Baker, lawmakers lock horns again over climate change bill

Doug Fraser Cape Cod Times 

Published Jan 26, 2021

BOSTON – Legislators will vote Thursday to approve the same sweeping climate change bill that was vetoed by Gov. Charlie Baker two weeks ago.

Baker refused to sign the bill Jan. 15, citing concerns over the economic hardship higher emissions reductions could cause state residents and businesses. He was also skeptical that some renewable energy goals could be achieved, and said building-code changes in the bill would depress the industry and hamper efforts to build affordable housing. 

“There is strong agreement from the governor with the Legislature’s goals to address climate change as aggressively as we can and maintain the leadership role we have had in Massachusetts,” Kathleen Theoharides, Secretary of Energy and Environmental Affairs, told the Times Tuesday. 

Gov. Baker’s plan released on Dec. 30 was based on two years of analysis, she said, and set emissions goals based on science and cost-effectiveness. 

Two weeks ago, Baker said the bill landed on his desk at the close of the last legislative session and left him no time to make amendments. It’s likely there will be amendments this time, but the House and Senate passed the climate bill by overwhelming majorities, enough to override amendments or the governor’s veto, should he use it.

“I am expecting a unanimous or near-unanimous vote again this week,” said State Rep. Sarah Peake, D-Provincetown, who thinks Baker will return the bill with amendments to the Legislature.

“At this time, I certainly have no appetite to take up any of his amendments that may slow down the implementation of this bill and slow us down in getting to net-zero (greenhouse gas emissions by 2050),” Peake said. “All of us who live here on the Cape see the realities of climate change happening before our very eyes. …There is a clear cost to not addressing climate change as quickly as possible.”

While there has been pointed criticism of Gov. Baker from legislators and environmentalists for not signing the climate change bill, it’s not like he’s a climate change denier.

Last month, his administration released its own plan to reach climate change goals that included a 45% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 and net-zero emissions by 2050. This included retrofitting one million of the state’s 3 million homes to use electricity for heating and cooling, and electrifying the transportation sector, including the state fleet of 750,000 electric vehicles, by 2030. The state would also add 2,000 additional megawatts of renewable energy beyond what is already in the pipeline to power that change.

The Legislature’s bill, known as the Next-Generation Roadmap for Massachusetts Climate Policy, set more ambitious goals, including a target of 50% emissions reductions from 1990 levels and 75% by 2040, with status checks at five-year intervals.

It also boosted goals for offshore wind by 2,400 megawatts to a total of 5,600 megawatts. For context, the 800 megawatt Vineyard Wind utility-scale wind farm will generate enough electricity to power 400,000 homes and businesses.

The climate bill sets safety and accountability measures for the natural gas industry, including leaks and infrastructure, and environmental justice provisions for low- to middle-income communities that have suffered inequitably from climate change impacts and solutions. 

One of the main points of contention is the 5% of additional emission reductions by 2030 in the Legislature’s bill, which is beyond what Baker proposed.

Theoharides said that while it seemed like a small amount, it actually required heavy lifting, including an additional 400,000 electric vehicles, a new low-carbon fuel standard 50% tougher than any in the U.S., completely eliminating petroleum-based fuel oil for heating and adding 2,000 megawatts in clean energy.

She said the Legislature’s higher emission reduction goal didn’t allow for homeowners and businesses to take advantage of stock rollover, naturally retiring old equipment. She estimated the higher emission target would cost $6 billion and would be borne by taxpayers, businesses, vehicle owners and homeowners. 

Theoharides was also critical of the new building codes that require new structures to meet net-zero for emissions, while the governor’s proposal worked on making existing and new buildings as energy efficient as possible while preparing to switch to clean energy. 

“It’s disappointing that the governor is nitpicking at the margins of legislation,” state Sen. Julian Cyr, D-Truro said. “It will cost the commonwealth, businesses (and) families money, but prior generations have kicked the can down the road and left us with the clearest of choices: We either take action or sentence my generation, my children’s generation, or our grandchildren to a future that is unlivable.” 

