Showing posts with label ABORTION PILL. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ABORTION PILL. Show all posts

Friday, June 14, 2024

No Standing For You

 


No Standing For You

FDA v. Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine

In April of 2023, Matthew Kacsmaryk, a federal district judge in Amarillo, Texas, entered a nationwide injunction banning mifepristone, one of two drugs used for medication abortion. He did that despite 20 years of data that established mifepristone as safe and effective, with fewer complications than Tylenol. Judge Kacsmaryk entered a stay for seven days to give DOJ an opportunity to appeal his order. They didn’t need a week, though. They filed within hours.

People who thought it couldn’t get any worse after Dobbs gutted the abortion rights guaranteed in Roe v. Wade were stunned. Medication abortion accounts for more than half of the procedures in the United States, and a significant majority of the public favors letting women use it.

The Supreme Court: Current Justices | Supreme Court Historical Society

Today, the Supreme Court released its opinion in FDA v. Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine. Here’s a little background—you can be forgiven if you’ve lost track of how this case has evolved since I first wrote about District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk’s order granting a nationwide injunction banning mifepristone in April of 2023.

Mifepristone was approved by the FDA in 2000. At that time, it had to be prescribed by a doctor, patients were required to have three in-person visits with the doctor, and the drug could only be used to terminate pregnancies up to seven weeks. That changed in 2016, when the FDA relaxed some of those rules, permitting mifepristone to be used up to 10 weeks, allowing healthcare providers like nurse practitioners to prescribe the drug, and permitting just one in-person visit . In the midst of the pandemic in 2021, the FDA did away with the in-person visit requirement altogether.

None of that sat well with the plaintiffs, a group of doctors who were anti-abortion. They challenged everything from the FDA’s approval of the drug in the first place in 2000 forward. At the time, I was deeply concerned that when the case got to the Supreme Court, they might take advantage of the opportunity to all but end access to the most widely used form of abortion left to American women.

But that didn’t happen, at least not today. The Supreme Court didn’t end access to mifepristone; instead, it ducked the substantive issue, leaving it for another day by ruling that the plaintiffs in this case lacked standing and dismissing the proceeding on that basis without considering the merits of their argument. When we first looked at the case, we discussed the fact that that was the correct outcome, that the case should be dismissed due to a lack of standing. The surprise is that this Court, with its uniquely results-oriented jurisprudence when it comes to denying access to abortion, went ahead and did it.

The decision was 9-0, with Justice Brett Kavanaugh writing for a unanimous court. Only Justice Thomas wrote a separate argument, a concurrence.

The sigh of relief here is only temporary. There is nothing to prevent anti-abortion forces from finding better plaintiffs and returning to court. Part of the plaintiffs’ argument in this case involved the Comstock Act, an old law, not used for decades, which bans mailing anything that educates about or can be used to provide an abortion. The law was passed at the behest of a religious fanatic who wanted to define moral purity for the country. Now, conservatives want to bring it back into use, and it’s very unlikely we’ve heard the last of it. We talked about the Comstock Act and its origins in depth here, and it’s worth going back for the refresher—your outrage will keep you from becoming complacent.

If you’re out of time and attention, stop here. But I’ll spend a little time on the details of the case and the standing argument, and what it’s future implications might be, for those who want to be legal nerds tonight.

Your support lets me indulge in the legal nerdiness that follows. Sometimes, it’s enough to know how a case comes out. Other times, it’s good to have the chance to look at both procedural and substantive details to advance our understanding of how our courts work—and are supposed to work. I appreciate those of you who can sign up for paid subscriptions to make this possible.


You can read the full opinion here.

The lawsuit was filed in Texas in 2022 by four pro-life medical associations and several individual doctors with the goal of ending approval for mifepristone. They had a specific judge in mind for their case, Judge Kacsmaryk, who had vigorous anti-abortion views and was the only judge in the Amarillo Division of the Northern District of Texas, which meant they were almost certain to end up with him if they filed the case there. They asked Judge Kacsmaryk to enter a preliminary injunction while the litigation was underway that would either force the FDA to withdraw its initial approval of mifepristone or at least rescind the decisions in 2016 and 2021 that expanded access to it.

