Showing posts with label WILDERNESS WATCH. Show all posts
Showing posts with label WILDERNESS WATCH. Show all posts

Thursday, April 4, 2024

Poison has no place in the Strawberry Mountain Wilderness

 
ROTENONE WILL KILL ALL AQUATIC LIFE! 

Please read and gather the FACTS about the WILDNERNESS ECOSYSTEM and add 
your comments.

Columbia spotted frog by Chloe and Trevor Van Loon via iNaturalist

Speak up by April 11 to keep poison out of the Strawberry Mountain Wilderness

We need you to speak up for the Strawberry Mountain Wilderness in eastern Oregon to stop yet another project that would poison a lake and a few miles of streams with rotenone! This rugged, high elevation Wilderness was one of the original 54 Wilderness areas designated by the 1964 Wilderness Act. Today, its 69,350 acres protect alpine lakes, headwater streams, and countless native species.

The U.S. Forest Service has released a Minimum Requirements Decision Guide (MRDG) on a plan to poison High Lake and 1.5 miles of Lake Creek above Lake Creek Falls within the Strawberry Mountain Wilderness. And, rather than undertake the required environmental analysis and fulfill its obligation to properly administer this Wilderness, the Forest Service has passed the decision on to the Bonneville Power Administration, an agency with zero Wilderness expertise. We need you to speak up by April 11.

The original project proposal called for aerially spraying rotenone—a pesticide, insecticide, and piscicide—from a helicopter, in addition to drip station applications of the poison to eradicate brook trout in historically fishless waters and “replace the fishery with sterile rainbow trout” that “will be actively managed.”

While we appreciate that the agency has dropped the use of a helicopter to carry out this activity, it has ignored our calls to reject the proposal outright. Instead, an inflatable motorboat and a gas pump, both prohibited by the Wilderness Act, would be used to poison High Lake over the course of anywhere from one to three years, with the area closed to the public for two weeks a year. Wilderness Watch objects to both the use of poison in Wilderness along with the methods of application.

The project’s purported purpose is to kill brook trout, which compete and hybridize with native bull trout residing downstream. But rotenone will poison and kill other aquatic life, including possibly tadpoles of Columbian spotted frogs, a candidate species for Endangered Species Act listing. And rotenone’s broader impacts on the environment are not fully understood. Further, the section to be poisoned is above bull trout habitat, and the lower reaches also contain nonnative fish.

Additionally, it is unclear from the latest proposal whether the naturally fishless waters will be be restocked with fish as originally called for.

The Strawberry Mountain Wilderness is no place for poisons or motorboats, nor is it a place for managers to play God with species and habitat manipulation. The Wilderness Act was passed precisely to rein in the propensity of managers to want to control nature.

Destroying native species and damaging Wilderness ecosystems isn’t the answer for protecting native trout. Moreover, intensive intervention and manipulation projects like this are fundamentally at odds with the Forest Service’s mandate to preserve wilderness character. The appropriate wilderness response to previously introduced fish in these waters is to let nature take its course as the Wilderness Act prescribes, but if fish are to be removed, it must be done without motors and poisons. And, under no conditions should other fish be stocked in these historically fishless waters.

These activities could not be more antithetical to the concept of Wilderness. And unfortunately, this poisoning project in the Strawberry Mountain Wilderness is just one of an increasing number of proposed projects around the country where managers want to create their desired conditions rather than protect wild nature. Please speak up by April 11!

The Bonneville Power Administration is accepting public comments here: https://publiccomments.bpa.gov/CommentEntry.aspx?ID=507


Please write in your own words, and personalize your comments if you can, but try to include the following points:

I oppose the Upper Malheur Brook Trout Removal Project, which impacts the Strawberry Mountain Wilderness.

The Forest Service needs to fulfill its obligation to properly administer this Wilderness by completing a wilderness-specific environmental impact statement (EIS) rather than passing the decision to the Bonneville Power Administration—an agency without wilderness expertise or a statutory mandate to preserve wilderness. The EIS must demonstrate Wilderness Act compliance, analyze impacts to the entire aquatic ecosystem, and rigorously explore alternatives to this ecosystem manipulation and motorized use plan, including a no-action alternative reviewed through a Wilderness Act lens.

High Lake and Lake Creek are rich aquatic ecosystems filled with life. Rotenone will poison and kill other aquatic life, including possibly tadpoles of Columbian spotted frogs, a candidate species for Endangered Species Act listing, and rotenone’s broader impacts on the environment are not fully understood. Further, rotenone poisoning poses risks to downstream bull trout habitat, and the lower reaches also contain nonnative fish that will continue to compete with bull trout even if fish are successfully eradicated from upstream wilderness waters.

The plan includes activities prohibited by the Wilderness Act, including a motorboat and a gas pump for poisoning the lake. These activities could continue for anywhere from one to three years, and include yearly two-week closures.

