Superintendent Marguerite ‘Midge’ Connolly has tested positive for COVID-19, according to a local official. Town School Committee chair John Henry confirmed the news during a meeting of the panel that was held remotely last week and streamed online.”
– “Gateway Pub reopens after bureaucratic bungling,” by Bill Kirk, Eagle-Tribune: “Sometimes, it does pay to fight City Hall. In the case of Amy Wenzel-Mellman, owner of the Gateway Pub, vs. the City of Lawrence, Mellman fought to reopen her small neighborhood bar and won.”
– “Black Families Together lays out school, police reforms it seeks in Worcester,” by Scott O’Connell, Telegram & Gazette: “From removing police from schools to reforming the city’s chief diversity officer position, a local group representing Black city residents laid out a list of changes the black community would like to see in Worcester at a town hall meeting Monday evening.”
REMEMBERING JOHN DELUCA … via MetroWest Daily News: “With a sly grin almost always on his face and a sometimes sarcastic sense of humor, it was sometimes easy to forget Framingham District Court Clerk Magistrate John Deluca had been battling cancer for more than a decade. Early Saturday morning, Deluca, 70, died from complications from treatment of his cancer.” Link.
HAPPY BIRTHDAY – to former President Barack Obama, who is 59; Dorchester Reporter founder and Boston Irish Reporter publisher Ed Forry; and Jordan Maynard of Gov. Charlie Baker’s office.
NEW EPISODE: THE ENDORSE RACE – On this week’s Horse Race podcast, host Jennifer Smith and guest host Katie Lannan discuss what’s happening on Beacon Hill, and Stephanie Murray weighs in on the race between Sen. Ed Markey and Rep. Joe Kennedy III. Subscribe and listen on iTunes and Sound Cloud.
Want to make an impact? POLITICO Massachusetts has a variety of solutions available for partners looking to reach and activate the most influential people in the Bay State. Have a petition you want signed? A cause you’re promoting? Seeking to increase brand awareness among this key audience? Share your message with our influential readers to foster engagement and drive action. Contact Jesse Shapiro to find out how: jshapiro@politico.com.

POLITICO'S "FUTURE PULSE" - THE COLLISION OF HEALTH CARE AND TECHNOLOGY : As the United States remains stuck in a screening crisis, a worldwide competition has been launched to find the top Covid-19 rapid testing solutions. The contest aims to find a system with a painless sample and quick turnaround for results. When will a breakthrough come? From Congress and the White House, to state legislatures and Silicon Valley, Future Pulse spotlights the politics, policies and technologies driving long-term change on the most personal issue for voters: Their health. SUBSCRIBE NOW.



Follow us on Twitter
Stephanie Murray @StephMurr_Jour

Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family
FOLLOW US


 POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA









Sunday, July 19, 2020

RSN: David Sirota | Wall Street Is Deeply Grateful for the Supreme Court's Recent Little-Noticed Ruling



Reader Supported News
19 July 20

At this time we have no donations coming in at all. We need your immediate assistance at whatever level you can afford.
Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News


If you would prefer to send a check:
Reader Supported News
PO Box 2043
Citrus Hts
CA 95611


Reader Supported News
19 July 20
It's Live on the HomePage Now:
Reader Supported News


Chief Justice John Roberts. (photo: Jim Lo Scalzo/EPA/Shutterstock)
David Sirota, Jacobin
Sirota writes: "Chief Justice John Roberts has created the most conservative court in modern history."

