Eurie Stamps died in a 2011 police shooting. Now there are new calls for justice in his death

Malik Harding, 7, is flanked by his parents, LaRoy, left, and Ashley during a march to demand justice for Eurie Stamps that began at City Hall in Cambridge on Saturday. Stamps was a 68-year-old man who was shot and killed by Framingham police during a 2011 drug raid at his home.CRAIG F. WALKER/GLOBE STAFF/THE BOSTON GLOBE

George Floyd. Breonna Taylor. Eric Garner.

Their names are more prominent in the national Black Lives Movement than that of Eurie Stamps Sr., a retired MBTA maintenance worker shot and killed in his home by Framingham police in 2011.

But as demonstrators recite the names of Black people who have died from police violence amid demands for justice, calls for public recognition of Stamps have grown louder as Massachusetts faces its own reckoning over systemic racism in policing.

In Cambridge Saturday, organizers of a march from City Hall to Hoyt Field in the name of Stamps, who grew up in that city, said they wanted to tell his story, honor his legacy, and demand accountability for his death, said Selvin L. Chambers III, one of the march’s organizers.

Stamps, 68, who was a grandfather to 15 children and had a great-grandchild, was a fixture in that city and was active in local sports leagues.

The demonstrators are also calling for the attorney general and Middlesex district attorney’s offices to review Stamps’s case, Chambers said. Paul K. Duncan, the officer who shot Stamps, never faced charges in the case and remains with Framingham’s police force. The district attorney at the time called the incident an accident.

“We’re bringing this to light because it hit us close to home, but it’s happening in every urban community across the country,” said Chambers, 57, who knew Stamps when Chambers was a teen.

Middlesex District Attorney Marian T. Ryan in a phone interview Saturday, pledged to release materials from the nearly decade-old case as quickly as possible.

“I believe in the transparency and public confidence around these investigations, and it is important to hear the questions that people have, and [hear] about the pain that they’re feeling,” said Ryan, who became district attorney in 2013.

At Cambridge’s City Hall, councilors named Stamps in a recent order calling for the eradication of systemic racism from local government. Stamps’s name was also heard in the State House in late July as lawmakers worked on a policing reform bill.

And it has sounded in the top echelons of professional sports: Christian Wilkins, a member of the Miami Dolphins of the National Football League, said he strives every day to live up to the example set by his grandfather.

People who came in contact with Stamps loved him and had a lot of respect for him, Wilkins said in a recorded statement to The Boston Globe.

“It means a lot that the people in [Massachusetts] really want to continue to honor my grandpa, even years later, after he’s passed,” Wilkins said. “It just really shows who he was, and what he meant to people.”

Demonstrators marched in honor of Eurie Stamps in Cambridge Saturday.CRAIG F. WALKER/GLOBE STAFF/THE BOSTON GLOBE

Nearly a decade ago, on Jan. 5, 2011, the Framingham police SWAT team executed a search warrant on the Fountain Street apartment Stamps shared with his wife and then-20-year-old stepson.

Police were acting on a report that Stamps’s stepson and others were selling crack cocaine from the apartment. They did not suspect Stamps of any crime. Officers entered the apartment and ordered Stamps to lie on his stomach on the floor.

Duncan moved to handcuff and search Stamps. The officer pointed a rifle at Stamps, his finger on the trigger, according to documents filed in federal court as part of a later lawsuit by Stamps’s family.

Stamps, who had no history of violence, was shot in the face and later pronounced dead at a nearby hospital.

In a statement at the time, then-Middlesex District Attorney Gerard T. Leone Jr. said Duncan lost his balance and fell, causing the officer to fire his weapon accidentally. No charges were filed against Duncan following the investigation by Leone’s office and State Police.

Organizers of the Cambridge march Saturday alleged a cover-up in the case.

In an e-mail to the Globe, Leone, now the general counsel for the University of Massachusetts, declined comment. Duncan did not respond to requests for comment.

A State Police spokesman had no comment Saturday.

In 2016, Framingham reached a $3.75 million settlement with Stamps’s estate and his family.

The following year, Framingham changed from town government, became a city, and elected Mayor Yvonne M. Spicer as its first executive.

In a statement to the Globe, Spicer said she has known the Stamps family for years and remembers when Eurie Stamps’s life was taken.

“It saddened me then and now,” she said.

Spicer said the city has made changes to its Police Department, which trains and works diligently to maintain and grow public trust, ensure accountability, transparency, and continue to heal the community. The SWAT team was disbanded in 2013.