MASSterList: Hope and fears | Most popular lawmakers | Pillow fight: Today's sponsor - the American Heart Association

 

Today  Articles  Headlines  Jobs

Advertise  Subscribe  Archives  Twitter  Facebook  Instagram

This email may be cut off by your email provider. To see today's full MASSterList, click "View entire message" at the bottom, or view the online version here. By Jay Fitzgerald and Keith Regan 01/20/2021 Hope and fears | Most popular lawmakers | Pillow fight       Happening Today   Biden and Harris inauguration   -- Amid tight security, President-elect Joe Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris take the oath of office in the 59th inaugural ceremony that marks the end of the presidency of Donald Trump. -- Mass. Gaming Commission meets to select topics for future business meeting agendas, 10 a.m. -- Massachusetts Water Resources Authority Board of Directors holds its January meeting virtually, with members expected to receive a fiscal year 2021 financial update, 1 p.m. -- Treasurer Deb Goldberg holds a private virtual orientation session for new legislators to give them an overview of the treasurer office’s duties, 3 p.m. -- Progressive Massachusetts hosts a virtual Zoom event to celebrate the inauguration of President-elect Joe Biden and to review legislative updates, 7 p.m. For the most comprehensive list of calendar items, check out State House News Service’s Daily Advances (pay wall – free trial subscriptions available), as well as MassterList’s Beacon Hill Town Square below.     Sponsored Taxing Drinks by Sugar Content Reduces Consumption by 25% The facts on sugary drinks are simple. They pose a real health risk. Kids especially are drinking too many of them. All those sweet drinks contribute to major health problems, like diabetes and heart disease. And with Massachusetts already spending nearly $2 billion per year treating obesity-related diseases, we need to address the problem. Massachusetts should take a page from a growing number of places across the country and adopt a tax on sugary drinks. Learn how a sugary drink tax would improve the health of Massachusetts.     Today's News   Reminder to readers: SHNS Coronavirus Tracker available for free   A reminder to our readers as the coronavirus crisis unfolds: The paywalled State House News Service, which produces MASSterList, is making its full Coronavirus Tracker available to the community for free on a daily basis each morning via ML. SHNS Coronavirus Tracker.     The coronavirus numbers: 45 new deaths, 13,469 total deaths, 2,567 new cases   WCVB has the latest coronavirus numbers for Massachusetts.     Presidential Inauguration: An historic day of hope and fears   It’s supposed to be a day of democratic pageantry – the swearing in of a new president and vice president, the latter the nation’s first female vice president. But the backdrop of today’s inauguration of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris is thousands of troops and police officers standing guard in the event of right-wing extremist violence in the nation’s capital. U.S. Rep. Seth Moulton says the threats are “very, very specific,” based on law enforcement briefings he’s received, reports WCVB. Still, most members of the state’s congressional delegation plan to attend today’s events, reports the Herald’s Lisa Kashinsky. Meanwhile, here's a sampling of the hopes and fears from around the state. From the Greenfield Recorder: “Locals nervous but excited for inauguration day.” ... From the Cape Cod Times: “Cape Cod people of color have renewed hope with Biden-Harris inauguration.” ... From the Globe: “Galvin calls for celebration of democracy on Inauguration Day.”     The roundup continues: Natick Town Meeting member and Straight Pride Parade organizer arrested for alleged Capitol-riot ties   The Globe’s Travis Andersen and Tonya Alanez and MassLive’s Michael Bonner report on the latest local arrests of those allegedly involved in the storming of the U.S. Capitol earlier this month. Some of the apparent evidence against them: ‘digital breadcrumbs,” as Bonner notes. Some residents are happy in Natick over the arrest of one of their own, calling it a ‘great first step,’ report MetroWest Daily News         Coming soon to Fenway Park and local pharmacies: Coronavirus shots   Faced with mounting criticism over the inconvenient locations of existing vaccination sites and the slow rollout of vaccinations in general, the Baker administration yesterday announced Fenway Park will be used as a mass-inoculation site – and shots will also be given out at CVS and Walgreens pharmacies across the state, reports Asher Klein at NBC Boston. And here’s more good news, via MassLive: “UMass expanding COVID