FAIR: Gov. Hogan’s Purchase of Korean Covid Tests Looks Like a PR stunt—and Media Fell for It

View article on FAIR's website Gov. Hogan’s Purchase of Korean Covid Tests Looks Like a PR stunt—and Media Fell for It Pete Tucker   The New York Times (4/20/20), among other outlets, presented Hogan's acquisition of Korean tests as a Trump-defying coup. Despite being the governor of a small state, Larry Hogan secured coronavirus test kits from “13 time zones away,” thanks to “nearly a month of diplomacy talks” and “middle of the night” negotiations. His “tell it like it is” approach provides “a contrast with the president.” That was the storyline Hogan wanted, and he got it, in no small part because the Maryland governor offers an irresistible profile for the media: a Republican—yes, a Republican!—who criticizes Trump. Having checked that box, little else mattered. The Hogan-initiated negotiations that led to a South Korean company flying 500,000 coronavirus testing kits to Maryland were glowingly reported on by the New York Times (4/20/20), NPR (4/21/20) and pretty much everyone else. The past few weeks, it’s been hard to watch TV without seeing Hogan, the chairman of the National Governors Association, holding forth on shows like ABC’s The View (4/21/20), Comedy Central’s Daily Show (4/29/20) and MSNBC’s Morning Joe (4/21/20). Hogan’s victory tour for what he dubbed “Operation Enduring Friendship” was set to continue with a live conversation on April 30, branded “Leadership During Crisis” with the Washington Post, a newspaper that generally loves him (FAIR.org, 11/21/18). But that morning, the bottom of the Post’s front page had a damning exposé (4/29/30) on Hogan’s South Korean gambit. The Washington Post (4/29/30) published an exposé that punctured much of the hype surrounding the Korean tests—notably paired, however... The tests Hogan purchased abroad for $9.5 million were “not in short supply in the United States,” and in fact were available “for 20 to 30% less than what Hogan paid,” the Post's Erin Cox and Steve Thompson reported. “If somebody had come to us a few weeks ago and said we need a large order for Maryland, we would have been...capable of taking the order and fulfilling it,” a CEO of a company that makes Covid tests told the Post. “We always love to ship in the United States, because it’s a lot easier to ship domestically than foreign.” Even if Hogan insisted on buying the tests from South Korea—which he may have done for publicity—he still paid 38% more than the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) did that same month for South Korean tests, the Post reported. In addition to wasting a couple million tax dollars on what appears to be more PR stunt than public health measure, Hogan’s claim that the tests were going to be an “exponential, game-changing step forward” was a vast exaggeration. The US’s testing deficiency isn’t due to a lack of tests, but the ancillaries needed to make them work, which weren’t a part of Hogan’s Korean purchase. “Without things like reagents, [the tests] are sort of like paperweights,” Montgomery County executive Marc Elrich, the Democratic chief of Maryland’s largest county, told the Post. Nearly two weeks after the tests arrived, AFSCME Maryland president Patrick Moran was wondering when they’d help his frontline workers. “We’ve been asking, ‘Where are the tests? Where are the tests?'” the union leader told the Baltimore Sun (4/30/20). “The governor took a victory lap before finishing the job.” A week later, Maryland nursing homes, which have accounted for nearly 60% of the state’s Covid-19 deaths, were still looking for the tests. “They don’t exist,” the CEO of an association of Maryland’s long-term facilities told state lawmakers (Washington Post, 5/6/20). Without the ancillaries, the tests aren’t useful. Even Hogan (Baltimore Sun, 4/20/20) noted this, but only after proclaiming his “amazing” and “unprecedented” international purchase would “keep people safe all across the state.” ...with the Post's Robert Costa (4/30/20) interviewing Hogan about his "Leadership During Crisis." Those pronouncements rang hollow after the Post’s exposé. And now Hogan was set to take part in a Post conversation, awkwardly billed as “Leadership During Crisis.” Fortunately for the governor, he was questioned by national Post reporter Robert Costa, not the local reporters who exposed his suspect deal. After Hogan (unsuccessfully) tried refuting the Post’s reporting, Costa prompted him to create a new and more dramatic story line, one that would provide the governor with another round of media adulation. Turns out, there were sensational aspects of the story that Hogan had left out. As an eager Costa looked on, Hogan recalled how he’d diverted the South Korean plane to Maryland’s BWI airport. “We wanted to make sure that that plane took off from Korea safely, landed here in America safely, and that we guarded that cargo from whoever might interfere,” said Hogan, who dutifully met the plane on the tarmac. Once the wheels touched down, Hogan had “a large contingent” of Maryland National Guard and State Police on hand to secure the tests and whisk them away to “an undisclosed location,” where they remain under guard, Hogan said, claiming the cargo “was like Fort Knox to us.” Wasn’t it true, Costa asked, that Hogan feared the feds would seize the tests? Indeed, “it was a little bit of a concern,” said Hogan, citing examples in other states, like Massachusetts, which may have provided Hogan with his playbook. When Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker’s order for desperately needed masks was intercepted by the feds, the Republican teamed up with New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft, who used his team plane to fly 1.2 million N95 masks from China to Boston, resulting in glowing media accounts. Following in his friend Baker’s footsteps, Hogan also dramatically welcomed a plane carrying supplies from Asia to his state, then guarded the cargo from the feds. The governor shifted the storyline from "Hogan paid too much for tests" to "Hogan kept Trump from stealing tests" (CNN, 4/30/20). The media jumped all over the improved story, ignoring the Post’s exposé. Even astute outlets like Democracy Now! (5/1/20) were swept off their feet by Hogan’s anti-Trump pose. It’s possible Hogan really feared the feds, but media reports show them going after invaluable Covid supplies, such as personal protective equipment, N95 masks, ventilators, thermometers and ancillary materials for test kits. Hogan had a planeload of overpriced, domestically available tests of limited immediate utility. Only days after its damning exposé, the Post (5/3/20) pretended its reporting never happened. Hogan was again sharing the limelight with Baker, two Republican leaders who secured vital supplies abroad in defiance of Trump. That’s the storyline Hogan wanted all along. Maryland, meanwhile, is suffering from one of the country’s deadlier Covid-19 outbreaks, made worse by inadequate testing.