Supreme Court Justice John Roberts has been praised recently as a heroic force for moderation. But his court’s recent ruling just helped Wall Street giants stomp on thousands of public-sector workers and retirees in one of America’s poorest states.

hief Justice John Roberts has created the most conservative court in modern history: In just the last few weeks, his court has helped financial firms bilk pension funds, strengthened fossil fuel companies’ power to fast-track pipelines, limited the power of regulatory agencies that police Wall Street, and stealthily let Donald Trump hide his tax returns. As a reward for Roberts’s continued defense of the wealthy and powerful, much of the national media has obediently depicted him as a great hero of moderation, because he sort of seemed to snub Trump in a handful of other rulings.
The press corps is willfully covering up the Roberts Court’s class war — and the cover-up is happening even as the court’s latest salvo is now reverberating far away from the Washington political theater out here in the actual, real world.
Indeed, one of the Supreme Court’s least-noticed rulings in the last few months just helped the planet’s most rapacious financial firms — and one of Donald Trump’s billionaire pals — stomp on thousands of public-sector workers and retirees in one of America’s poorest states. It also helped Wall Street avoid a full public examination of schemes that fleece investors. As one industry trade publication put it: “Hedge fund managers slept a little bit easier” after the events that unfolded last week.
The Kentucky Case That Wall Street Really Feared
All of this traces back to the Supreme Court’s recent Thole v. US Bank ruling, which we first reported on in June. That radical opinion  — which has gone unmentioned in all the Roberts hagiographies — effectively barred retirees from suing when their employers let Wall Street firms bilk their pension funds.WALL
This was a huge win for both employers and the financial firms that drain retirement systems — and it was a victory that came at exactly the moment the Securities and Exchange Commission and FBI are sounding alarms about such firms’ exorbitant fees, conflicts of interest and secrecy.
This story could have ended there — and if you paid attention to the news (or lack thereof) you may have thought it did. However, less than six weeks after this travesty, the Thole ruling was just used by Kentucky judges to shut down another landmark case that Wall Street really feared — a case that could have forced some of the globe’s most powerful financial firms to open up their secretive schemes to public scrutiny for the first time.
The Kentucky case was filed by public-sector retirees who alleged that Wall Street behemoths including KKR and The Blackstone Group misled their state pension fund into investing in “extremely high-risk, secretive, opaque, high-fee and illiquid vehicles” that enriched the firms with excessive fees while delivering subpar returns that exacerbated the state’s financial crisis. Among the named defendants was billionaire Blackstone CEO Stephen Schwarzman, a top outside adviser to President Trump.
The plaintiffs in the case argued that in order to protect the pension system, the court needed to recognize workers’ standing to sue because the Kentucky pension officials who authorized the original investments would never take legal action that might spotlight their own complicity in the alleged rip-off schemes.
“The current (pension board) cannot and will not sue themselves or their alleged co-actors and any demand that they bring this suit would be a useless act,” they asserted. “All (pension) trustees have been involved in the wrongdoing and will not subject themselves to suit or public exposure and scrutiny.”
Preventing a Potential Pentagon Papers Moment for Wall Street
If the case went forward, KKR and Blackstone could have been compelled to turn over documents detailing all the secret fees, shell games and get-rich-quick schemes they use to profit not only off of Kentucky workers, but off of millions of public workers and retirees across the nation whose pension funds they manage. It would have been a potential Pentagon Papers moment for Schwarzman and other Wall Street billionaires.
But that’s when the Kentucky Supreme Court stepped in last week to side with the Wall Street firms and shut down the case — and to do that, they relied on the Roberts Court.
In its opinion, which cited the Thole ruling eighteen separate times, the Kentucky court asserted that the case should be thrown out because even though the Wall Street firms may have bilked the now-beleaguered pension fund, the Kentucky workers themselves had not yet seen a reduction in their promised benefits — and so therefore, the workers did not have standing to sue.
“Our decision today borrows heavily from the analysis of Thole,” wrote the Kentucky judges, who have their own separate, well-funded state pension system that didn’t funnel money into the high-risk investments.
They noted that “the Supreme Court in Thole recently rejected this exact argument” that the Kentucky workers were making.
Back in Washington, none of this made any news — the press was too busy helping manufacture their saccharine fairy tale about Roberts saving the world, even as he was ruining it for millions of workers.

