POLITICO Massachusetts Playbook: Wu’s housing play

 

View in browser   BY JENNIFER SMITH Presented by National Grid PLANS ARE USELESS, PLANNING IS INDISPENSABLE — Boston’s development community is recalibrating after a week of rapid-fire announcements that set the stage and the stakes for Mayor Michelle Wu’s housing policies. Brian Golden, the longest-serving director of the Boston Planning and Development Agency, announced his resignation last week. A Walsh administration appointee, Golden oversaw a substantial modernization of the beleaguered BPDA, which controls some 13 million square feet of real estate in the city, as well as a shift toward long-term planning, not just fast-paced construction. But those changes are still considered, by some, to be more of a rebrand than true reform. That includes Wu, who ran for mayor with plans to “abolish” the agency, which has been criticized for a history of messy bookkeeping, opaque processes and aggressive use of its powers that predated Golden. And she pledged to separate city planning from developers’ project approvals. Now HUD alum Arthur Jemison is coming in as Wu’s chief of planning to shake things up. Here’s where it gets tricky: Jemison is also expected to be appointed as the BPDA’s new director in May. That’s creating some confusion about his obligations to the 234 employees who would answer to him — and, by extension, the mayor — because the BPDA is technically an independent state-established agency, which past mayors have often used to maintain plausible deniability about their influence over city development. The BPDA is also bleeding staff. Eighteen BPDA staffers left in 2020, followed by 47 in 2021 and another 15 so far this year. That’s not counting the seven staffers who have submitted their resignations but have not yet departed. Attempts to fill the 35 open full-time posts at the agency are haunted by the prospect that the whole place could be gutted, sources tell Playbook. The stakes are expensive. Boston’s budget lives or dies by the building market, with about 70 percent of its annual revenue coming from new development and property taxes. If the development pipeline tanks, so do the most reliable streams of cash for the mayor's ambitious long-term projects like expanding affordable housing. At the same time, affordable housing advocates have been calling for a slowdown in development until more robust planning can take place, fearing widespread displacement. Political observers and the development community see two paths. On one hand, Jemison is an established figure in the Massachusetts housing world — a former employee of the development agency and a Patrick administration housing and community development alum who’s worked in Boston, Detroit and Washington, D.C. He could be a long-term bridge between Wu and the BPDA, which are in a chilly communication cycle. But that’s going to be a lot harder if Wu follows through on literally abolishing the BPDA. The mayor’s been dodging questions recently about her intentions. Either way, she’d need the support of lawmakers: any effort to strip the agency’s powers or abolish it entirely would need to go through the Boston City Council and the state Legislature. Right now, the mayor is extending an olive branch to developers. The Boston Globe reported this week that the mayor will be hosting a select group of Boston real estate heavyweights at the Parkman House later this month. Jemison himself may attend, but an invitation obtained by Playbook says city brass, including “representatives” from the BPDA, will join the mayor. GOOD FRIDAY MORNING, MASSACHUSETTS. I’m Jennifer Smith , a Boston-based reporter and Lisa’s co-host on The Horse Race podcast. She handed me the Playbook reins for the day, and instead of letting her rest I talked her ear off about Boston development and now you all get to come with us. If you want to hear me talk about something else, something a bit more gubernatorial, I’m on GBH’s "Talking Politics" this evening with Adam Reilly and the Boston Globe’s Adrian Walker. And for the third day/night in a row, huge thanks to Madison Fernandez. TODAY — Rep. Jim McGovern meets with agriculture advocacy groups at 9:30 a.m. in Lancaster. Sen. Elizabeth Warren discusses the need for continued public investments in rail at 11:05 a.m. at North Shore Community College. Boston Mayor Michelle Wu hosts an Earth Day Celebration at noon in Chinatown and offers remarks at a community Iftar dinner at 7 p.m. in Roxbury. THIS WEEKEND — Sen. Ed Markey hosts a media availability about his visits to Poland and Brussels at 11 a.m. Saturday at the JFK Federal Building in Boston. State Rep. Tami Gouveia kicks off a signature-collecting drive for her LG bid at 11 a.m. Saturday in Lowell. COP26 President Alok Sharma speaks at Tufts’ Fletcher School at noon on Saturday. SUNDAY SHOWS — Northeastern journalism professor Dan Kennedy is on WBZ’s “Keller @ Large” at 8:30 a.m. Sunday. Rep. Ayanna Pressley is on WCVB’s “On the Record” at 11 a.m. Sunday. Lisa's still under the weather, but please email all your tips and scoops her way: lkashinsky@politico.com. A message from National Grid: There Is A Better Way. National Grid is announcing our path to a fossil-free energy future. By using renewable natural gas, and green hydrogen produced from water using wind energy, we can achieve a fossil-free energy future by 2050 or earlier.   