“Mr. Stamps’ passing is heartbreaking, and there are no words to ease that loss,” Spicer said. “What we can do, however, is to learn from the past and demonstrate that moving forward through our actions." 

Nicco Harding, 6, joined his family at City Hall during Saturday's march calling for justice for Stamps in Cambridge.CRAIG F. WALKER/GLOBE STAFF/THE BOSTON GLOBE

Around midday on Saturday, dozens gathered at Cambridge City Hall before the march. Ryan said she spoke to Stamps’s granddaughter. The district attorney said she went to the City Hall to listen and learn from those who attended.

“I can’t take away the pain that is obviously still very deeply felt, that I saw this morning from the family, from the members of the community,” Ryan said. “Mr. Stamps clearly made a great impact here.”

Ryan said she would be looking at the case material herself.

As demonstrators walked from City Hall toward Central Square, they chanted: “Say his name! Eurie Stamps!”

In Framingham, a vigil is planned for Aug. 15 at the city’s Memorial Building on Concord Street.

The need for accountability in Stamps’s death at the hands of police has been growing in recent weeks.

The Cambridge City Council in June named Stamps in an order calling for a systemwide review of city government to eradicate systemic racism.

City Councilor E. Denise Simmons, who was the measure’s lead sponsor, grew up knowing Stamps and his family. When he was killed by Framingham police, she said in an e-mail, “it was a blip on the screen.”

Deaths like Stamps’s should not be brushed aside, she said.

“And that effort starts by saying his name, and reminding people about how he died,” Simmons said.

State Representative Liz Miranda, who successfully pushed for an amendment imposing restrictions on no-knock warrants as part of the House policing bill, cited the death of Stamps among others during a recent debate on the House floor.

For family and those close to Stamps, he was a man of great generosity, a mentor to young people, and was a kind spirit.

Hazel Stamps, Stamps’s sister, recalled her brother’s big, hearty laugh and a smile that could “light up the world.”

“I never had to call him to ask him to do anything. He was just there. He would appear, and ask me what I needed,” Hazel Stamps said. “He was the best brother one could ask for.”

Wilkins wrote about losing his grandfather following the death of Floyd in an Instagram post.

In his statement Saturday, Wilkins said his grandfather was an extremely humble man, the type to give you the shirt off his back and place others before himself. People who came in contact with him “loved him [and] had a lot of respect for him,” Wilkins said.

Wilkins said that while justice should be brought in the case, his focus remains on emulating his grandfather.

“I’m just going to continue to put my head down, and honor him in the best way I can,” Wilkins said. “And that’s continuing to be his legacy.”

Donnie Harding bows his head before a march calling justice for Eurie Stamps that began at City Hall in Cambridge Saturday.CRAIG F. WALKER/GLOBE STAFF

Column: Saying the name of Eurie Stamps & “The Rise of the Warrior Cop: The Militarization of America’s Police Forces”

Column: Saying the name of Eurie Stamps

By Rick Holmes
Opinions/Mass Political Editor

That means we have to try harder. The deaths of George Floyd, Eurie Stamps and so many others at the hands of police have exposed deep flaws in America’s law enforcement systems. In their names, we must make real change happen, from the White House to City Hall.

Columns share an author’s personal perspective and are often based on facts in the newspaper’s reporting.

After the Framingham Police SWAT team killed Eurie Stamps Sr. in 2011, there were no protest marchers chanting his name. There were no cameras running during the midnight raid on Stamps’ house, hence no viral videos. We didn’t get to see Stamps lying face-down on the hallway floor on the orders of the cop who, moments later, shot him in the head. Eurie was 68, African-American, a grandfather and a suspect in no crime.

There was no nationwide coverage of Eurie Stamps’ death, but the local MetroWest Daily News treated it as a major story. I wrote about it in editorials and columns, and nine years later I’m still outraged.

Town officials, intimidated by the police department and the advice of lawyers, did nothing and said nothing in the days after the killing of an innocent man. The Middlesex County DA cleared the officer and he returned to the force. Framingham’s selectmen commissioned independent reports and adopted minor policy changes and, some months later, a major one: The police chief disbanded the SWAT team.

SWAT teams are modern policing at its worst. They are equipped and trained to use military force against civilian targets, with an emphasis on intimidation and surprise. In most places, there are few situations ­– riots, active shooters, hostage standoffs and the like – for which SWAT teams are designed. So the Framingham SWAT team used the task of serving the routine search warrant for the Stamps house as a training opportunity. Even though the suspect in the investigation was already in custody and Stamps’ wife greeted them on the sidewalk, the police used all their toys: battering rams to knock down two doors, flash-bang grenades to shock anyone inside, full battle gear with fire trucks standing by in case they had to burn the house down. Mr. Stamps was the only one inside, watching the Celtics game in his pajamas. Moments later, he was dead.

