Showing posts with label ENERGY TRANSITION. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ENERGY TRANSITION. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 2, 2024

COMMON DREAMS: Climate Advocates 'Confident' in Victory as Shell Appeals Landmark Ruling

 

Climate Advocates 'Confident' in Victory as Shell Appeals Landmark Ruling

Campaigners described the company’s appeal as “a desperate attempt at justifying more oil and gas extraction.”

Shell appealed a case on Tuesday at The Hague that ordered the fossil fuel giant to drastically cut its greenhouse gas emissions.

A Dutch court ordered the company in 2021 to reduce its carbon emissions by 45% by 2030. Shell is arguing that customers will turn to other fuel suppliers if it obeys the order.

"This case has no legal basis," Shell's lawyer Daan Lunsingh Scheurleer told the court. "It obstructs the role that Shell can and wants to play in the energy transition."

"Oil and gas will play an important role in both the security of supply and affordability during the energy transition," he claimed.

Friends of the Earth Netherlands, which brought the case against Shell, said the "scientific basis" for its case has "only solidified" since the initial ruling.

"I am confident that we can once again convince the judges that Shell needs to act in line with international climate agreements," the group's lawyer Roger Cox said.

The court order affects the company as a whole, not just its operations in the Netherlands. A verdict on the appeal is expected later this year.

"Shell aims to reduce the carbon intensity of products it sells by 15-20% by 2030 from a 2016 baseline after watering down the target in March," Reutersreports. "Shell has an 'ambition' to reduce customer emissions from the use of its oil products by 15-20% by 2030 compared with 2021. Shell also aims to become a 'net zero' emissions company by 2050."

A report from last year found Shell knew about the impacts of burning fossil fuels much earlier than previously known.

SHELL APPEAL


Sunday, November 27, 2022

FOCUS: Bill McKibben | The Tyranny of Inertia

 

 

Reader Supported News
27 November 22

Live on the homepage now!
Reader Supported News

A RUDE AWAKENING ON DONATIONS | Yesterday’s fundraising inspiration was to try to underscore the importance of a strong finish. The donations stopped completely. It was as though we hit a brick wall. Back in crisis mode.
Marc Ash • Founder, Reader Supported News

Sure, I'll make a donation!

 

Bill McKibben. (photo: StoryWorkz)
FOCUS: Bill McKibben | The Tyranny of Inertia
Bill McKibben, Bill McKibben's Substack
McKibben writes: "I've actually been home from Egypt for a couple of days, so this final dispatch comes in part from talking to people still in the conference center at Sharm El-Sheikh where—with utter predictability—talks went into 24 hours of overtime before finally concluding in the early morning hours Sunday."


Egypt Dispatch 6: Getting something this big done is...hard

I’ve actually been home from Egypt for a couple of days, so this final dispatch comes in part from talking to people still in the conference center at Sharm El-Sheikh where—with utter predictability—talks went into 24 hours of overtime before finally concluding in the early morning hours Sunday.

The talks produced one real success: civil society had focused on getting the rich nations to agree to a ‘loss and damage’ fund, and at the last minute they did just that. It was a triumph for movement organizers from the global south—for groups like the Climate Action Network—that made the issue the unrelenting focus of their efforts in the lead-up to this COP, and for good reason: as Reuters reported

55 vulnerable countries estimated their combined climate-linked losses over the last two decades totalled $525 billion, or 20% of their collective GDP. Some research suggests that by 2030 such losses could reach $580 billion per year.

Read those numbers again—they are astonishing (a fifth of GDP!) and there is no doubt where justice lies: the iron law of global warming is, as always, those who did the least to cause it suffer first and most.

But it wasn’t an unalloyed triumph. Setting up a fund and filling it with money are two different things, and the second task will be harder. So far a handful of the usual suspects (Scandanavia, Japan) have contributed amounts in the tens of millions of dollars. I do not think it will be easy to find tens or hundreds of billions of dollars—not, at least, from the government I know best. The U.S. Congress is going to be in divided hands; I think it will be simple for Kevin McCarthy to block progress here and get in some demagogic licks in the process, especially since China—officially a ‘developing country’—isn’t obligated to take part in the new effort. There may be other sources of money (a tax on Big Oil profits? a modest tax on all financial transactions?) but none of these will be easy; pundits are hailing the Loss and Damage agreement as a way to ‘rebuild trust’ between north and south, but it’s also possible it will be one more ongoing source of rancor.