Judge Kacsmaryk went all in with the plaintiffs, effectively enjoining the FDA’s approval of mifepristone and ordering its removal from the market. On appeal, the Fifth Circuit granted the stay in part. On the case’s first trip to the Supreme Court, the Justices stayed Judge Kacsmaryk’s order. If you want to refresh your recollection of that “shadow docket” ruling, we discussed it here.

That decision was not unanimous. Thomas and Alito voted against the stay and would have let the ban go into effect while the case was being litigated. It’s possible there could have been additional dissents from granting the stay if Justices chose not to reveal their vote—it only takes five justices to act here. But it was Justice Alito who wrote to explain his decision, provocatively and baselessly claiming that under Biden, the FDA would refuse to follow a lawful court order against it in the case, which drew cries of outrage.

The case went back to the Fifth Circuit. They held that the plaintiffs had standing, so the case could proceed. But they ruled, partially, against the plaintiffs, finding they weren’t likely to successfully challenge the original approval of the mifepristone. They ruled in their favor on the FDA’s expansion of access to the drug in 2016 and 2021, calling it unlawful. That meant that while the Court permitted mifepristone to stay on the market, they limited its use to the original conditions, which only made it available up to seven weeks, so long as it was prescribed by a doctor and used in connection with three in-person visits. The Supreme Court agreed to revisit that decision, which is how the case got to the Court again.

But the Court never got to the question of whether the FDA exceeded its authority, because the case was over once they reached the conclusion the plaintiffs didn’t have standing. Justice Kavanaugh did not mince words, writing, “Under Article III of the Constitution, a plaintiff ’s desire to make a drug less available for others does not establish standing to sue. Nor do the plaintiffs’ other standing theories suffice. Therefore, the plaintiffs lack standing to challenge FDA’s actions.”

What is standing? Justice Kavanaugh references the famous question posited by Justice Scalia, writing in the opinion, “As Justice Scalia memorably said, Article III requires a plaintiff to first answer a basic question: “‘What’s it to you?’” Standing means that “the plaintiff cannot be a mere bystander, but instead must have a “personal stake” in the dispute.”

The test for standing is well established. It requires a plaintiff to show that

  1. She has suffered or likely will suffer an injury in fact,

  2. The injury likely was caused or will be caused by the defendant, and

  3. The relief requested from the court would be sufficient to redress the injury

Justice Kavanaugh wrote that the plaintiffs didn’t meet the test. There are federal conscience laws in place that provide definitive protection for doctors who don’t want to perform abortions or related treatment, and the law protects them from any repercussions due to their refusal. There was no evidence the doctors suffered any economic harms. So, he concluded, there was no injury in fact. “The injury in fact requirement prevents the federal courts from becoming a ‘vehicle for the vindication of the value interests of concerned bystanders.’” A person has to have actual skin in the game to be a plaintiff with standing. Justice Kavanaugh rejected the idea that these plaintiffs suffered injuries caused by the FDA, stating that “the causation requirement screens out plaintiffs who were not injured by the defendant’s action. Without the causation requirement, courts would be ‘virtually continuing monitors of the wisdom and soundness’ of government action.”

There’s a double-edged sword here that also gets fleshed out a bit further in Justice Thomas’ concurrence. It’s the notion of organizational standing. The plaintiffs say they have been harmed and forced to incur costs to oppose the FDA’s policies, listing the following items:

  • The FDA “caused” the associations to conduct their own studies on mifepristone so that the associations can better inform their members and the public about mifepristone’s risks.

  • The FDA “forced” the associations to “expend considerable time, energy, and resources” drafting citizen petitions to the FDA, as well as engaging in public advocacy and public education.

  • All of that has caused the associations to spend “considerable resources” to the detriment of other spending priorities.