But despite that news blackout, you can rest assured that the most powerful people in the financial industry noticed the ruling — and are deeply grateful for a Roberts Court that lets them continue stealthily vacuuming Americans’ meager retirement savings into billionaires’ bank accounts.
READ MORE


The White House at night. (photo: Susan Walsh/AP)
The White House at night. (photo: Susan Walsh/AP)

Trump Administration Pushing to Block New Money for Testing, Tracing and CDC in Upcoming Coronavirus Relief Bill
Erica Werner and Jeff Stein, The Washington Post
Excerpt: "The Trump administration is trying to block billions of dollars for states to conduct testing and contact tracing in the upcoming coronavirus relief bill, people involved in the talks said Saturday."
READ MORE


Federal officers use tear gas and other crowd dispersal munitions on protesters outside the Multnomah County Justice Center on Friday in Portland, Ore. (photo: Mason Trinca/Getty Images)
Federal officers use tear gas and other crowd dispersal munitions on protesters outside the Multnomah County Justice Center on Friday in Portland, Ore. (photo: Mason Trinca/Getty Images)  


ALSO SEE: Portland Mayor Demands Trump Remove Federal Agents From City

Oregon Sues Federal Agencies Over Protest Enforcement
Conrad Wilson and Dirk Vanderhart, NPR
Excerpt: "The Oregon Department of Justice is suing several federal agencies for civil rights abuses, and state prosecutors will potentially pursue criminal charges against a federal officer who seriously injured a protester." 


rotests in Portland, Ore., continued through early Sunday morning, following the Oregon Department of Justice's announcement it would be suing several federal agencies for civil rights abuses in the state. Demonstrations have taken place in the city for weeks following the police killing of George Floyd in May. 
Protesters dismantled fences in front of the Multnomah County Justice Center and Hatfield Federal Courthouse. The U.S. Attorney's Office in Oregon had previously said the fences were in place to "de-escalate tensions between protesters and federal law enforcement officers" and allow repairs on the buildings to begin. 
Demonstrators also set fire to the Portland Police Association building, according to Portland police. The fire was put out later in the evening, and police declared a riot in the area. 
Tear gas and flash bangs were used on protesters and arrests were made, according to videos and photos from the scene posted on social media. 
The Oregon Department of Justice announced Saturday it would be suing several federal agencies for civil rights abuses, and state prosecutors will potentially pursue criminal charges against a federal officer who seriously injured a protester.
The federal lawsuit names the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, the U.S. Marshals Service, the United States Customs and Border Protection, and the Federal Protective Service, agencies that have had a role in stepped-up force used against protesters since early July. The state filed the lawsuit late Friday night.
It lists defendants as John Does 1-10 because the "identity of the officers is not known, nor is their agency affiliation," the lawsuit states.
According to Oregon DOJ spokeswoman Kristina Edmunson, the suit accuses the agencies of engaging "in unlawful law enforcement in violation of the civil rights of Oregon citizens by seizing and detaining them without probable cause."
State attorneys are asking a judge to issue a temporary restraining order that "would immediately stop federal authorities from unlawfully detaining Oregonians," the DOJ said in a release.
The lawsuit is asking a judge to find that the federal agencies' tactics are indeed unlawful and violate Oregonians' First, Fourth and Fifth amendment constitutional rights. 
It is also asking that federal agents and officers identify themselves and their agencies before detaining or arresting any person, explain to the person why they're being arrested or detained, and not arrest any person without probable cause or a warrant.
The agency said that its Criminal Justice Division, joined by Multnomah County District Attorney Rod Underhill, has opened a criminal investigation in the case of Donavan LaBella, a demonstrator who was shot in the head with an impact munition last Saturday night, Edmunson said.
Those munitions are intended to be aimed below the waist.
LaBella's mom said she believes the officer aimed at LaBella's head."He's 6-foot-5," said Desiree Labella, referring to her son. "He has to be a terribly trained marksman to be off by 3 feet to hit him in the forehead right between the eyes. If he's that bad of a shot at such a short distance, he shouldn't have a gun."
The lawsuit, which is the second announced against federal authorities on Friday, comes after reporting by Oregon Public Broadcasting that revealed federal agents have detained peaceful protesters using unmarked vehicles, with little explanation or indication of which agency they belong to or why people are being taken into custody.
"I share the concerns of our state and local leaders — and our Oregon U.S. Senators and certain Congressional representatives — that the current escalation of fear and violence in downtown Portland is being driven by federal law enforcement tactics that are entirely unnecessary and out of character with the Oregon way. These tactics must stop," Oregon Attorney General Ellen Rosenblum said in a statement.
The state's lawsuit specifically highlighted the case of Mark Pettibone, a demonstrator who was snatched off the street by federal officers in the early hours of July 16, put into a van and brought to the federal courthouse.
"On information and belief, defendants did not have a warrant to seize Pettibone or the other citizens who have been detained, and will continue to seize individuals off the street without a warrant, in the absence of an injunction," the lawsuit reads.
Because the federal agents were not identified and their vehicles were unmarked, the lawsuit states that Oregonians could be at risk of kidnapping by "militias and other civilian 'volunteers' taking it onto themselves to pull peaceful protesters into their cars, in a manner that resembles the federal actions described."
Pettibone echoed that concern in his declaration within the lawsuit. 
"I did not know whether the men were police or far-right extremists, who, in my experience, frequently don military-like outfits and harass left-leaning protesters in Portland," Pettibone said. 
Pettibone's arrest has spurred national attention as President Trump has made Portland a focal point in recent days, saying local elected leaders have been overly lenient on protesters. On Thursday, acting Homeland Security Secretary Chad Wolf flew into Portland to tour the Mark O. Hatfield Courthouse, the federal facility where graffiti and other vandalism has been frequent in seven weeks of protests over police violence and racial injustice.
Since arriving just before July 4, the officers from Customs and Border Protection's elite U.S. Border Patrol Tactical Unit and the U.S. Marshals Special Operations Group have guarded Portland's federal courthouse. They've also assisted the Portland police in clearing protesters from city streets.
City, state and congressional leaders have criticized the federal force's use of weapons against protesters and have demanded their departure. 
"The federal administration has chosen Portland to use their scare tactics to stop our residents from protesting police brutality and from supporting the Black Lives Matter movement," Rosenblum said in a statement. "Every American should be repulsed when they see this happening. If this can happen here in Portland, it can happen anywhere."
READ MORE