The other cost was focus. It seems almost impossible to get these COPs to concentrate on more than one thing at a time. Last year in Glasgow there was a big push to get banks and financial institutions to take climate change seriously—the jet parking lot at Glasgow Airport was filled with planes from the planet’s biggest capitalists—and so we got the Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero. But in the course of the year GFANZ’s aspirations began to wither; very few of the banks have managed to even stop funding coal-fired power, which is the most obvious first step. The big American banks threatened to walk away this summer when it appeared GFANZ rules might restrict their ability to keep financing fossil fuel expansion (something that climate science has said clearly and repeatedly should be verboten), and so…the rules were changed. Republican attorneys general have mounted a red-state push to keep the banks on board with Big Oil, and they’ve met with little resistance from boardrooms. And so on—there was hardly a peep about any of this in Egypt, which I fear teaches the rich and powerful a lesson: if you say the right things when the spotlight is bright, your problems might go away.

And the bank story is emblematic. With the focus on loss and damage, this year’s COP did not manage to push harder for new climate targets, or even to call for an (undated) “phase out” of fossil fuel—which, after all, is what is required to have some hope of bringing climate change under control.

If this were a normal political problem, that might be okay: slow but steady progress counts. But this—almost uniquely for world leaders—is a timed test. Every year brings us 12 months further into the new geological epoch we’re creating. As we come out of Sharm el-Sheikh we’re still headed for a world nearly three degrees Celsius warmer.

What I’m trying to say is: inertia is becoming an enormous factor. Because Big Oil cost us three decades, we have to move with unheard-of speed. As Vaclav Smil has pointed out, big energy transitions (wood to coal, say) normally play out over a century. Since physics is allowing us a decade or two instead, we have to constantly goose this process. Movements have done a good job—without them we’d be nowhere—but we’re not managing to push things fast enough. Renewable energy is cheap enough that we could plausibly roll it out with real speed, but vested interest stands in the way, and without endless pressure we’ll never build up the necessary head of steam.

The tactic of the bad guys is delay, and delay is incredibly easy to achieve; a body at rest stays at rest. Our job is acceleration, and that’s not happening, at least at the pace that’s required. We’re starting to run out of years, so we best make the next one count.

Other news from the world of climate and energy:

Kate Aronoff, not for the first time, cuts through the news to get at the core. She describes the “effective altruism” movement funded by disgraced crypto financier Sam Bankman-Fried:

“Rich makes right” is not exactly revolutionary stuff. “Doing good by doing well” has been a long-held mantra of Davos types spewing TED-talkish bromides about wanting to make the world a better, greener place. “The laws of accumulation will be left free; the laws of distribution free. Individualism will continue,” steel magnate Andrew Carnegie wrote of his class’s charitable giving in 1899, “but the millionaire will be but a trustee for the poor; entrusted for a season with a great part of the increased wealth of the community, but administering it for the community far better than it could or would have done for itself.” Bizarrely, though, E.A. has been successfully marketed as new and innovative, mostly by dint of its proximity to tech.

+A new effort called Fossil Free Zones was launched in the waning days of the COP, with organizers highlighting “places that do not burn or extract fossil fuels. The framework aims to highlight the pioneers of ending fossil fuels and inspire others to follow in their footsteps. 250 Fossil Free Zones in 30 countries have already been identified,” ranging from individual homes to Antarctica, a “fossil-extraction-free continent.”

+The irreplaceable Emily Atkin makes the climate case against one Elon Musk. Yes, he’s brought us Tesla, but as she makes clear there’s another side to the ledger. His rocket company spews methane, and

By advocating for Republicans, Musk is using his massive influence as the world’s richest man to empower a party owned by the fossil fuel industry. He is advocating for political leadership that would seek not only reverse existing climate policy, but pass new policy ensuring new fossil fuel infrastructure for decades to come. There would be no bigger climate negative than this.

Not only that, but screwing up Twitter “has put this critical climate communication, education and advocacy platform at risk of failure. After mass layoffs and resignations, a former Twitter employee told The Washington Post Thursday that at least six critical systems that keep the site functioning no longer have any engineers.Climate disinformation has also increased on the platform since Musk took over,” which is something I’ve noticed too.

+A fascinating new study from Pew tracks the intersection between religious and environmental concern:

the survey finds that highly religious Americans (those who say they pray each day, regularly attend religious services and consider religion very important in their lives) are far less likely than other U.S. adults to express concern about warming temperatures around the globe.

To which one can only say, Sigh.



READ MORE

 

Contribute to RSN

Follow us on facebook and twitter!

Update My Monthly Donation

PO Box 2043 / Citrus Heights, CA 95611






Wednesday, November 23, 2022

FOCUS: David Wallace-Wells | The Coldhearted Carbon Math

 

Reader Supported News
22 November 22

Live on the homepage now!
Reader Supported News

A $100 DONATION WOULD DO WONDERS RIGHT NOW — Nothing does more to stop a slide than a badly needed triple digit donation. We sincerely understand that not all of our Reader-Supporters can manage that but hopefully a few can. Respectfully,
Marc Ash • Founder, Reader Supported News

Sure, I'll make a donation!