Justice Kavanaugh is still not impressed. He writes, “But an organization that has not suffered a concrete injury caused by a defendant’s action cannot spend its way into standing simply by expending money to gather information and advocate against the defendant’s action. An organization cannot manufacture its own standing in that way.” Justice Thomas would go further than that. He writes in his concurrence that, “Our third party standing doctrine is mistaken,”—he would abolish it.

Justice Thomas looks back to an old Alabama case using what’s called associational standing to permit the NAACP to assert claims on behalf of its members. He does not seem to take issue with that case directly because the NAACP arguably faced injuries of its own, but he suggests the Court subsequently did away with that requirement and that associational standing and broad injunctive relief are used to give far too many people remedies for tenuous reasons.

Some civil rights cases and other cases designed to protect rights like abortion rights rely on organizational standing when the proper criteria are met. In some situations, organizations can sue when it is not safe or practical for their members to do so individually. That means there is reason to be concerned that this decision will come back to haunt in future cases. These restrictions on organizational standing already exist in the law, but it is easy to imagine this case being cited back at clinics suing against abortion restrictions or voters who are represented by a civil rights group. Standing is in the eye of the beholder, which means judges have a great deal of discretion to exercise and no definitive answer since the inquiry, as Justice Kavanaugh noted earlier in the opinion, is heavily fact-based. What is needed is the judge as a neutral umpire, calling the balls and the strikes, and not a judge who is seeking to restore what he considers the godliness of America with his every ruling. In other words, this case only underscores our concerns about the Court. And while Justice Thomas is the only one explicitly calling to reject this form of standing today, he was once the only Justice suggesting privacy protections that gave Americans a right to contraception should be overruled. Don’t lose sight of what’s on the ballot in November.

But, at least for today, the Supreme Court has protected the right of American women to access medication abortion in states where abortion is still legal. Justice Kavanaugh concluded: “We recognize that many citizens, including the plaintiff doctors here, have sincere concerns about and objections to others using mifepristone and obtaining abortions. But citizens and doctors do not have standing to sue simply because others are allowed to engage in certain activities—at least without the plaintiffs demonstrating how they would be injured by the government’s alleged underregulation of others.” He also rejected the plaintiff's argument that they had to have standing because if they didn’t, no one did. First, he didn’t accept the idea that there was no one else with standing—perhaps a harbinger of a future legal challenge by states using the Comstock Act—but also, he noted that not all disputes with the government have to be solved with lawsuits and that “some issues may be left to the political and democratic processes.”

Last night I suggested we shouldn’t lose sight of the Court’s ethics issues when the “big cases” started coming down. This case illustrates that proposition. Earlier this week, I mentioned that I was intrigued by a review of how Justice Alito ruled in standing cases. His results-oriented rulings showed he ruled that 100% of the plaintiffs in cases he was ideologically aligned with had standing, but none of the plaintiffs in cases he was opposed to did. That’s remarkable. Here’s a little excerpt from that edition of the newsletter:

Image

What should we now make of Justice Alito’s ruling in the mifepristone case, where he ruled against a party he, until now, has always sided with? It was Justice Brandeis who once said that sunlight is the best disinfectant.

At oral argument in this case, Justice Alito seemed well along to affirming the Fifth Circuit and finding that the plaintiffs’ had standing. But after recent focus on his and other ethical issues on the Court, he apparently backed off.

The test for standing clearly leads to the result in this case, the one that a 9-0 Court reached—no standing. That hasn’t stopped Justice Alito from engaging in results-oriented judging in cases with tenuous standing in the past, but it did here.

Sunlight and lots of it. When we pay attention in a sustained and well-informed fashion, we ourselves may actually be able to restore some of the guardrails at the Court. They used to self-enforce. We don’t know for certain what came into play in this opinion, but Justice Alito’s remarkable shift in view from oral argument and it’s timing lead me to believe we must make sure the Court knows that our eyes are on them and that our expectations for their commitment to the rule of law and the institution they have the honor of being part of are far higher than what we’ve seen recently.

We’re in this together,

Joyce


Thursday, April 25, 2024

Wednesday When The News Kept Happening

 


Today has been one of those blockbuster days where you don't know quite where to look.