© 2020 Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting. All rights reserved.  Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting Our mailing address is: FAIRNESS & ACCURACY IN REPORTING 124 W. 30th Street, Suite 201 New York, NY 10001 FAIR's Website FAIR counts on your support to do this work — please donate today.

DEMAND PROGRESS: Sign the petition: Stop Jared Kushner from hoarding coronavirus supplies

Where are all the masks, test kits, and other crucial supplies desperately needed to safely end the lockdowns and end the coronavirus pandemic?

It looks like Jared Kushner, Donald Trump's son-in-law, has a lot of them. He's secretly working with big corporations to hoard millions of gloves, masks, swabs, and more.¹ We don't know where they're all going, even as governors have to have the National Guard protect their own shipments so the feds don't seize them.²

This is totally unacceptable. It could even be criminal. But we don't know the details. It's time for Congress to act.

Sign the petition and tell Congress: Don't let Trump and Kushner hoard desperately needed coronavirus supplies!

Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner runs Project Airbridge, which is a the heart of the issue. According to Bloomberg News, Project Airbridge has imported at least 746 million pairs of gloves, 71 million surgical masks, 10 million surgical gowns, 2 million thermometers, 768,000 N95 masks and 562,000 face shields.¹

But those supplies don't appear to be making it to where they're needed -- especially to states run by Democrats. Governors from Illinois and Washington State have pointed out the White House has failed to deliver the promised supplies. They have no way to know what Kushner is doing with this enormous hoard. Neither do we.

The necessary coronavirus lockdowns can only end when states have enough supplies to protect the public and test and trace their populations to stop a renewed spread of the infection. Most states don't have those supplies yet.

Jared Kushner has a lot of these supplies, but we don't know what he's doing with it. We don't know if he and his family are personally profiting from this. We don't know whether big corporations that are involved are making big profits either.

This is a totally unacceptable situation, especially amidst a national crisis. It's time for Congress to step in.

Add your name: Tell Congress to investigate Jared Kushner's Project Airbridge and make sure needed supplies get where they need to go!

Thanks for taking action,

Robert and the team at Demand Progress

Sources:
1. Bloomberg News, "Kushner Airlift Moves Millions of Masks, But Details Are Secret," May 1, 2020.
2. New York Post, "Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan has National Guard protecting coronavirus tests from feds," April 30, 2020.

---

PAID FOR BY DEMAND PROGRESS (DemandProgress.org) and not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee. Contributions are not deductible as charitable contributions for federal income tax purposes. 

RSN: Al Franken | Start Hearings Now!

03 May 20

It's Live on the HomePage Now:
Reader Supported News

---

Al Franken | Start Hearings Now!