THE LATEST NUMBERS — "Massachusetts reports 2,528 new COVID cases, virus hospitalizations increase," by Rick Sobey, Boston Herald: "The 2,528 daily virus cases in the state was down from 2,962 reported cases last Thursday. However, testing dropped 11% from last Thursday’s report." DATELINE BEACON HILL — “Climate, downtowns, housing focus of Baker spending bill,” by Shira Schoenberg, CommonWealth Magazine: “Gov. Charlie Baker on Wednesday filed a $3.5 billion economic development bill that focuses on climate-related projects, downtown revitalization, and housing. The bill is chock-full of specific local projects, a strategy likely aimed at getting the support of individual lawmakers — and getting municipal officials to lobby their lawmakers to pass it.” GAMBLING ADDICTION .... — “ Ex-state lawmaker leaves prison for community confinement,” by The Associated Press: “A former Massachusetts state lawmaker who pleaded guilty to various corruption charges has been released from prison and will serve the rest of his sentence in home confinement or at a halfway house. Former Democratic state Rep. David Nangle, of Lowell, was sentenced in September to 15 months in prison after pleading guilty to illegally using campaign funds to pay for personal expenses, defrauding a bank to obtain loans to buy a home and repay personal debts, and collecting income that he failed to report to the IRS.” — “ AG Healey signs off on acquisition of state’s largest independent doc group,” by Jessica Bartlett, Boston Globe: “Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey’s office has signed off on Optum’s acquisition of Atrius Health for $236 million, a critical step to allowing the national health care group to acquire the state’s largest independent physician organization. The deal will transition nearly all of Atrius’s assets from a nonprofit to a for-profit entity and will still have to be reviewed by the state’s Supreme Judicial Court.” — “ Private pay childcare providers say they’re being forgotten,” by Shira Schoenberg, CommonWealth Magazine: “When the state required most daycares to close in the early days of the COVID pandemic, Gov. Charlie Baker reassured providers that they would continue getting state subsidies during the closure. … Two-plus years later, daycare providers who are paid privately by families say they continue to feel left out, struggling for acknowledgment in policies that prioritize providers who take state subsidies.” VAX-ACHUSETTS — MORE GUIDELINES THAN ACTUAL RULES: Massachusetts cities and institutions experiencing an uptick in Covid-19 cases are suggesting people continue wearing masks indoors but stopping shy of issuing mandates (for now). As Boston’s positivity rate ticks up to 6.9 percent, Bisola Ojikutu , executive director of the Boston Public Health Commission said, “we are recommending that individuals protect themselves and others by masking indoors, particularly in crowded places.” In an campus-wide email obtained by Playbook, UMass Boston Chancellor Marcelo Suárez-Orozco said masks are “strongly recommended” on campus and required on UMass shuttles despite the MBTA dropping its mandate on buses and trains. Tufts University abandoned its plan to lift mask mandates this week, the Tufts Daily reported, as 6 percent of its undergraduates tested positive upon returning from spring break. — “14 sick due to COVID-19 outbreak at Chelsea Soldiers’ Home ,” by Arianna MacNeill, Boston.com: “The cases were discovered during ‘routine testing’ over the holiday weekend, according to a statement from a spokesperson for the state Department of Veterans’ Services. … The Soldiers’ Home in Holyoke was the site of a major outbreak of COVID-19 in spring 2020. At least 76 residents died after testing positive. It’s thought to be one of the worst outbreaks in a long-term care facility across the country.”   DON'T MISS ANYTHING FROM THE 2022 MILKEN INSTITUTE GLOBAL CONFERENCE: POLITICO is excited to partner with the Milken Institute to produce a special edition "Global Insider" newsletter featuring exclusive coverage and insights from the 25th annual Global Conference. This year's event, May 1-4, brings together more than 3,000 of the world’s most influential leaders, including 700+ speakers representing more than 80 countries. "Celebrating the Power of Connection" is this year's theme, setting the stage to connect influencers with the resources to change the world with leading experts and thinkers whose insight and creativity can implement that change. Whether you're attending in person or following along from somewhere else in the world, keep up with this year's conference with POLITICO’s special edition “Global Insider” so you don't miss a beat. Subscribe today.     