The St Pancras branch of the National Unemployed Workers' Committee Movement stage a demonstration to demand 'work or maintenance' in March 1925. (photo: Topical Press Agency/Getty Images)
The St Pancras branch of the National Unemployed Workers' Committee Movement stage a demonstration to demand 'work or maintenance' in March 1925. (photo: Topical Press Agency/Getty Images)

Unemployed Workers Can Fight Back
Marcus Barnett, Jacobin
Barnett writes: "In the Depression-era United Kingdom, the National Unemployed Workers' Movement mobilized thousands to resist the indignities of unemployment. We're entering another period of massive economic crisis - and just like workers then, unemployed workers today can fight back."
READ MORE


Mohammed bin Zayed has built strong alliance with French President Emmanuel Macron (photo: AFP)
Mohammed bin Zayed has built strong alliance with French President Emmanuel Macron (photo: AFP)

France to Investigate Abu Dhabi Crown Prince Over Torture Accusations
The Middle East Eye
Excerpt: "French authorities are opening an investigation into allegations that Abu Dhabi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Zayed has been complicit in acts of torture."
READ MORE




Sunday Song: Leonard Cohen | The Partisan
Leonard Cohen, YouTube
Cohen writes: "Oh, the wind, the wind is blowing. Through the graves the wind is blowing. Freedom soon will come. Then we'll come from the shadows."