vaccinations.” NBC Boston     Help (really) wanted: Barnstable virus assistance line flooded on day one   And here’s why new vaccination sites will be so desperately needed. On its first day in operation, a new Covid-19 help line in Barnstable County fielded close to 1,000 calls, many of them from older residents wanting to know when, how and where to get vaccine shots, reports Cynthia McCormick at the Cape Cod Times. Cape Cod Times     Are we bending the second-surge curve? Looks like it   SHNS’s Chris Lisinski (pay wall) reports on some encouraging statistical signs that the current post-holidays surge may be ebbing, based on weekend case data. And WCVB reports that yesterday’s case count of 2,567 was the lowest since Dec. 7. But here’s a warning shot via GBH: “New COVID Variant To Become 'Dominant' Strain In Massachusetts, Says Rep. Jon Santiago.”     Sponsored An investigative watchdog exposing corruption through filmmaking and unbiased reporting. Seeking to expose and report on Anti-Semitism and the BDS movement in America today, reversing the tide against hate. Dark Wire will bring you information and coverage you will not get anywhere else.     National Guard dispatched to Pittsfield nursing home after major outbreak   The overall coronavirus case numbers may be improving in Massachusetts. But the virus is still raging out there – and a Pittsfield nursing home has been hit particularly hard by an outbreak, reports Larry Parness at the Berkshire Eagle. Berkshire Eagle     Dems refile climate bill, setting up clash with Baker   The Herald’s Erin Tiernan reports that Democratic lawmakers yesterday “made good on their promise to forge ahead with wide-ranging climate legislation, refiling an identical bill to one vetoed by Gov. Charlie Baker last week.”  But leaders aren’t saying when a vote might be taken. Which leads to ... might they try to work out a compromise with the governor over some of his objections to items in the bill? Or are they truly in a defiant mood (CommonWealth)? Just thinking aloud.  Boston Herald     Regarding all those vetoes: Lawmakers have no one else to blame but themselves   It came down to bad time management. SHNS’s Michael Norton has a good story on all those gubernatorial vetoes of various bills and line items, big and small, and notes lawmakers left themselves vulnerable to override-proof vetoes due to leaving so much legislative business until the end of the session. SHNS (pay wall -- free trial subscription available)         Still, we have the most popular legislature in the country   Speaking of lawmakers, they may not be good at time management, transparency and other assorted parliamentary matters. But they’re still liked by the good people of Massachusetts, where voters hold the legislature in high regard, making it the most popular legislature in the country and nearly rivaling the popularity of Gov. Charlie Baker. Steve Koczela at CommonWealth has the poll numbers to prove it. CommonWealth     Globe to Baker: Either overthrow Lyons – or leave the GOP   This is interesting. The Globe’s liberal editorial board is advising Gov. Charlie Baker, a moderate Republican, to either oust conservative Jim Lyons and other pro-Tumpsters running the state GOP – or the governor should leave the party. Which, if the latter is the case, would admittedly “spell extinction for two-party politics in Massachusetts.” And which, we ask, would accomplish what?  Boston Globe     Taking their toll: Protests outside Baker’s home are trying Swampscott’s patience and resources   GBH’s Adam Reilly takes a look at all the recent protests outside Gov. Charlie Baker’s home in Swampscott and finds they’re stretching town resources, not to mention the town’s patience. One woman of color even says she’s afraid when she walks out her door. GBH         For some councilors, canceling special mayoral election is no slam dunk   Gov. Charlie Baker, Secretary of State Bill Galvin and some legislative leaders have signaled a willingness to let Boston forgo a special mayoral election this year. But first the city council has to ask – and there’s debate among councilors whether the idea is fair or not, reports Michael Jonas and Bruce Mohl at CommonWealth. Meanwhile, the Globe’s Marcela Garcia is giving state Rep. Jon Santiago, who’s also an emergency-room physician in Boston, a big plug this morning, saying he “seems to be perfectly positioned to meet the current moment and run for mayor.”     