For starters, we’re catching up with a decision by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) that ends the use of noncompete agreements. A noncompete usually takes the form of a clause in a contract or a separate agreement that prohibits a departing employee from taking any job or starting any business that competes with their former employer for a specified period of time after the employment ends. The agreements also prevent the employee from revealing proprietary information or secrets to anyone else at any time.

Their use is widespread, and there is an entire industry of lawyers who specialize in them. So it was a sea change yesterday when the FTC issued a final rule that the agency says will promote competition by banning noncompetes nationwide. The move is billed as one that will protect “the fundamental freedom of workers to change jobs” as well as “increasing innovation, and fostering new business formation.”

This will affect a lot of folks in the workforce. It has the potential to become not just an interesting legal issue but also a campaign one, with the FTC claiming major benefits for the economy as a result. Read their press release on this move here.

Then, there was the Supreme Court, where the Idaho abortion case was argued today. You may recall this situation from August of 2022, when Idaho passed a law criminalizing virtually all abortions, and we first discussed it here on Civil Discourse. DOJ sued the state, making an argument that Idaho, even after Dobbs took away abortion rights and left women at the mercy of state legislatures, couldn’t do this because of an obscure federal provision called the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA). Our original post about this case and the theory behind it is here.


Today’s argument was astutely characterized as “gendered” by Dahlia Lithwick, one of the commentators who noted there seemed to be a split between the views of the four women Justices and the men. Idaho argued that women might be required to lose an organ to save an “unborn child.” The progressive Justices, with the somewhat surprising addition of Justice Amy Coney Barrett, saw flaws in Idaho’s approach.

EMTALA was enacted by Congress in 1986 and requires that hospitals that receive federal funds provide patients with stabilizing care. It was an effort to prevent the practice of “patient dumping” that often left uninsured or low-income people in precarious medical conditions as hospital ERs transferred them to other facilities that would care for them without stabilizing their condition first.

Although this case is limited to Idaho’s near-total abortion ban, the decision will likely have impacts across the country. We will take that up in more detail Friday night when we hear from emergency room physician and all-around good human being Dara Kass, whose commentary you may have seen on television—she recently left the Biden Administration, where she had a position with the Department of Health and Human Services. Dara will help us understand the likely impact of the decision in this case from a medical perspective.

Idaho argued that the Dobbs decision left abortion access entirely up to the states. It accused the Biden administration of upending federal law to turn Idaho emergency rooms into “abortion enclaves in violation of state law.” The state’s law authorizes prison sentences of up to five years and loss of a doctor’s medical license, even if the doctor believes the procedure was necessary under the law’s narrow exception for saving the woman’s life or in cases of rape and incest.

When it comes to this term’s abortion cases, there has always been reason to believe that although the Court probably won’t go so far as to ban medication abortion completely in the mifepristone case, the EMTALA case is likely to go in favor of Idaho. The hope is that the loss in EMTALA will be the narrowest one possible, one that avoids further devastation of women’s access to care and the medical risks we’re now seeing them face. Justice Barrett will play an important role here. Uncertainty will continue until the decision is made and likely after that, as doctors continue to worry about prosecutors second-guessing their treatment decisions. A decision will likely come down late in the Court’s term, which ends the last week of June/first week of July.

This is a real problem in the post-Roe v. Wade environment. So long as there is uncertainty about when doctors can perform an abortion without risk of criminal prosecution, women's health suffers. Uncertainty around care continues to be devastating for women’s health, as we saw last week when a Texas woman miscarried in a restroom toilet in an emergency room lobby while her frantic husband called for help from 911. The front desk staff at Sacred Heart Emergency Center in Houston refused to permit her to check in when she arrived seeking care.

Wednesday night, as the news day was drawing to a close on the East Coast, we learned that Arizona had indicted people involved in the fake elector scheme in that state following the 2020 election. The charge is an Arizona state law conspiracy to overturn the popular vote in that state. Arizona joins Georgia, where Fani Willis notably brought a RICO indictment, and Michigan, where only the in-state electors are indicted, in charging fake electors cases. Two people from Trump’s inner circle who haven’t been indicted before, lawyers Boris Epshteyn and Christina Bobb, are included in the Arizona indictment.