Al Franken, Al Franken's Website
Franken writes: "Before President Trump offered the insanely stupid (and I do not mean that sarcastically) idea of injecting disinfectants into our bodies to treat Covid-19, a good majority of Americans had already concluded that Trump is not providing the wise, measured leadership of, say, a Lincoln or an FDR."

Leadership has come from elsewhere. From governors, medical professionals, and other essential workers on the front lines. But we have no coherent national response to this pandemic. That response really should come from the federal government.

There are three branches of our federal government. Donald Trump leads the executive branch and has shown himself to be completely dishonest, extremely paranoid, and, yes, stupid. Dishonest, disturbed, and stupid are no way to lead a country, sir.

That leaves the other two branches. One of those is the Supreme Court, which is ill-suited to lead in anything other than a Constitutional crisis, let alone a pandemic. Also, the Court just fast-tracked the appeal of the decision of both the district and circuit courts by a purely partisan 5-4 margin. All in order to force the people of Wisconsin to risk their lives to vote in the state election of a state judge.

The 5-4 margin exists only because Senate majority leader, Mitch McConnell is a proudly transparent, shameless hypocrite, who recently gave “a sly smile” when confirming that he would fill a Court vacancy if one opens up between now and noon on January 20, 2021.

In the meantime, McConnell is suggesting that states declare bankruptcy.

So, that leaves the House, whose members are now back in their home districts on recess. Most, I’m sure, are sheltered at home and working hard, consulting with state officials, local businesses, hospitals, schools, doctors, and (if they’re Democrats) labor leaders.

A message to Speaker Pelosi. Tens of thousands of Americans are dead, and tens of thousands more will die. Our economy is in freefall. Maybe this would be a good time to have hearings.

Say, on testing. President Trump keeps saying that we’ve tested more people per capita than any other country. He’s lying! Shouldn’t Congress call expert witnesses, read and hear their testimony, and then ask them questions?

Do we have a national plan for scaling up the testing as fast as possible? What should the federal role be? The state role? Do we have every lab working at full capacity? What kind of tests do we need and in what quantities, and how do we make sure they are distributed and administered strategically? Is the FDA on top of guaranteeing that Americans aren’t getting bad tests? Do we have the reagents we need? No? Then where can we get them? Do we have a national plan for contact tracing? How would that work? What is the most effective use of testing to enable us to get people back to work? Do we need to spend a lot more on testing?

That’s just the tip of the iceberg. On testing.

How do we make sure kids aren’t hungry?

What would the effect on worldwide markets if our states did start declaring bankruptcy?

This is a worldwide pandemic. How are we working with the rest of the world?

What exactly does the World Health Organization do? Is it really a good idea to cut off our funding?

Is there a black market in PPE? What can we do to stop that? Should Trump finally fully invoke the Defense Production Act so there are no shortages?

And – how about a little oversight on the nearly $3 trillion dedicated so far to addressing the pandemic and the economic disaster that has come along with it. Yes, the Speaker has established an oversight committee on the $3 trillion that Congress has approved thus far. But why exactly aren’t we having hearings now?

It’s true that bringing the 435 House members together under one Dome creates some real social distancing problems. But it’s also true that my three-year-old granddaughter, Avery, meets with her pre-school class five days a week online. She has a staffer (my daughter) who gets her connected. And it works like a charm. Yes, the House would need to adopt new rules to allow virtual hearings. Well – do that!

Now, Americans might say – “Hey, Congress! Suck it up and wear PPE at hearings. Just like our medical professionals and so many other Americans.” Fine. Then do that! But, Christ! Do something!

America desperately needs leadership – right now. Donald Trump is not providing it. The Senate won’t provide it. If Mitch McConnell approves an oversight committee, it’ll be on Joe Biden. Or Hunter Biden. Or another Biden.

Avery sees and talks with her teacher and classmates on this thing called Zoom. They’re working now on sounding out the letters of the alphabet. I’m not sure how secure Zoom is. But my guess is that the House could figure this out. Please. Start hearings now!

READ MORE

Antibody tests are performed on a blood sample, and are seen by many governments as key to better understanding the spread of mild and asymptomatic cases of Covid-19. (photo: IPA/Zuma Press)

FDA Approves Antibody Test That Claims Near-Perfect Accuracy
Denise Roland, The Wall Street Journal
Roland writes: "The Food and Drug Administration has cleared for emergency use an antibody test from diagnostics giant Roche Holding AG RHHBY -1.45%, the company said Sunday, a move that could add significant capacity to efforts to determine the wider spread of Covid-19."

EXCERPT:

Roche says its test has proven 100% accurate at detecting Covid-19 antibodies in the blood, and 99.8% accurate at ruling out the presence of those antibodies. In other words, only two in every 1,000 samples lacking the antibodies would produce a “false positive” result.