Indonesia's dam project might devastate the most critical areas of the Batang Toru ecosystem and drive the Tapanuli orangutan to extinction. (photo: Tim Laman/Wikimedia Commons)
Indonesia's dam project might devastate the most critical areas of the Batang Toru ecosystem and drive the Tapanuli orangutan to extinction. (photo: Tim Laman/Wikimedia Commons)

Critically Endangered Orangutan Species in Indonesia Gets Reprieve as Controversial Dam Delayed
Hans Nicholas Jong, Mongabay
Jong writes: "Construction of a hydropower plant in the only known habitat of a critically endangered orangutan species on the Indonesian island of Sumatra might be delayed for up to three years due to COVID-19 and funding issues."
Muhammad Ikhsan Asaad, who oversees the project for state-owned utility PLN, said the Batang Toru plant was supposed to start operating in 2022, based on the agreement between PLN and project developer PT North Sumatra Hydro Energy (NHSE).
"But it might be delayed to 2025, mainly because the drawdown from lender Bank of China is stopped due to environmental concerns as well as COVID-19," he said.
In construction, a drawdown refers to a situation in which a company receives part of the funding necessary to complete a project, and the rest of the funding might be disbursed gradually over the course of the project.
The project is estimated to cost $1.68 billion, financed through equity and loans.
NSHE initially sought loans from funders like the World Bank's International Finance Corporation (IFC) and the Asian Development Bank (ADB). But following the description of a new orangutan species, the Tapanuli orangutan (Pongo tapanuliensis), in the Batang Toru ecosystem in northern Sumatra in 2017, environmentalists have called for the project to be stopped or at least halted to allow for an independent scientific study of its impact on the newly known species.
They say the project might devastate the most critical areas of the Batang Toru ecosystem and drive the Tapanuli orangutan to extinction. Only 760 of the great apes are estimated to survive in a tiny tract of forest less than one-fifth the size of the metropolitan area that comprises Indonesia's capital, Jakarta.
Shortly after its description, the Tapanuli orangutan was categorized as critically endangered on the IUCN Red List due to its decreasing population trend — down by 83% in just three generations — and heavily fragmented distribution.
The IFC and ADB subsequently distanced themselves from the project. And in March 2019, the Bank of China, which is also involved in financing the project, said it had "noted the concerns expressed by some environmental organizations" and promised to carefully review the project. It has not issued any further public updates, leaving the funding for the project uncertain.
NSHE has previously confirmed that the project's funding was in doubt as a result of campaigns against the dam.
PLN director Zulkifli Zaini said environmental issues were among the reason why the project might be delayed.
"It is true that the project faced hurdles from NGOs over environmental issues," he said. "There are apes and other [animals] there."
The coronavirus outbreak has also proved to be a setback, with the work on the hydropower plant put on hold since January after construction workers from Chinese state-owned contractor Sinohydro, who had gone home for the Lunar New Year holiday, were barred entry back into Indonesia over health concerns.
NSHE has submitted a request to PLN, as the buyer of the plant's power, to push the start of the dam's operation to 2025. But the utility said a decision hadn't been made yet.
"NSHE and PLN are still in the stage of discussion or collective review regarding the target of the Batang Toru hydropower dam operational target," NSHE spokesman Firman Taufick said. "Whatever the result of the discussion between NSHE and PLN, we will always follow the policy and direction from PLN."
A decline in electricity consumption as a result of suspended economic activity during the pandemic is another factor that could delay the project, according to Riza Husni, chairman of APPLTA, a national association of hydropower plant developers.
Dana Tarigan, the head of the North Sumatra chapter of the Indonesian Forum for the Environment (Walhi), said he hoped PLN would take into account the environmental concerns over the project in making a decision.
"We're hoping PLN could see the rejection well," he told Mongabay. "There's not only the problem with COVID-19, but also rejections from many parties, whether it's because of [the potential impact on] the orangutan and other biodiversity, or on the safety of the people [living in nearby areas]."
Dana said Walhi had staged a protest in 2018 against the project outside the offices of PT Pembangkit Jawa Bali (PJB) Investasi, a subsidiary of PLN that serves as the project sponsor and a shareholder in the Batang Toru power plant.