Kenneth Chesebro may be cooperating with prosecutors. He is not charged—but seems to be one of the unindicted co-conspirators in the case. There were earlier reports that he was cooperating with Arizona prosecutors. If that cooperation is fulsome, it could lead to a situation where people he is able to testify against become highly motivated to cooperate as well. But he has been a reluctant and less than cooperative in other situations as NYU Law Professor Ryan Goodman points out.

Trump is an unindicted co-conspirator in the case.

Image

It is unclear whether they decided against charging him because of evidentiary failures, legal issues, or practical considerations at this point. But having additional cooperating witnesses certainly wouldn’t hurt.

Boris Epshteyn has been represented by lawyer Todd Blanche in the past. The Guardian’s Hugo Lowell told me that the relationship is now over, and he expects Epshteyn will find a local Arizona lawyer to represent him.” Epshteyn and Trump’s interests are now at odds in the case because Trump is named as an unindicted co-conspirator in the case. They could have waived the conflict if they both wanted him as their lawyer. We don’t know who initiated the change or why.

Others indicted include Mark Meadows, John Eastman, Rudy Giuliani, Jenna Ellis, and Mike Roman, a now familiar cast of characters, along with a slate of fake electors from Arizona. Some of the names remained redacted, but identities could be discerned from information in the indictment. For instance, one of those individuals was referred to as “the Mayor,” which in context seems to be Giuliani.

Former Obama-era Arizona U.S. Attorney Dennis Burke told me there wasn’t a doubt in his mind that Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes has a solid, well-considered investigation and indictment because of the high regard the lead prosecutor handling the case is held in. In a public statement, Mayes said, “I will not allow American democracy to be undermined.”

Trump’s spokesperson had this response:

Image

Trump also moved to dismiss two counts in the Georgia indictment today. He argues that the conduct in counts 15 and 27 violates federal law, and charges can only be brought in federal court. You can read his brief here. Trump cites an 1890 case, In re Looney, for the proposition. It’s a novel theory, to say the least.

The heart of Trump’s argument is that: “Using (which necessarily includes filing) false documents in the jurisdiction of the judiciary of the United States is criminalized by a specific federal statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1001(a)(3).2 3 That statute is designed to protect the federal interest against the use of allegedly false documents in connection with the United States judiciary. The alleged conduct which the state is attempting to prosecute in counts 15 and 27 is addressed by the federal false statement statute and thus jurisdiction is exclusively vested in federal court. As such, the state is without jurisdiction or authority to prosecute President Trump when the plain purpose of doing so is to protect the integrity of federal matters.”

Count 15 involves filing the fake elector documents in federal court in Georgia.

Count 27 involves false statements Trump and John Eastman made in a federal challenge they filed to the election.

This deserves some study, but even if there is merit to Trump’s argument—and that’s a big if; the motion has the feel of a Hail Mary—granting it would have no impact on the RICO charge, and the conduct described in counts 15 and 27 could be offered as proof of the RICO charge. To no one’s surprise, this looks more like a delay tactic than anything else. Trump offers only the 1890 case and an even older Georgia case to support his argument, and neither case discusses this statute and this conduct. We’ll look forward to Fani Willis’ response, which is likely to be very dismissive.

We are still waiting on a gag order ruling in Manhattan.

David Pecker resumes his testimony tomorrow in the catch-and-kill to elect Trump case. He is about to the part of his testimony where the effort to suppress Stormy Daniels’ story begins. Pecker has been clear that his role here began as Trump contemplated running for President and that it was designed to make that happen. He did not engage in catch-and-kill for Trump prior to 2015.

Trump has been notably silent about Pecker, perhaps because of the gag order. Pecker has done well on direct examination but the true proof of how good a witness is comes on cross-examination.