 

Pollution from a factory. (photo: Science Focus)
FOCUS: David Wallace-Wells | The Coldhearted Carbon Math
David Wallace-Wells, The New York Times
Wallace-Wells writes: "Last November in Glasgow, the annual United Nations climate conference ended with its president, Alok Sharma, declaring that the global goal of keeping warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius had been just barely kept alive. 'Its pulse is weak,' he said."


Last November in Glasgow, the annual United Nations climate conference ended with its president, Alok Sharma, declaring that the global goal of keeping warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius had been just barely kept alive. “Its pulse is weak,” he said.

This week in Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt, delegates reconvened for COP27, this year’s conference, amid a flurry of confident assertions that the same goal — which has energized and mobilized a global generation of activists and provides the conventional standard for judging progress on emissions — was now dead.

“Say goodbye to 1.5° C,” The Economist intoned on a cover this month, in an edition that called climate adaptation “the challenge of our age” and also raised the specter of cooling the planet with geoengineering. With an image of the flooded Cologne Cathedral — repurposed from a 1986 issue warning of a coming “Klima-Katastrophe” — the November cover of Der Spiegel announced that the target would be missed and advised, grimly: “Save yourself, those who can.” The United Nations secretary general António Guterres, who has spent the past few years raising the rhetorical stakes, declared on Monday that “we are on a highway to climate hell with our foot still on the accelerator.”

This kind of rhetoric, designed to focus attention and clarify the stakes of inaction, can also make things murky. What is the line between climate danger and climate disaster? Or between climate normal and climate disruption, and climate catastrophe and climate apocalypse? Is “climate hell” what awaits us past 1.5 degrees above preindustrial levels, or past 2.0 degrees, or at the level the U.N. expects the world’s current policy commitments to take us this century, 2.6 degrees?

The language is useful as a reminder of the grim impacts to come, but less so as a measure of progress — how much has been done, how far short we are falling, and how much faster we might have to move to reach our temperature targets. For that, we have a much more coldhearted standard: the carbon math, which tells us how much the world is emitting, how much more it can produce while retaining a decent chance of a particular temperature threshold and, therefore, how plausible or implausible each threshold really is.

In 2012, the author Bill McKibben wrote that the math of warming was already “terrifying.” At the time, he was tabulating our emissions against a temperature target of 2.0 degrees Celsius. A few years later, alongside that 2.0-degree goal, the more ambitious target of 1.5 degrees was consecrated in the Paris agreement — the result of several decades of agitation and protest by the world’s most vulnerable countries, which found the prospect of 2.0 degrees intolerable.

We can put much less carbon in the atmosphere to have a chance of 1.5 degrees warming than we could if we were aiming for 2.0 degrees — a principle called the carbon budget, though significant uncertainties surround any estimate of it. And the world has spent the years since Paris setting new emissions records rather than bending the curve downward. There has been reason for optimism and cause for despair over those years, but the math is not a matter of mood or of vibes. It is much more like an hourglass, with 50 gigatons of sand falling through the neck each year.

So what does that math look like now, as world leaders parade across the stage in Egypt, a two-week pageant of taking this seriously? There are at least two ways of looking at the numbers. The first, captured powerfully in the International Energy Agency’s recent World Energy Outlook 2022 report, paints a relatively rosy picture of transformational momentum in the energy transition — things are moving quite fast, indeed faster than most predicted a short time ago, if not quite fast enough to make the Paris targets all that likely. The second, contained in the U.N. Environmental Program’s emissions gap report released just before the conference began, suggests that no matter the speed, the deadlines are uncomfortably close already.

Both sets of numbers are legit. Which means you can tell different stories about the present state of climate action depending on your perspective, inclination, point of ideological emphasis or even mood. In an essay I wrote in October, I emphasized the glass-half-full side of the equation — that the speed of the energy transition meant some of the scariest climate futures (4.0 or 5.0 degrees Celsius of warming by the end of the century) no longer seem nearly as plausible as they did just a few years ago. The recent I.E.A. report illustrates that relative optimism, predicting that fossil fuel use will peak this decade, declaring that the energy crisis sparked by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has accelerated rather than decelerated the global transition, and finding that global rollout of wind and solar is exceeding earlier projections. Which is all to say: The world is already in the midst of a pretty breakneck green transition, which makes the pathway to 1.5 degrees, the report finds, “narrow but achievable.”