Political pillow fight: Wayfair and other retailers reportedly drop MyPillow products over founder’s stolen-election claims   Take it from us: The pillows are overrated anyway. The BBJ’s Lucia Maffei reports that Boston-based Wayfair and other retailers have dropped the sale of MyPillow products due to founder Mike Lindell’s vocal embrace of stolen-election conspiracy theories. Or at least Lindell claims he’s the victim of a vast retail boycott. BBJ     Upheaval: Two of three Wenham select board members call it quits   It’s extra lonely at the top right now. The town of Wenham’s select board is down to a single member after two others abruptly resigned in the wake of a municipal employee’s discrimination complaint against one of them. Julie Manganis at the Salem News reports the board could be shorthanded until the next local election, currently scheduled for May.  Salem News     Protecting their turf: Pot shops sue over new marijuana delivery regulations   They warned they would. And they did. The BBJ’s Jessica Bartlett reports that marijuana dispensaries have indeed filed suit over the Cannabis Control Commission’s recent approval of new pot delivery licenses that may, theoretically, cut into the profits of pot shops. BBJ         State Street says 1,200 jobs on the block in 2021   They held off as long as possible. After keeping its CEO’s pledge to avoid cutting jobs during a brutal 2020, State Street Corp. is now saying as many as 1,200 positions could be cut during the coming year, Jon Chesto at the Globe reports. Boston Globe     FBI arrests Watertown political scientist charged with secretly working for Iran   Local academics allegedly taking money from Chinese operatives. Now this. From Benjamin Kail at MassLive: “Federal prosecutors allege a Watertown political scientist and author posed for more than a decade as a neutral expert on Iran while peddling propaganda to American lawmakers and journalists on behalf of the Iranian government.” Kaveh Lotfolah Afrasiabi, 63, who says he’s taught at local schools, was arrested on Monday. MassLive     Global demand: The international community has a TTD list for John Kerry   Get the pom-poms out. As former Secretary of State John Kerry prepares for his new role as Joe Biden’s climate czar, a team of Politico reporters asked international leaders to assemble a to-do list for Kerry. Job one? To be a high-profile cheerleader for responding to climate change, both in the U.S. and around the world.  Politico     Glimmer of hope? Federal panel says Weymouth compressor project should get hearing   ‘What took you so long?’ That’s the reaction from neighbors who have spent six years battling a natural gas pipeline compressor station to news that the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission voted to find the agency improperly denied residents’ requests for a hearing on the facility before issuing a permit, David Abel at the Globe reports.  Boston Globe         Today's Headlines   Metro   South Boston St. Patrick’s Day parade again canceled due to coronavirus - Boston Herald Winthrop police chief to investigate Marblehead Swastika incident - Lynn Item   Massachusetts   JetBlue Worcester to NYC flight could be lost in airline agreement - Telegram & Gazette After losing $35 million, Berkshire Health Services leaders hopeful for better 2021 - Berkshire Eagle Worcester residents may be eligible for up to $3,000 in rental assistance through program launched by city amid COVID pandemic - MassLive   Nation   ‘Like a Ghost’ in the White House: The Last Days of the Trump Presidency - Politico Trump has discussed forming a new political party - Wall Street Journal   Jobs   Reach MASSterList's 22,000 Beacon Hill connected and policy-minded subscribers with your job postings. Have friends interested in one of these positions? Forward the newsletter to them! Contact David Art at dart@massterlist.com or call 860-576-1886 for more information.   Recent postings to the MASSterList Job Board:   Director of Programs, The Rennie Center for Education Research & Policy Deputy Director, Local Initiatives Support Corporation Data Strategist, Boston Region Metropolitan Planning Organization Central Transportation Planning Staff Executive Director, The Massachusetts Association of Community Colleges (MACC) State Contracting Policy Analysis Consultant, The Collaborative UTEC Policy Director, UTEC AIM Engagement Director- Central/Western MA, Associated Industries of Massachusetts Legislative Liaison, Department of Family and Medical Leave Director of Communications, Massachusetts Immigrant and Refugee Advocacy Coalition (MIRA) Workforce Development Director, The Massachusetts Association of Community Colleges (MACC) Deputy Political Director, SEIU Local 509 Executive Director, Asian American Commission (AAC)   To view more events or post an event listing on Beacon Hill Town Square, please visit events.massterlist.com. Beacon Hill Town Square   Jan. 20, 6 p.m. Lost Wonderland: The Brief and Brilliant Life of Boston's Million Dollar Amusement Park Hosted by: Boston Public Library   Stephen R. Wilk, author of Lost Wonderland, will discuss the story of Wonderland's creation and wild, but brief success which is full of larger-than-life characters who hoped to thrill attendees and rake in profits. More Information     Jan. 21, 8:30 a.m. 2021 Economic Outlook Hosted by: Boston Business Journal and CIBC Commercial Banking   Join the Boston Business Journal and CIBC for an expert look at the latest information concerning global, national and regional trends impacting the economy. The 2021 Economic Outlook will offer unique access to economic insights from world-class experts and professionals to help translate economic trends into competitive intelligence to grow your business and find opportunity in the coming year. More Information     Jan. 21, 12 p.m. Practical Tips to Ensure Personal Security and Avoid Cyber Crime Hosted by: Ashland Business Association   Fidelity Security Service VP and former FBI special agent Gary Rossi will explain how to protect ourselves and our loved ones from cyber threats. What you will learn: Learn where cyber crimes take place; how cyber criminals operate and who they target; strategies to protect ourselves; and how to protect elders from scams. More Information     Jan. 21, 1:30 p.m. Live Chat with Google Product Manager Hosted by: Product School   Join in and get all your product questions answered during our online event with Neil Joglekar, Product Manager at Google. He is a product manager at Google where he leads teams to improve consumer experience. He is also a YC founder. More Information     Jan. 21, 6 p.m. Alex Zamalin - Against Civility: The Hidden Racism in Our Obsession with Civility Hosted by: Boston Public Library   Join the Boston Public Library in partnership with the Museum of American History for an online conversation with author Alex Zamalin moderated by MAAH Direcror of Education and Interpretation L'Merchie Frazier. This program is part of the BPL's Repairing America Series. More Information     Jan. 25, 12 p.m. Defense Project Series: Dr. Peter Mansoor Discusses, "How cultural biases influence success or failure in war" Hosted by: Harvard Kennedy School   Join us as Dr. Pete Mansoor Mason Chair of Military History, The Ohio State University, discusses the influence of culture on U.S. and international militaries and the resulting impact on war strategies and the prospects for success. More Information     Jan. 25, 12 p.m. Light, Land, and Water; Native and non-Native Visions of New England Hosted by: The Courtauld Research Forum   This lecture will attempt to honor diverse definitions of :landscape" by examining Wabanaki baskets and beadwork alongside canvases by New England painters such as Fitz Henry Lane and Martin Johnson Heade, It will raise questions about depictions (or embodiments) of natural resources, relationships between humans, and the environment and entanglements of Native non-Native histories. More Information     Jan. 25, 6 p.m. Human Trafficking 101 Hosted by: The Key2Free   The Key2Free is committed to education and increased awareness with the goal of preventing trafficking before it starts. Across all states, victims of sex trafficking are enslaved every day through force, fraud, or coercion. Together, we can call attention to and fight the shocking realities of the injustice happening right here in our communities. More Information     Jan. 25, 7 p.m. The History of the Big Dig with David Kruh Hosted by: Cary Memorial Public Library   David Kruh returns with another exciting talk, this time on a history you might remember - the Big Dig. Get the scoop on one of the country's most expensive and ambitious construction projects, from a former spokesperson of the project. Brought to Cary Library in partnership with the Lexington Historical society. More Information     Jan. 26, 1:30 p.m. Live Chat with fmr Netflix Senior Product Manager Hosted by: Product School   Join in and get all your Product Management questions answered during our online event with Johnny Chang, Product Manager at Netflix. Chang is a Senior Product Lead who focuses on users, bringing leadership and vision and simplifying the chaos and chunk vague problems. He was passionate about computer software from a young age and studied computer science in college and grad school. More Information     Jan. 26, 6 p.m. Lindsay Peoples Wagner - The Pandemic & Black Lives Matter: How Young People Are Building A New Normal Hosted by: Boston Public Library   The Boston Public Library welcomes Editor-in-Chief of New York Magazine's The Cut, and former Editor-in-Chief of Teen Vogue, Lindsay Peoples Wagner, for