FROM THE HUB — THE TONIEST OF TOWNS: The Globe has a rundown this week — complete with charts! — of American Community Survey five-year data on the wealthiest municipalities in the state. Massachusetts is the state with the third-highest average annual household income, $84,385, behind only Maryland and New Jersey. Twenty Massachusetts cities and towns have no households reported below the poverty line — including Dover, where its just over 2,000 residents have a median household income of $250,000. That’s by no means the norm. Holyoke reported 23 percent of its residents live below the poverty line and a median household income of $43,537. Even closer to the Hub, Newton’s $154,398 median household income is twice that of Boston as a whole. — “‘Just one paycheck away.’ Report finds 142,000 low-income Mass. families need affordable housing,” by Alexa Gagosz, Boston Globe: “The majority of the lowest-income renters in Massachusetts spend more than half of their income on housing alone, putting them at risk of homelessness, according to a newly released report. … In Massachusetts there are 47 rental homes for every 100 extremely low-income (also known as ELI) households, which are households with incomes at or below the poverty level of $32,000 for a household of four. In Rhode Island, that number is 51. In New Hampshire, it’s 37.” — “Boston police unions threaten legal action over tear-gas ordinance,” by Sean Philip Cotter, Boston Herald: “Some of the city’s police unions are threatening legal action against Mayor Michelle Wu as they make noise about an ordinance passed last year around pepper spray and rubber bullets. The letter from the Boston Police Superior Officers Federation and the Boston Police Detectives Benevolent Society, dated Wednesday, is taking issue with the measure that limits the use of tear gas, pepper spray, rubber bullets, flash-bands, beanbag rounds and other related tools against protests, demonstrations or other gatherings of people. Cops now can only use such measures in narrowly defined situations and only after warnings.”   A message from National Grid:     ON THE STUMP HI PLAYBOOK FAM! Lisa here with a few quick dispatches: — ABOUT THAT CLIMATE DEBATE: State attorney general hopefuls Shannon Liss-Riordan and Quentin Palfrey will take part in a climate debate hosted by 350 Mass in late May. Liss-Riordan’s campaign says it’s “unclear” whether Andrea Campbell will participate. Liss-Riordan challenged her rivals to a climate debate a couple weeks ago, things quickly escalated, and this is where we’ve ended up. “Perhaps the spirit of Earth Day will encourage Andrea to join us in this conversation,” Liss-Riordan said in a statement. — SPEAKING OF DEBATES: All three Democrats running for AG will participate in a Boston College Law School forum at noon next Thursday, moderated by the Boston Globe’s Kimberly Atkins Stohr. GOP AG hopeful Jay McMahon declined to attend because of a prior commitment, organizers said. — FEATURED SPEAKER: Rep. Byron Donalds (R-Fla.) will keynote the MassGOP convention next month in Springfield, Chair Jim Lyons announced yesterday, calling him “a shining example of what the Republican Party is all about” and “someone who is unafraid to speak out against the Democrats’ radical agenda.” Donalds is a conservative Black Republican and supporter of former President Donald Trump who pushes back against accusations that Republicans are racists. — “ Mass. lieutenant governors officially have little power. Yet 8 candidates are seeking the job,” by Anthony Brooks, WBUR: “More people are running for lieutenant governor than for any other state office in Massachusetts. The current crop of eight candidates includes six Democrats (state Rep. Tami Gouveia, state Sen. Adam Hinds, Salem Mayor Kim Driscoll, state Sen. Eric Lesser, businessman Bret Bero and Scott Donohue); and two Republicans (former state Rep. Kate Campanale and former state Rep. Leah Cole Allen). But what's the attraction of a job with so few official duties?” — “ GOP governor hopefuls spar over Chris Doughty’s debate challenge,” by Amy Sokolow, Boston Herald: “GOP gubernatorial candidate Chris Doughty has repeatedly jabbed rival Geoff Diehl this month, urging him to accept a debate challenge ahead of the party’s convention. Diehl has finally responded, with his own suggestions.” — WBUR’s Miriam Wasser has a rundown of the Democratic gubernatorial hopefuls’ “ambitious, but complicated” plans for climate change: “How should Mass. tackle climate change? Here's what the candidates for governor say.” PLANES, TRAINS AND AUTOMOBILES — "Boston could allow double-decker buses, to dismay of some," by Marie Szanizslo, Boston Herald: "Three Boston sight-seeing businesses are fighting to prevent two double-decker bus companies from being approved by the city and state." DAY IN COURT — “Convicted Murderer Thomas Koonce Released From Prison,” by WBZ: “Thomas Koonce, who was sentenced to life in prison for murder, has been freed.”   JOIN US ON 4/29 FOR A WOMEN RULE DISCUSSION ON WOMEN IN TECH : Women, particularly women of color and women from disadvantaged socioeconomic backgrounds, have historically been locked out of the tech world. But this new tech revolution could be an opportunity for women to get in on the ground floor of a new chapter. Join POLITICO for an in-depth panel discussion on the future of women in tech and how to make sure women are both participating in this fast-moving era and have access to all it offers. REGISTER HERE.     