The protesters demanded that PJB Investasi, which holds a 25% stake in NSHE, to withdraw from the project.
Dana also urged PLN to take into account a recent fact-check report by the IUCN that analyzes the many contradictory claims being made about the project's potential impacts, specifically assertions made by NSHE.
Fact-Checking
The report identifies several significant claims found in NSHE's publications or press releases as being inaccurate or misleading.
"In at least ten cases, assertions made in public-facing NSHE literature or on the NSHE website are found to be inconsistent with findings presented in earlier impact assessments conducted on behalf of NSHE," the report says.
The report also finds other claims made by NSHE contradict findings in peer-reviewed literature and technical reports.
"Some of these relate to the most controversial aspects of the project such as its impact on the Tapanuli orangutan and the ecology of the Batang Toru river, the demand for the power that the plant would produce, and the project's compliance with international investment standards," the report says.
Emmy Hafild, a senior adviser to NSHE's chairman, said the report mistakenly accounted for the whole project permit area, instead of its actual footprint, to assess its potential impact on the orangutan. She also said the permit area referred to in the report was based on the company's permit area during exploration stage, which was larger than the current permit area post-exploration.
"The IUCN fact check report is clearly wrong," Emmy said. "The report uses data that's already outdated and this is the location permit, not the footprint of the project."
Serge Wich, the co-vice chair of the IUCN primate specialists' section on great apes (SGA) and one of the researchers who described the Tapanuli orangutan, said it's clear the IUCN report refers to the whole permit area in fact-checking the company's claim.
"[A]nd we have always said that this indicates the maximum impact," he told Mongabay.
Wich said that while the project might not occupy the full area, its impact on the orangutan could still be devastating due to the location of the project, which lies at a key location for connectivity between the orangutan's subpopulations, split up across three separate blocks: west, east and south. By locating the dam there, the project would jeopardize that connectivity, he said.
Emmy denied the location of the project would impact the potential for a future forest corridor linking the western and southern populations of the orangutan.
"The footprint of the project has been checked by our friends [researchers] and it will not disturb the corridor," she said.
Wich said that might not be the case, as the latest Batang Toru ecosystem map provided by NSHE clearly shows that the project area is "a long wall-like structure cutting those three areas from each other."
Didik Prasetyo, an orangutan researcher at Jakarta's National University, who conducted a study on the project, said he's confident the hydropower dam will not threaten the orangutan as long as NSHE sticks to his recommendations. Among them: limiting the amount of traffic passing over the project's roads; and designing the project's overhead power lines to allow the orangutans to travel safely beneath them.
"If it's safe, then [the orangutans] will not be scared to briefly walk on the ground [to cross from one population to another]," Didik said. "The width of the road is not too dangerous for the orangutans if there's no one passing on the road. So we're recommending the traffic be limited to particular hours."
He said rehabilitating impacted areas is also crucial.
"We're recommending to the company that there are three areas that will be impacted significantly if the company doesn't manage [the project] sustainably," Didik said. "So we recommend these most-threatened areas to be restored as soon as possible."
He said there are 273 hectares (585 acres) of orangutan habitat in the project area, of which 84 hectares (207 acres) will be used as a location for permanent buildings by the company. The remaining 189 hectares (467 acres) will be reforested, he added.
NSHE said it will offset permanent forest loss caused by the project by planting trees in other areas, while temporary forest loss will be restored.
The IUCN report, however, says restoring affected areas might not be feasible. NSHE literature identifies heaps of dug-up dirt as the areas intended for restoration, but the IUCN says this might not be realistic because these areas consist of large amounts of unconsolidated material.
"The material is from underground and is potentially sterile to rehabilitation efforts and/or volatile to erosive processes," the report says.










Tuesday Afternoon Updates – Error 404: President Not Found

                                                                                                                                            ...