an online conversation moderated by BPL President David Leonard. More Information     Jan. 27, 12 p.m. Malcolm Gladwell and the New Normal after COVID-19 Hosted by: Arent Fox LLP   Join Arent Fox for a one hour virtual event with Malcolm Gladwell, the celebrated journalist and best-selling author of Tipping Point, Outliers, and Talking to Strangers, who will talk about life after COVID-19. There will also be a Q&A with Arent Fox Partner Anthony V. Lupo.Malcolm Gladwell and the New Normal after COVID-19 JAN 27 2021 12:00 PM Hosted by: Arent Fox LLP Online Event www.eventbrite.com/e/malcolm-gladwell-and-the-new-normal-after-covid-19-tickets-132113604347?aff=ebdssbonlinesearch Join Arent Fox for a one hour virtual event with Malcolm Gladwell, the celebrated journalist and best-selling author of Tipping Point, Outliers, and Talking to Strangers, who will talk about life after COVID-19. There will also be a Q&A with Arent Fox Partner Anthony V. Lupo. More Information     Jan. 28, 11 a.m. Condition of Education in the Commonwealth Hosted by: The Rennie Center for Education Research & Policy   Join the Rennie Center for a conversation on the state of learning in this unprecedented time, including a panel discussion with all three MA education commissioners—Elementary and Secondary Education Commissioner Jeffrey C. Riley, Early Education and Care Commissioner Samantha Aigner-Treworgy, and Higher Education Commissioner Carlos Santiago—and remarks from Secretary of Education James Peyser. More Information     Jan. 28, 2 p.m. lo T in Sports: Changing the Game Hosted by: Verizon   Join us as we hear from industry experts about the integration of lo T in the world of live sports, how major leagues like the NFL are utilizing wearable technology and connected devices, what features fans can expect from stadiums as they become more connected, and how 5G & MEC are changing the game for years to come. More Information     Jan. 28, 6 p.m. Dr. Maya Rockeymoore Cummings & James Dale - "We're Better Than This" Hosted by: Boston Public Library   Join the Boston Public Library for an online talk with distinguished political expert, Dr. Maya Rockeymoore Cummings and longtime non-fiction writer James Dale, co-authors of We're Better Than This: My Fight for the Future of our Democracy, primarily authored by the late Elijah Cummings. More Information     Jan. 28, 6 p.m. Community Read Book Group: An Indigenous Peoples' History of the United States Hosted by: Boston Public Library   Let's read together! Join your friends, family and fellow Yearlong Reading Challenge participants at the Boston Public Library as we discuss the January Community Read for adults: An Indigenous Peoples' History of the United States by Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz. The discussion will be moderated by a librarian and will take place on Zoom. More Information     Jan. 29, 12 p.m. Global Mobility and the Threat of Pandemics: Evidence from Three Centuries Hosted by: Harvard Kennedy School   Researchers at the Center for Global Development test predictions across four global pandemics in three different centuries: the influenza pandemics that began in 1889, 1918, 1957, and 2009. They find that in all cases, even a draconian 50 percent reduction in pre-pandemic international mobility is associated with 1-2 weeks later arrival and no detectable reduction in final mortality. More Information     Feb. 1, 12 p.m. Human Rights and the Future World Order Hosted by: Harvard Kennedy School and Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs   Speakers include Hina Jilanni, former United Nations Special Representative of the Secretary-General on Human Rights Defenders; Samuel Moyn, Henry R. Luce Professor of Jurisprudence, Yale Law School and Professor of History, Yale University; Zeid Ra'ad, Perry World House Professor of the Practice of Law and Human Rights, University of Pennsylvania. More Information     Feb. 2, 2 p.m. Social Media for Government Agencies and the Public Sector: Everything You Need to Know but are Afraid to Ask, a Digital CP Hosted by: Harvard Kennedy School   Come learn the basics of the Social Media platforms and how you can use them effectively to achieve your goals. Whether you're a Tik Tok influencer or just learned that the symbol # isn't a "pound sign". This workshop is open to all levels. More Information   How to Contact MASSterList     For advertising questions and Beacon Hill Town Square submissions, please email: dart@massterlist.com. For Happening Today calendar and press release submissions, please email: news@statehousenews.com. For editorial matters, please email: editorial@massterlist.com.   MASSterList, 568 Washington St, Wellesley, MA 02482