Tomorrow the Supreme Court (finally) takes up the presidential immunity appeal. Monday night, when I previewed the Supreme Court immunity argument, I suggested that the best type of hypothetical for the Special Counsel to use would be one that made it clear to the Justices that a president with absolute immunity for any criminal conduct could act against them too. For instance, a president could order Justices he disagreed with arrested and jailed.

This reminds me of another case. In January of 2012 the Supreme Court decided U.S. v. Jones. The issue was whether the government had to get a search warrant before it could use a GPS device to track a vehicle. Prosecutors reasoned that people who drove on public roads lacked the reasonable expectation of privacy in their movements necessary to implicate their rights against search and seizure under the 4th Amendment. That meant prosecutors didn’t need to get a search warrant before planting the device—getting a search warrant involves convincing a federal judge probable cause exists for the search. That had been the practice for years and many prosecutors who had been following the case avidly thought a win for the government was at hand.

The hypothetical came from Chief Justice Roberts, who asked if prosecutors could place a GPS device on the car of one of the Justices without a search warrant under the government’s theory. That brought it home. Sometimes, the personal impact of these cases needs to be brought home to the Justices. The government lost in Jones, with that hypo, which provoked nervous laughter when it was asked, playing no small part in the decision. Prosecutors have had to get a search warrant to use a GPS tracking device ever since.

In my mind, that hypothetical lost the argument for the government or at least put the nail in its coffin. The hypo hit the Court close to home. They could imagine it happening to them in that moment. Sometimes, the Supreme Court needs to be reminded that the cases they are deciding impact real people, and the best way to do that is to make sure they understand the impact their decisions can have on them.

The lawyer in Jones? That was Michael Dreeben, the former Deputy Solicitor General who will be arguing for the Special Counsel tomorrow. I bet he hasn’t forgotten that moment.

If Donald Trump is permitted to have the broad presidential immunity he claims he is entitled to, all of us, even the Justices, and especially our democracy, will suffer.

We’re in this together,

Joyce





Sunday, April 14, 2024

Will you sign the petition to stop anti-abortion extremists from pushing a nationwide medication abortion ban?


 "R" VOTERS ARE CONSPICUOUSLY UNINFORMED, REFUSE TO RESEARCH 
ISSUE AND SIMPLY EMBRACE DISINFORMATION. 

"R" VOTERS IGNORE THE REST OF THE WORLD!

"R" VOTERS IGNORANCE = FAILURE!

EUROPE DOESN'T HAVE A SIMILAR PROBLEM WITH ABORTION BECAUSE 
THEY PROVIDE EASY ACCESS AND FREE BIRTH CONTROL. 

RED STATES THAT RUSHED TO BAN ABORTION HAVE HIGH MATERNAL 
& INFANT MORTALITY, FAILED TO PROVIDE FAMILY LEAVE OR PRE-NATAL 
CARE, FAIL TO PROVIDE SCREENING FOR CONGENITAL SYPHILIS and MUCH ELSE.


IT'S TIME FOR UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE!



LeftNet


Once again, our rights and bodily autonomy are in the hands of the right-wing-packed Supreme Court. The Supreme Court has recently heard oral arguments on access to mifepristone–the FDA-approved, safe, and effective abortion pill.1 And two of the court's most conservative, anti-abortion judges referenced the Comstock Act, a 150-year-old, sexist, invasive, and dormant law—that is, tragically, still on the books—in their questions, a sign that they are looking for opportunities to turn back the clock a century and a half.2

This law could be the way MAGA bans abortion. Will you sign the petition to demand that the Comstock Act be repealed NOW?

This is the same Supreme Court that overturned Roe v. Wade just two years ago. And although there have been reports of justices seeming skeptical about restricting access to mifepristone, we should be alarmed: Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas referenced the Comstock Act of 1873 during the oral arguments.3

The Comstock Act—if enforced—is a law that prohibits the mailing of contraceptives through the mail.4 If the Republican Party wins the presidency this November, Donald Trump could enforce this law, which is still on the books—and therefore restrict access to medication abortion as well as other contraceptives. That's right: It's a back door to an abortion ban—as well as an attack on birth control, which the right wing has its targets set on—and the Supreme Court is handing Donald Trump the key. We need to act now, while we can, to make sure we aren't subject to the whims of an ancient, sexist law, a maniacal president, and a regressive Supreme Court.