IT'S NOT EASY BEING GREEN — "U.S. Climate Envoy John Kerry stops by MIT to deliver urgent message on climate change," by Amy Sokolow, Boston Herald: "John Kerry, the country’s first climate envoy, stopped by his home state, where he warned of the dangers of political polarization standing in the way of climate change." FROM THE 413 — "Chicopee School Superintendent Lynn Clark indicted by federal grand jury for lying to FBI," by Jeanette DeForge, Springfield Republican: “A federal grand jury has indicted Chicopee Superintendent Lynn A. Clark on charges of making false statements to FBI agents investigating threatening messages to a candidate being considered for the police chief’s position.” — "Massachusetts Trial Court says cleaning, filtration is addressing mold in Springfield courthouse ," by Jim Kinney, Springfield Republican: “Remediation efforts, upgraded building filtration and the use of portable air-cleaning units are addressing mold in the troubled Roderick L. Ireland Courthouse according to a report from the Massachusetts Trial Court.” — " UMass Amherst to transition campus to entirely renewable energy; officials to unveil details Friday," by Erin Tiernan, MassLive. THE LOCAL ANGLE — "Millbury, Spencer parents sue schools over alleged harm to children from mask mandates," by Jeff A. Chamer, Worcester Telegram & Gazette: "A group of Central Massachusetts parents is suing school officials over alleged physical and emotional injuries to their children caused by school mask mandates. ... The parents — including Michelle Frigon and Ashley Kavanagh-Russo from Millbury, Kristen Herholz from Spencer and Nichole Gustafson, who previously lived in Spencer but now lives in Texas, according to court documents — are suing 22 defendants for $24 million." MEANWHILE IN NEW HAMPSHIRE — “Bill adding exception to NH abortion ban headed to governor,” by Holly Ramer, The Associated Press: “A bill adding an exception to New Hampshire’s new abortion ban for cases in which the fetus has been diagnosed with ‘abnormalities incompatible with life’ is heading to the desk of Gov. Chris Sununu, who has said he will sign it. Since Jan. 1, New Hampshire has outlawed abortion after 24 weeks gestation, with exceptions only for pregnancies that threaten the mother’s life or health. Doctors who provide late-term abortions can face felony charges, and ultrasounds are required before any abortion.” FEELIN’ 22 — "A New England Patriot and a conservative billionaire are trying to take down a GOP senator ," by POLITICO's Alex Isenstadt A message from National Grid: National Grid is announcing our path to a fossil-free energy future for our customers and communities. Our fossil-free plan will help achieve the Northeast’s aggressive climate goals and set a new standard for energy companies. We will use renewable natural gas, green hydrogen generated from wind and solar power, battery storage, and greater energy efficiency to make our National Grid system fossil-free by 2050 or earlier. Climate scientists say renewable natural gas is a win-win for the environment. There Is A Better Way to keep energy affordable, reliable, and clean. That’s why we are creating a hybrid pathway that preserves customer choice while delivering the clean, affordable energy future our customers want and deserve. See How.   TRANSITIONS — Miriam Cash, deputy press secretary for Sen. Elizabeth Warren, is leaving for the House side of the Hill, multiple sources tell Playbook. Cash will move to the office of Rep. Mondaire Jones (D-N.Y.). HAPPY 6TH ANNIVERSARY — to the Boston Guardian. HAPPY BIRTHDAY — to Yasmina Vinci and Evan Dobelle. HAPPY BIRTHWEEKEND — to state Rep. Brian Ashe, 90 West founder and CEO Alex Goldstein, Taylor Pederson, Terrence Clark, Kerry Talbot, GOP gubernatorial hopeful Geoff Diehl and former Massport Police Chief Joe Lawless, who celebrate Saturday; and to Sunday birthday-ers Matt Vautour, Melrose Mayor Paul Brodeur, Romney alum Charlie Pearce, Chris Wayland, and Mass. Sierra Club Deputy Director Jacob Stern. NEW HORSE RACE ALERT: STOP, DROP AND POLL — Jenn is flying solo to talk with MassINC Polling Group research director Rich Parr about statewide races and why Massachusetts residents are less worried than you might expect about the threat of climate change in this here Bay State. Subscribe and listen on iTunes and Sound Cloud. Want to make an impact? POLITICO Massachusetts has a variety of solutions available for partners looking to reach and activate the most influential people in the Bay State. Have a petition you want signed? A cause you’re promoting? Seeking to increase brand awareness among this key audience? Share your message with our influential readers to foster engagement and drive action. Contact Jesse Shapiro to find out how: jshapiro@politico.com.   Follow us on Twitter Lisa Kashinsky @lisakashinsky   Subscribe to the POLITICO Playbook family Playbook  |  Playbook PM  |  California Playbook  |  Florida Playbook  |  Illinois Playbook  |  Massachusetts Playbook  |  New Jersey Playbook  |  New York Playbook  |  Ottawa Playbook  |  Brussels Playbook  |  London Playbook View all our politics and policy newsletters FOLLOW US

POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

RSN: Dan Rather and Elliot Kirschner | How Do You Make Sense of This?

 

 

22 April 22

A Moment to Honor Those Who Sustain RSN

The problem of people who use Reader Supported News but will not contribute is so serious that it often overshadows the efforts of those who are quite willing to help sustain the organization, and there are many.

We are a long way from finished for April. Let’s take a moment however to thank sincerely our sustainers, large and small each and every one.

In solidarity.

Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News

Sure, I'll make a donation!

 

If you would prefer to send a check:
Reader Supported News
PO Box 2043 / Citrus Heights, CA 95611

Follow us on facebook and twitter!

Update My Monthly Donation

 

21 April 22

Live on the homepage now!
Reader Supported News

WE’RE GOING TO GET KILLED UNLESS WE FIGHT — In fundraising as in political life it is a struggle out there. RSN get’s nothing in terms of funding we do not fight for. We would much rather be putting the time and attention into research and publishing, but we must have a budget. Your contribution matters. Bring it on please.
Marc Ash • Founder, Reader Supported News

Sure, I'll make a donation!

 

Dan Rather and Elliot Kirschner | How Do You Make Sense of This?
Dan Rather and Elliot Kirschner, Steady
Excerpt: "Well, Steady community, perhaps the question at the top of the newsletter and the picture above have given you a clue as to what we will be discussing today."

Writing a draft for history

Well, Steady community, perhaps the question at the top of the newsletter and the picture above have given you a clue as to what we will be discussing today.

Oftentimes, we try to pose questions in this newsletter as a way to share our perspectives and encourage community engagement. Today, however, we are mixing it up and trying something a bit different. Actually it’s a first at Steady: a contest (of sorts).

Hopefully you will find this exercise interesting, or even fun (by some tenuous definition of the word). Ultimately, however, this contest is about something deadly serious: the future of our democracy.

Naturally, we have written a lot in Steady about the events of January 6, what led to that day, and how it continues to inflect, inflame, and undermine the health, steadiness, and security of our political system.

When we talk about “January 6,” we are really using shorthand for a movement that was months, if not years, in the making. It’s similar to how “Watergate” became a stand-in for a vast criminal conspiracy run out of the Oval Office.