If this sounds familiar, it’s the same kind of raid that left Breonna Taylor, 26, dead in Louisville last March: a no-knock search warrant, served after midnight. The suspects in the case were already in custody. After forcing their way into the apartment with a battering ram, police fired 20 shots into the apartment, eight of which hit Taylor. We say her name, along with that of George Floyd, the latest in a long line of victims.

But we don’t say the name of Eurie Stamps Sr. After Ferguson, I went to a rally in Framingham Centre where politicians, clergy, leaders of the black community and even, as I recall, the police chief, gathered to protest racial injustice. They read the names: Michael Brown, Tamir Rice, Eric Garner, Trayvon Martin. But not the name of Eurie Stamps.

There was another rally earlier this month, in front of City Hall. If Eurie’s name was spoken, there was no mention of it in the account in the local paper. I’m told the police chief took a knee along with the protesters. Good for him.

I left Framingham three years ago, and I’m in no position to judge how the city’s police department has changed. But a video that made the news last August when Framingham and Natick officers invaded a home without a warrant in search of marijuana indicates the warrior cop mentality – the mindset on display across the nation this month as police clash with protesters – is still an issue in MetroWest. Four years after voters legalized marijuana, they are still acting like old-time narcs.

The deaths of innocents at the hands of police have sparked an overdue debate over how to fix America’s police departments, and there’s no shortage of ideas for reform. Some have already been implemented in some places: bodycams on officers; training in de-escalation and subconscious bias; civilian review boards.

We’re now seeing a new crop of reform proposals: repealing the “qualified immunity” that protects bad cops from accountability; banning chokeholds and tear gas; prohibiting no-knock warrants; reining in police unions, so that contracts cover only wages and benefits, not use-of-force policies or disciplinary procedures. Another set of reforms falls under the “defund the police” slogan, which is best understood as a way to reduce the police footprint by taking away jobs cops aren’t good at: Put social workers in schools instead of police “resource officers.” Invest in emergency mental health services, addiction counselors and social workers, and have them respond to 911 calls when no serious crime is alleged. Let trained, unarmed civilians handle crowd control and construction details, even traffic citations.

In the wake of the Ferguson protests, President Barack Obama suspended the transfer of military equipment to police departments and stepped up the Department of Justice’s use of consent decrees to encourage reforms at the local level. Both those policies were reversed by President Donald Trump. If you want change, win elections.

Congress is already debating some of these ideas, and an election is coming up. Police reform is now a national issue. But managing police departments is a local responsibility. In cities like Minneapolis, New York and Los Angeles, elected officials and activists are already engaging on a new agenda for police reform.

But it’s a different story in smaller cities and towns. Fixing police departments is hard work. It requires changes in recruiting, hiring, training and discipline. Policies need to be rewritten. To do these things right, strong relationships must be forged among elected officials, police officers and members of the community. That takes a sustained commitment. Especially here in New England, decisions are made by the people who show up at the meeting. Will the people marching in the streets today be there for the police department budget hearing next spring?

Compounding the difficulty is the withering of local newspapers. Half the jobs in America’s newsrooms have disappeared since 2008. In thousands of American communities, there’s no longer a reporter reading police reports every day. There’s no one covering the city council meeting where the police chief discusses budgets and priorities. There’s no editorial page to advocate for reform. And when someone witnesses police misconduct, there’s no newspaper they can call.

That means we have to try harder. The deaths of George Floyd, Eurie Stamps and so many others at the hands of police have exposed deep flaws in America’s law enforcement systems. In their names, we must make real change happen, from the White House to City Hall.

Rick Holmes is the former opinion editor for the MetroWest Daily News.

LINK

RICK HOLMES: Goodbye Officer Friendly; hello ‘Warrior Cop’

Just after midnight on Jan. 5, 2011, Framingham police smashed through two doors of Eurie Stamps’ home, threw a flash-bang grenade through a broken window and invaded. Stamps, a 68-year-old grandfather, was in his bedroom in his pajamas, watching sports on TV.

Just after midnight on Jan. 5, 2011, Framingham police smashed through two doors of Eurie Stamps’ home, threw a flash-bang grenade through a broken window and invaded. Stamps, a 68-year-old grandfather, was in his bedroom in his pajamas, watching sports on TV.