Thomas Schinecker, who leads Roche’s diagnostics business, said in an interview that the company was able to run its test on around 6,000 blood samples, a figure he said was significantly higher than smaller rivals. He said the test reliably detects antibodies when the blood sample is drawn at least 14 days after infection.

Governments around the world hope reliable antibody testing could help gauge how much of the population remains susceptible to the virus, in order to guide decisions about easing lockdowns. Some have even considered issuing “immunity passports” to people who have antibodies that could allow them to, for example, return to work earlier.

In most infectious diseases, the antibodies produced after a first infection act quickly to neutralize any subsequent infection, protecting the person from falling ill again. But even a reliable antibody test may not be a foolproof way of measuring immunity against Covid-19. Because the virus is so new, scientists still don’t know how long antibodies remain in the blood. What’s more, it is unclear whether it is possible to fall ill from Covid-19 a second time, despite the presence of antibodies.

The Swiss health-care giant’s heft means it can ramp up the provision of its antibody test quickly. The test kits are designed to run on the company’s automated machines, which are already installed in more than 100 laboratories across the U.S. They will be made available immediately.

Roche says it will be able to churn out test kits, made in Germany, in the high double-digit millions by June. The company aims to double that capacity by the end of the year, said Mr. Schinecker.

READ MORE

Donald Trump. (photo: Win McNamee/Getty Images)

Trump Casually Doubles the Number of Americans He'd Be Okay Losing to the Coronavirus
Bess Levin, Vanity Fair
Levin writes: "Presumably this won't be the last time between now and November that he revises both the number of dead Americans the country should consider a success, and how many he'll take credit for saving."

HORRIFYINNG EXCERPT:

One-hundred thousand is the new sixty-thousand.

f your sense of time has become a flat circle these last couple of months, it might be hard to remember what was going on in February 2020. But as a reminder, that was when Donald Trump declared that there would be no more than 15 coronavirus cases total in the U.S. Shortly thereafter, he nudged that number up just slightly, claiming that the disease would prove nowhere near as bad as the 2009 H1N1 flu outbreak, which killed roughly 12,500 Americans. At the end of March, he shifted expectations a tad, saying that if the U.S. death toll clocked in between 100,000 and 200,000, it would mean his administration had “done a very good job.” Later, when strict social distancing measures began to flatten the curve, he opined that 60,000 dead Americans would be a win. Now, as the U.S. has surpassed that figure, the president has adjusted his yardstick for success once again, casually declaring that, actually, maybe 100,000 people will die.

Speaking to reporters before departing for a weekend at Camp David, Trump shared that “hopefully we’re going to come in under 100,000 lives lost,” and if that’s the case, it’ll mean he saved something like 1 millions lives, or 1.5 million or hey, let’s just call it 2.5 million lives.

READ MORE

People hold signs during a protest against coronavirus lockdown measures in Chicago, Illinois. (photo: Kamil Krzaczyński/AFP/Getty Images)

Auschwitz Memorial Condemns Presence of Nazi Slogan at US Anti-Lockdown Rally
Jedidajah Otte, Guardian UK
Otte writes: "The organization that runs the Auschwitz memorial has condemned the appearance at a US anti-lockdown rally of a picket sign bearing a Nazi slogan displayed above the entrance of the concentration camp."

HORRIFYING EXCERPT:

Holocaust survivors often describe the slogan as a reminder of the many ways in which the Nazis tried to give their prisoners false hope, with the inscription suggesting to the people arriving at the camps that hard work would eventually secure their release, when their deaths were already certain.

The long, curving iron sign spanning the gates of Auschwitz is perhaps the best known version of the slogan. It was stolen by thieves from the death camp’s memorial site in Poland in 2009, but recovered by police and returned a month later.

Pritzker, a Democrat, has repeatedly emphasised the need for an extensive test-and-trace programme across the state before lockdown measures can be lifted, and ordered all Illinois residents to shelter in place from 21 March.

He subsequently extended the order until at least 31 May, a decision that could be overruled by the courts after the Republican lawmaker Darren Bailey filed a lawsuit alleging Pritzker did not have the legal authority to extend it beyond 30 days.

David Harris, CEO of the American Jewish Committee, said in a tweet: “Those words – Work Sets You Free – were a savage Nazi hoax for slave labor and gas chambers. JB in the sign refers to state’s Jewish governor. Shameful. Shocking. Sickening.”