I urge Bonneville Power and the Forest Service to say NO to this proposal to degrade the Strawberry Mountain Wilderness with motorboats and poison. The appropriate wilderness response to the presence of fish that were introduced a century ago is to let nature takes its course as the Wilderness Act prescribes. If efforts are made to remove the fish, they must be done without motors and poisons. Under no conditions should other fish be placed in this historically fishless area, and if the agencies know this is being considered, it must be disclosed to the public.

Thank you for considering my comments.

TAKE ACTION

 Help us protect Wilderness around the country. A generous member has pledged to DOUBLE all first-time donations up to $30,000 this year.

DONATE
 

We're celebrating 60 years of the Wilderness Act! Learn more in "Wilderness At 60: A Brief Overview."

Share

Photo: Columbia spotted frog by Chloe and Trevor Van Loon via iNaturalist 

P.O. Box 9175  |  Missoula, MT 59807  |  406.542.2048  |  wildernesswatch.org




Thursday, June 2, 2022

Groups challenge massive poisoning of Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness



Helicopter-assisted poisoning and fish farming have no place in Wilderness

Wilderness Watch, along with allies, has filed a formal Objection against the Buffalo Creek Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout Conservation Project, a Montana Department of Fish, Wildlife, and Parks proposal to poison 45.5 miles of Buffalo Creek, plus 11 lakes in the Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness in Montana, part of the famed Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. The Forest Service recently issued a draft decision notice approving the project with an August 2022 start date, despite a 2021 federal court order requiring the Forest Service to postpone immediate implementation of a nearly identical project in the Scapegoat Wilderness in Montana.

The State’s goal is to kill the rainbow trout it has been stocking in the project area since the 1930s, and replace them with Yellowstone cutthroat trout. Neither species existed in the project area historically. The plan involves massive amounts of helicopter and motorized equipment use—for up to a decade—in addition to spreading hundreds of gallons of the poison rotenone, which kills all gill-breathing organisms.

The Forest Service will authorize 99 helicopter landings in Wilderness to deliver supplies and to aerial spray rotenone in meadow areas, plus the use of motorboats and gas-powered generators, and the placement of various installations. Even more troubling is the state’s plan to again fill these naturally fishless lakes and streams with fish, despite the impacts fish stocking has on the area’s native amphibians and other aquatic biota by introducing these non-native predators.

While we support efforts to conserve Yellowstone cutthroat trout, those efforts need to focus on the trout’s native waters. Destroying native species and damaging naturally fishless ecosystems isn’t the answer for protecting native trout. Moreover, intensive intervention and manipulation projects like this are fundamentally at odds with the Forest Service’s mandate to preserve wilderness character, and raise concerning questions over the long-term viability of Wilderness. The appropriate wilderness response to previously-introduced fish in these waters is to let nature take its course as the Wilderness Act prescribes, but if fish are to be removed, it must be done without motors and poisons. Under no conditions should other fish be stocked in this historically fishless area.

Read our Objection.

DONATE

Help us protect the Absaroka-Beartooth and Wilderness around the country. All first-time donations matched by a generous member in Alaska.

Follow Us

Photo: Buffalo Plateau on the border of Yellowstone National Park and the Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness. The east side of the plateau drains into Buffalo Creek. Photo by Howie Wolke.


P.O. Box 9175  |  Missoula, MT 59807  |  wildernesswatch.org  |  DONATE

 






Wednesday, May 11, 2022

Unprecedented—Jimmy Carter calls on court to protect Izembek Wilderness



Izembek is still at risk, but the fight isn’t over

As you may recall, in a devastating legal opinion this past March, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upended decades of successful efforts, including three prior court opinions, protecting the Izembek Wilderness from road construction. Former Interior Secretary Sally Jewell made the right decision back in 2013 to protect Izembek when she rejected the proposed road. During the Trump administration, Interior did an about-face, approving not one, but two, closed-door land exchanges needed for road construction. The federal district court ruled in our favor when we challenged the agreements. The Trump administration appealed those rulings that protected Izembek from the road, and disappointingly, the Biden administration continued that appeal. The recent 2-1 decision in the Ninth Circuit reversed the good district court decisions.

Now we’ve requested an en banc, or full-court, hearing in the Ninth Circuit. Our petition for this rehearing is being supported by former President Jimmy Carter, who signed into law the legislation that protects Izembek and other wild public lands throughout Alaska. Former Dept. of Interior Secretary Bruce Babbitt, former Interior Solicitor John Leshy, and a group of law professors have also filed amicus briefs in support of our en banc petition.

A road bisecting the internationally-renowned Izembek National Wildlife Refuge and Wilderness would be catastrophic. Secretary of Interior Deb Haaland must reverse the Biden’s administration’s current misguided course, and instead defend and protect Izembek as Congress intended and as Americans deserve. Read more in an op-ed by Fran Mauer, our Alaska representative:

Trustees for Alaska represents Wilderness Watch and eight other groups in the lawsuit.