The assault on the modest home played out like a military raid. Within seconds, an officer had Stamps face-down on the floor, his M4 assault carbine inches away from his back, the safety switch turned off. Investigators later concluded that the officer stumbled over Stamps and his gun went off. Within seconds, he was dead.

Stamps was suspected of no crime; no guns were found in the home. Framingham police were serving a search warrant related to a non-violent drug offense. They captured their target, Stamps’ stepson, on the street outside the home before the raid was launched. They launched it anyway.

Friends called the retired transit worker a “gentle giant” and “a stand-up guy.” He left behind a large family, including 12 grandchildren.

The killing of Eurie Stamps Sr. wasn’t a mistake, and it wasn’t a tragedy. It was a symptom of what has happened to America’s police forces since government started declaring war on domestic crimes.

There are as many as 50,000 SWAT raids like that every year, according to academic studies, and very few of them involve hostage situations or violent threats for which SWAT teams were supposedly created. The vast majority of SWAT deployments are for serving warrants in non-violent drug cases, though the military tactics have also been used to break up charity poker and to bust bars for underage drinking.

Stamps is one of at least 50 innocent people killed in SWAT raids targeting non-violent consensual crimes like drugs and gambling, journalist Radley Balko says. All were killed when police, who are supposed to prevent violence, instead applied lethal force to situations where no violence was threatened.

We’ve become so used to these raids that it’s easy to forget that, not long ago, the idea of local police smashing down the door of a quiet house in the middle of the night was unthinkable. The principle that a citizen’s home was his castle, safe from unannounced raids by government agents, predates the Declaration of Independence.

Before Richard Nixon declared “war on crime,” followed by presidential declarations of war on drugs and war on terror, there was a clear distinction drawn between cops and soldiers. Police dressed in blue, with badge numbers or name tags identifying individual officers. They carried billy clubs and revolvers, weapons appropriate for walking beats on neighborhood streets.

SWAT teams today dress in black, with body armor and sometimes masks. It’s no wonder that when they crash into homes in the middle of the night, yelling obscenities and pointing guns at people – and often shooting family dogs, Balko reports – they are sometimes assumed to be criminal gangs.

Framingham’s SWAT team, like many, dresses in jungle camouflage, matching the camo paint on their military-issue armored personnel carrier. It’s a uniform I’ve never understood. Do they plan to hide out in the jungles of Massachusetts? Who would they be hiding from?

These fashion statements come with new laws, new tactics and a new attitude. Goodbye Officer Friendly. Hello “Warrior Cop.”

In his new book, “The Rise of the Warrior Cop: The Militarization of America’s Police Forces,” Balko shows how this transformation took place. A procession of politicians exploited fears sparked by rising crime in the ’60s and ’70s. Compliant judges upheld new laws authorizing “no-knock raids” and forced entry warrants. Federal grants encouraged the flow of military hardware to local police departments. Asset forfeiture laws giving a portion of assets seized from criminal suspects to local police made it more profitable to spend police resources chasing drug dealers than those who commit violence or property crimes.

There were no paramilitary police units before 1969, when the first SWAT team was created in Los Angeles. Now they are everywhere. Balko estimates that 80 percent of communities with populations between 25,000 and 50,000 have SWAT teams.

And if you’ve got a SWAT team, and a warehouse full of military equipment – local police now get grants to purchase helicopters, tanks, even bayonets – you might as well use them. So the Framingham SWAT team showed up at the Stamps house in full battle gear, nearly two dozen officers, with paramedics and firefighters along for the ride. They smashed the doors with government-issue battering rams. They threw a flash-bang grenade into the apartment to scare every living thing into submission.

Winding back the policies encouraging militarization will be tough, Balko writes, but even more troubling is the mindset that has come with it. Police recruitment videos and popular culture celebrate breaking down doors and blowing things up. Police policies and rhetoric give force protection a higher priority than citizens’ rights.

Crime rates have fallen dramatically in the last 20 years, not because of aggressive police tactics – drug use, the main target of those tactics, has not noticeably declined – but in spite of them. But the militarization continues, and it is now being pushed by defense contractors and what Balko calls a growing “police-industrial complex.”

But there is hope. A new generation of political leaders is challenging the war on drugs and the mass incarceration model for criminal justice. They should all read Balko’s book, and begin an overdue discussion of the difference between a civilian police force and an army of occupation.

Rick Holmes, opinion editor for the MetroWest Daily News, Framingham blogs at Holmes & Co. (http://blogs.wickedlocal.com/holmesandco).

LINK