Will you sign the petition demanding that the Comstock Act be repealed NOW?

Sign the Petition

Anti-abortion extremists are willing to go to any length to strip away our rights and access to reproductive health. From Roe v. Wade to IVF to mifepristone, the right wing will stop at nothing to implement a nationwide abortion ban.

The Comstock Act states that "every article or thing designed, adapted, or intended for producing abortion" is "nonmailable." Medication abortion accounted for 63% of all abortion care in 2023.5

The act was also an obstacle to birth control for many years—something that many conservatives want to attack next. Enforcing the Comstock Act would restrict millions of people from getting the crucial health care they need. Add your name to demand that the Comstock Act be repealed now!

Supreme Court justices' and anti-abortion extremists' referencing of this law is dangerous on various levels. It has been reported that these extremists and Trump allies are planning to enforce this law if Donald Trump becomes president again. One of the leaders behind the Texas abortion ban said, "We don’t need a federal ban when we have Comstock on the books" and that Trump should keep his mouth shut about Comstock until after the election.6

Anti-abortion extremists are working behind the scenes and with the right-wing-backed court on their side. We have to come together to spread the word about these dangerous threats to our reproductive rights and demand that those in power take action NOW to stop these extremists from using the Comstock Act, before it's too late.

Sign the petition now to demand that the Comstock Act be repealed, and share it with three friends!

Thanks for all you do.

–MoveOn

P.S. It’s going to take all of us to come together and defeat MAGA to win the House, Senate, and White House in 2024. Sign up today to join millions of MoveOn members organizing to turn out voters in key battleground states and districts.

Sources:

  1. "The Abortion Pill Case: What's at Stake and What's Next," The New York Times, March 25, 2024
    https://www.nytimes.com/article/supreme-court-abortion-pill-ruling.html
  2. "Why a 19th-century law matters in the Supreme Court abortion pill fight," Axios, March 26, 2024
    https://www.axios.com/2024/03/26/supreme-court-abortion-pill-case-comstock-act
  3. "Most Supreme Court Justices Seem Skeptical of Effort to Curtail Abortion Pill Access," The New York Times, March 28, 2024
    https://www.nytimes.com/live/2024/03/26/us/abortion-pill-supreme-court
  4. "Why a 19th-century law matters in the Supreme Court abortion pill fight," Axios, March 26, 2024
    https://www.axios.com/2024/03/26/supreme-court-abortion-pill-case-comstock-act
  5. "Medication Abortion Accounted for 63% of All US Abortions in 2023—An Increase from 53% in 2020," Guttmacher Institute, March 19, 2024
    https://www.guttmacher.org/2024/03/medication-abortion-accounted-63-all-us-abortions-2023-increase-53-2020
  6. "Trump Allies Plan New Sweeping Abortion Restrictions," The New York Times, February 17, 2024
    https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/17/us/politics/trump-allies-abortion-restrictions.html

PAID FOR BY MOVEON.ORG POLITICAL ACTION, http://pol.moveon.org/. Not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee.

Email us: team@leftnet.org



Rates of congenital syphilis are skyrocketing in the US. Here's why
CONGENITAL SYPHILIS

Congenital syphilis
CONGENITAL SYPHILIS


Congenital Syphilis – CDC Fact Sheet
CDC CONGENITAL SYPHILIS

Thursday, March 28, 2024

COMMON DREAMS: Top News: Could Taxing the Rich Lift Biden? CARBON CAPTURE IS A SCAM! NEIL CHATTERJEE FAILED FERC - QUESTION THIS!

 

DON'T FORGET TO READ THE OPINIONS ON THE LINK BELOW!








Tuesday Afternoon Updates – Error 404: President Not Found

                                                                                                                                            ...