The events of 1/6, and all that led up to them and have transpired since, involve a president, his family, allies in Congress, and even the wife of a Supreme Court justice. They involve a vice president, the role of the press, and the judicial system. Books have already been written about that day, and likely countless pages will follow in the years ahead.

This is all important. We need to root out the details, wherever and whatever they may be. We need to be complete and thorough in telling the story of what happened and hopefully in holding those responsible accountable.

But there is another challenge with a story this sweeping, especially one that continues to unfold. The final chapters cannot be written until we know what happens next, including in upcoming elections.

Consequently, the voting public needs to have a clear and succinct sense of what the story of 1/6 is to help them weigh their ballot choices. Messaging is of vital importance. This is not to say that most or even many who support Trump and his enablers will be swayed. But some might, perhaps enough to make the difference between who gets elected and what happens to American democracy.

So with all of this as prelude, here’s the challenge:

Using no more than 75 words (succinctness is key), explain what happened on 1/6. You can paint as broad or as narrow a picture as you want. You can mention individuals by name or keep it general. The goal is to express as much of the story in as compelling and clear a way as possible. This is about clarity, urgency, and a fidelity to the facts. It should be about explaining to a fair-minded person what happened and why it is important.

For those who want to submit an entry (and we encourage all of you to do so), please add it to the comments section. And for everyone else, we encourage you to click on the little heart button to like your favorite submissions. Feel free to share this post with others outside the Steady community so we can hear their perspectives, too.

We are not sure what our next steps will be for this challenge; we just thought we would try something new. We have been so impressed whenever we hear from you. We may be biased, but we think the Steady community is among the most thoughtful, caring, and wise online. We’re eager to read your ideas.

READ MORE

A Russian rocket carrying cluster munition that landed in the countryside near Hostomel. (photo: Alessio Mamo/Guardian UK)

Russia Using Cluster Bombs to Kill Ukrainian Civilians, Analysis Suggests
Lorenzo Tondo, Guardian UK
Tondo writes: "Russian troops have used a number of weapons widely banned across the world, which have killed hundreds of civilians in the Ukrainian region of Kyiv, research by the Guardian suggests."
READ MORE

An Amazon distribution center was heavily damaged after a strong thunderstorm moved through the area Friday, Dec. 10, 2021, in Edwardsville, Ill. (photo: Jeff Roberson/AP)

Amazon Drivers Caught in Warehouse Wrecked by a Tornado Are Suing Company, Claiming Staff Threatened to Fire Them if They Went Home
Isobel Asher Hamilton, Business Insider
Hamilton writes: "Four drivers who were inside an Amazon warehouse when it was partially destroyed by a tornado have filed a lawsuit against the company."
READ MORE

Michigan state Sen. Mallory McMorrow (D) on April 19, decried the unfounded "pedophile" and "groomer" allegations made against her in a fundraising email by fellow state Sen. Lana Theis (R). (video still: Michigan Senate)

GOP Turns to False Insinuations of LGBTQ Grooming Against Democrats
Colby Itkowitz, The Washington Post
Itkowitz writes: "When Michigan Democratic state Sen. Mallory McMorrow stood on the chamber floor to take on a Republican colleague who had accused her of wanting to sexually groom children, she was denouncing not just an isolated incident, but an onslaught of GOP attacks on the LGBTQ community."
READ MORE

SEIU members and Chicago Teachers Union members protest during a rally and march on the first day of a teacher strike, Oct. 17, 2019, Chicago, IL. (photo: Shutterstock)

Does Democrats' Support for Unions Extend to Their Own Employees?
Li Zhou, Vox
Zhou writes: "House Democrats are facing a telling question: How committed are they to unions when it's their own employees who want one?"
READ MORE

The administration said in March it would bring up to 100,000 Ukrainians fleeing war to the U.S. (photo: Getty)

Biden Announces 'Streamlined' Plan to Bring Ukrainian Refugees to the US
Julia Ainsley and Alexandra Bacallao, NBC News
Excerpt: "President Joe Biden announced a plan on Thursday to begin bringing Ukrainians fleeing war to the U.S., addressing a promise the president made nearly a month ago to welcome up to 100,000 Ukrainian refugees."
READ MORE

Trump supporters in Pittsburgh. (photo: Megan Handel/ChimeIn)

Right-Wing Populist Parties Are Bad for Climate Action, Study Finds
Olivia Rosane, EcoWatch
Rosane writes: "From Jair Bolsonaro in Brazil to Donald Trump in the U.S., the past five years have offered prominent examples of right-wing leaders who set back collective action against the climate crisis."