But the glass is also half empty. If there is a significant breakthrough at this conference it is much less likely to be about bending emissions curves and accelerating decarbonization than it is to be about dealing with a world ravaged by climate impacts — establishing some form of institutionalized climate finance for the vulnerable and underresourced nations of the developing world, which have done the least to create the problems they face now and in the decades ahead. These nations are focusing on forms of climate reparations because they are convinced that dangerous disruption is inevitable. Indeed, they are here already, with more and more scientists expressing open fear at the intensity of today’s impact and worrying about what unexpected transformations may await at 1.5 degrees or just above.

That level of warming, and the rate of decarbonization required to achieve it, has provided the architecture for nearly all global ambition undertaken over the past half decade. And how plausible is it in the end? To give the world a 66 percent chance of limiting warming to 1.5 degrees, conventional climate science suggests a carbon budget of 280 gigatons — just seven years of current emissions. Even in its rosy report, the I.E.A. projects that we won’t even reach a peak until later this decade, which means that for much of the next seven years we should expect to be emitting more carbon than we are today. Possibly, the turn could come even later: The I.E.A.’s chief, Fatih Birol, said, “We now see a peak around 2030 for all fossil fuels,” but the projected decline is slow thereafter, with total fossil fuel use not dropping to around 2010 levels until after 2050 in its “stated policies” scenario.

And while cutting emissions more aggressively now would mean more time to ultimately get all the way to zero emissions, what that requires in the short term already looks daunting.

For a 66 percent chance of limiting warming to 2.0 degrees, there is a longer timeline than for the 1.5 target but not much longer; that full carbon budget would be exhausted in 26 years of current emissions. From now, emissions would have to drop globally by 5 percent every year, still a much faster drop than has ever been engineered globally in any year by anything but the Covid-19 pandemic. This is why the climate scientist Glen Peters often says, cheekily, that 1.5 degrees may be impossible and 2.0 degrees only extremely hard, with 2.5 degrees, relatively speaking, “a walk in the park.”

When you look at charts plotting climate promises made by the nations of the world, they tell a relatively reassuring story, with Climate Action Tracker’s analysis suggesting that, if fully carried out, those promises could deliver a global temperature rise below 2.0 degrees, with a central estimate landing at 1.8 degrees.

But those headline promises paper over an enormous amount of sketchy accounting. A separate Climate Action Tracker analysis of 37 countries and the European Union, which account for the vast majority of world emissions combined, finds that none have a climate policy even “compatible” with a 1.5-degree goal. According to the Land Gap report released Nov. 1, global climate pledges by countries require reforestation and other sequestration measures taking up more land than the entire United States — indeed, require using as much land to sequester carbon as is used to produce all the world’s croplands today. The world’s governments are planning twice as much fossil fuel development as would be consistent with 1.5-degree goals, and 93 percent of corporations with net-zero pledges are off track to meet them.

For decades, those worrying about the geopolitics of climate change would often drift into debates about possible enforcement mechanisms, worrying that nations would be simply unwilling to move on their own. The world has changed more recently, with a moralistic model of decarbonization as a necessary burden giving way to a green energy arms race defined by new competition and rivalry. Even so, ambition is woefully lagging, and in a world full of climate promises without any meaningful leadership for carbon-based sanctions, enforcement looks less like planetary governance forcing countries and corporations to move faster than like finding ways to hold them to their promises.

That is the premise of a report delivered to the secretary general in Egypt this week that pointed squarely at the problem of climate hypocrisy — and the delusion that promises and good intentions could substitute for good math.

The greenwashing report, focused on private sector pledges, outlines 10 gold standards, including that companies should not be able to describe themselves as “net-zero-aligned” while continuing to invest in fossil fuels of any kind, buy cheap carbon credits that don’t stand up to independent scrutiny, only reduce the intensity of their work and not the absolute emissions produced by it, and lobby against climate action or participate only in voluntary disclosure protocols rather than more transparent regulatory frameworks.

“You walk down the street, and we have oil and gas companies saying, ‘Guess what. We’re net zero. We’re carbon neutral,’ whatever,” said Catherine McKenna, a former environment minister of Canada and the current chair of the group that wrote the report. “The problem is everyone’s making announcements, there’s billboards, there’s all these things out there. And if you’re a regular person, you’re like, ‘I don’t know. Is that true or not?’”

Whether the United Nations builds a true oversight program for net-zero pledges, as is called for in the report, is an open question, but, McKenna said, “we do need to move to a more rigorous structure for sure.”

“And that goes for governments too,” she went on. “They need to actually not just have targets. They need to actually be having policies that are going to help them reach those targets. And then they’re going to have to be more ambitious,” she said. “You have to be more ambitious.”

READ MORE

 

Contribute to RSN

Follow us on facebook and twitter!

Update My Monthly Donation

PO Box 2043 / Citrus Heights, CA 95611






Idaho hunters killed 12 newborn wolf pups and got paid

                                                                                                                                            ...