DONATE

Help us protect Izembek and Wilderness around the country. All first-time donations matched by a generous member in Alaska.

Follow Us

Photo: Kristine Sowl/USFWS 

P.O. Box 9175  |  Missoula, MT 59807  |  wildernesswatch.org  |  DONATE





Tuesday, May 3, 2022

We have good news for the Hoover Wilderness!

 


Wilderness and wildlife, Yes! Cows, No.

On April 19, the Forest Service (FS) issued a good decision to keep part of the Hoover Wilderness in California closed to cattle grazing, in part due to pressure from Wilderness Watch and our members and supporters. The area in the "Bridgeport Southwest Rangeland Project" had been closed to livestock grazing for more than a decade, after domestic sheep were removed to protect state and federally endangered Sierra bighorn sheep. In 2018, the FS proposed re-opening part of the Hoover Wilderness to cattle grazing.

That’s when Wilderness Watch—and so many of you—stepped in. In reaching his decision to not issue grazing permits for the area, Forest Service district ranger David Risley acknowledged that early in the process they received more than 3,500 letters from from “a campaign sponsored by a wilderness organization,” and added that in response to the environmental assessment, they received “thousands” of comments from people “responding to an outreach by Wilderness Watch.” Thank you for weighing in!

Bordering Yosemite National Park along the Pacific Crest and falling away to the Great Basin to the east, the Hoover Wilderness is a spectacular piece of the Sierra Nevada range in California. First established as a Primitive area in 1931, and then a Wild area in 1957, the Hoover Wilderness was officially designated as one of our first Wilderness areas in 1964, the year the Wilderness Act was signed into law. 

Re-opening this area to cows would have created substantial impacts to the Hoover Wilderness, its watersheds, sage-grouse, and other native wildlife. As the decision properly stated, “The improved conditions across this project area that has occurred over the last 10-20 years and the potential for continued improvement outweighs the benefit that would arise from authorizing cattle….”

A big thank you to all of you who sent more than 5,000 public comments urging the Forest Service to drop this grazing proposal. And to district ranger Risley for saying no to cattle and sheep in this part of the Hoover Wilderness. It’s all too rare when the agency favors wildlife and Wilderness over domestic cows and sheep.

DONATE

Help us protect the Hoover and Wilderness around the country. All first-time donations matched by a generous member in Alaska.

Follow Us

Photo: Scrubhiker via Flickr

P.O. Box 9175  |  Missoula, MT 59807  |  wildernesswatch.org  |  DONATE





Wednesday, April 27, 2022

Urge Secretary Haaland to Protect the Izembek Wilderness

 


Share This

Izembek Wilderness, Alaska

On April 20, U.S. Secretary of Interior Deb Haaland visited the native village of King Cove, Alaska, near the Izembek National Wildlife Refuge and Wilderness. Sec. Haaland was accompanied by Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK), Gov. Mike Dunleavy (R-AK), and other proponents who want to build a road through the heart of the Izembek Wilderness to connect King Cove with the community of Cold Bay, which has a large airport runway. 

This issue has gone on for years. It began in the 1980s when commercial fishing interests in King Cove proposed a road through the Wilderness in order to transport fresh fish to the all-season air strip at Cold Bay. More recently, the media has focused on the residents of King Cove who want the road, claiming it is necessary for medevac emergencies, rather than risk transporting them by water in rough weather.

Former Interior Secretary Sally Jewell made the right decision in 2013 to protect Izembek and deny the road proposal. Jewell also requested that the Corps of Engineers analyze non-road alternatives. A subsequent 2015 report by the Corps of Engineers determined the most reliable method of transport during inclement weather to be a marine ferry for transport from King Cove and break-water/dock improvements at Cold Bay. During storms, a road would be impassible due to blowing snow and avalanche risk. This non-road alternative could be implemented using infrastructure funds recently passed by Congress.

During the Trump administration, Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke approved a land exchange to permit the road (the courts rejected that), and then the next Trump administration Interior Secretary, David Bernhardt, approved another land exchange to allow the road (still in court).

While Secretary Haaland made no public comments nor answered any reporters’ questions during her recent visit, she was only surrounded by road proponents.  Wilderness advocates were not invited. Your help is needed now to let Secretary Haaland know that many people want to see the Izembek Wilderness protected from the road-building scheme.

Please email Secretary Haaland soon and let her know you support protecting the Izembek Wilderness from the road-building scheme. Urge her to support a non-road alternative such as marine ferry with break-water and dock improvements at Cold Bay.  

Take action
 

Learn more about this issue by watching our webinar, “Izembek: World-Class Wilderness or Highway?"

 

Help us protect Izembek and Wilderness around the country. All first-time donations matched by a generous member in Alaska!

DONATE

Follow Us



Photo: Kristine Sowl/USFWS

P.O. Box 9175  |  Missoula, MT 59807  |  wildernesswatch.org  |  DONATE





Idaho hunters killed 12 newborn wolf pups and got paid

                                                                                                                                            ...