From Jair Bolsonaro in Brazil to Donald Trump in the U.S., the past five years have offered prominent examples of right-wing leaders who set back collective action against the climate crisis.

Now, a study published in Global Environmental Politics this month shows that the issue is much larger than a few high-profile leaders. The researchers, from the Universities of Sussex and Warwick in the UK, found that the influence of a right-wing populist party can reduce a country’s climate policy score by nearly 25 percent.

“Conventional centre-right political parties have always been more reluctant to adopt strong climate policies, but the rise of right-wing populist parties and movements represents a threat of a different order,” study co-author Dr. Matthew Lockwood, senior lecturer in Energy Policy in the Science Policy Research Unit (SPRU) at the University of Sussex Business School and co-director of the Sussex Energy Group, said in a press release.

The study authors focused on the climate and renewable energy policies of more than 25 countries, The Guardian reported. All the countries were members of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), and the researchers looked at their policies between 2007 and 2018, the Independent reported. The study used a quantitative analysis to determine how the presence of right-wing populist parties in the legislative and executive branches of the countries impacted their climate and renewable energy polices.

What they found was that the influence of center-left parties increased a country’s climate-policy score by around 22 percent above average, while the influence of right-wing populist parties decreased it by 24 percent, according to the press release.

How much influence a party can have on climate policy is partly determined by what system of government a country has, however. The study looked at both simple majoritarian systems like the U.S. and proportional representation systems. In proportional representation systems, several people are elected per legislative district, and their party affiliation is determined proportionally based on relative vote share, as Fair Vote explained.

Right-wing populist parties can do the most damage to a country’s climate agenda if they capture the executive and all the cabinet seats in a majoritarian system, as Trump and his administration managed to do in the U.S. In this scenario, they can decrease a country’s climate policy score by 58 percent. However, these parties have less impact in a proportional representation system, because they tend to enter as junior members in a governing coalition. Further, right-wing populist parties were not able to significantly influence the climate policy in EU countries, likely because much of this policy is crafted by the bloc as a whole.

“Our paper provides some of the first quantitative evidence on how right-wing populism is negatively associated with progress on climate policy, at least among OECD countries. Interestingly, membership of the EU and proportional representation rules seem to mitigate this effect,” study co-author and University of Warwick economics professor Ben Lockwood said in the press release.

Overall, the study authors found that the influence of right-wing populist parties did not influence renewable energy policy.

The study authors also looked towards the future, and warned that right-wing populist parties could focus on climate policy instead of other issues like immigration as energy prices continue to climb in the wake of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.

“The thing about rightwing populist parties is they tend to be very reactive to crisis,” Matthew Lockwood told The Guardian. “In Europe, a lot of that has been on immigration, and in the UK it has been Brexit. And these issues have gone off the boil a bit so the people who were pushing for Brexit are now in the net zero scrutiny group. It’s the same people reacting to a crisis but now pushing against climate action.”

READ MORE

Special Coverage: Ukraine, A Historic Resistance
READ MORE

 

Contribute to RSN

Follow us on facebook and twitter!

Update My Monthly Donation

PO Box 2043 / Citrus Heights, CA 95611

before Trump takes the stage in Ohio

 

I’m running for U.S. Senate in Ohio to expand the Democratic Senate majority and finally deliver meaningful change for America’s working families. But Donald Trump is coming to Ohio this weekend to rally his right-wing base, boost my potential GOP opponent, and attack me.

Republicans are already spending over $80 million to keep Ohio red, and take back the Senate for Mitch McConnell. Trump’s visit will bring a new wave of money and attacks, and I need your urgent help to fight back.

If you can, will you split a donation of $10 or more between my campaign and Daughters Defend to help us overcome the GOP, flip Ohio blue, and expand the Democratic Senate majority? It’s important we raise $100,000 before Trump’s rally.

Thank you, for everything. —Tim
	Paid for and authorized by Daughters Defend Democracy. DaughtersDefend.com. Not authorized by any candidate or candidate’s committee. Daughters Defend Democracy 2021 L Street NW Suite 101-172 Washington, DC 20036 United States   This advertisement was not approved by any candidate.