READ MORE

University of Illinois at Chicago graduate workers and supporters during a strike in 2019. (photo: Dawn Tefft)

Unions Can Fight for and Win COVID-19 Protections
Zukhra Kasimova and Dawn Tefft, Jacobin
Excerpt: "Workers at the University of Illinois at Chicago (UIC) have bargained what we believe are the first set of wins for a graduate union negotiating the effects of COVID-19. It was our winning strike last year that made our employer realize it should come to the table and give us what we demanded."
READ MORE

CDC's laboratory test kit for severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2). (photo: CDC)

Colorado Purchased 100K Covid-19 Tests From South Korea and 'Kept It Under Wraps' to Avoid Feds Seizure, Says Governor
Aila Slisco, Newsweek
Slisco writes: "Colorado Governor Jared Polis did not announce that the state recently received over 100,000 coronavirus test kits from South Korea over fears that federal authorities could seize them."

Multiple instances of feds seizing state supplies of tests and personal protective equipment have been reported since the COVID-19 pandemic began. Polis said on Friday that Colorado kept their latest shipment hidden because the state did not want to lose the tests to "the competition."

"We were worried that the federal government or somebody else would take them," the governor told Colorado Public Radio. "We kept it under wraps. We simply didn't know if anybody would swoop in... I mean, we didn't want another state or the feds or anybody."

"We don't want to give the competition, which could mean other countries, could mean our own country, could mean other states—we don't want to give them a heads up of what we're doing," he added.

Colorado is not the only state government to act out of concern that supplies could be taken by the federal government or others. Maryland Governor Larry Hogan told The Washington Post on Thursday that members of the Maryland National Guard and state police were at an "undisclosed location" protecting 500,000 tests that had recently arrived from South Korea.

Polis said that the state had previously attempted to buy a supply of ventilators but was unable to do so because the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) intervened to take control of supplies of the potentially life-saving medical equipment.

"With regard to a ventilator acquisition... we were basically told by the legitimate company and the CEO that, look, FEMA has delayed all the state orders," Polis said. "So, you know, it's not canceled. Maybe you'll get it someday in six months. But basically, FEMA is buying our entire production for four months. We can't fulfill yours."

Polis said that testing has rapidly increased in the state. He noted that the virus is often spread by people who are infected but asymptomatic and said the state would focus on testing workers in assisted living facilities regardless of symptoms. He also suggested that people who think they may have contracted the virus getting tested was of limited value, saying it provides "no clinical benefit."

The governor recently lifted his stay-at-home order in favor of a "safer-at-home" order that began this week. Businesses like salons and in-person shopping at retail stores were allowed to resume Friday. Polling has suggested that clear majority of Colorado residents would rather the stay-at-home order be continued.

Newsweek reached out to Polis for comment but did not receive a response in time for publication.

READ MORE

Smokes rises from forest fires in Altamira, Pará state, Brazil, in the Amazon basin, on August 27, 2019. (photo: Joao Laet/Getty)

Coronavirus: Amazon Deforestation Could Trigger New Pandemics, Experts Warn Amid Fears Over Brazilian Land Ownership Law
Andy Gregory, The Independent
Andy Gregory writes: "The Brazilian government is seeking to use coronavirus as cover to usher in laws which could lead to increased occupation of indigenous lands and deforestation in the Amazon, campaigners and experts allege, amid warnings that further environmental disruption may lead to new pandemics."

‘We run the risk of a serious environmental reverse during this crisis’, former environment agency chief warns

The country has been divided on the severity of Covid-19, with president Jair Bolsonaro dismissing it as “a little flu” and opposing lockdown measures, for which public support is waning, despite mass graves being dug in Sao Paulo in the face of rising fatalities.

While the crisis has seen most industries grind to a standstill, government data suggests deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon rose 30 per cent in March compared to the same period last year, with the most recent data suggesting the trend has continued in April.

Sharing the full story, not just the headlines

There has also been a reported increase in forays into some indigenous lands by miners and land-grabbers, as both civil and official protection efforts are scaled back for fear of infection.

Against this backdrop, scientists are issuing renewed warnings that ecological disruption can increase the chance of novel infections crossing over to humans – known as “zoonotic” diseases.

“Approximately one in three outbreaks of new and emerging illnesses is linked to changes in land use, like deforestation,” Peter Daszak, president of EcoHealth Alliance, told Mongabay.

Dr Daszak was lead author in a vast US government-backed study published in 2019 which noted that HIV, Ebola and Zika virus are all “diseases causally linked to land change use”.

Some experts suggest the Amazon is a particularly high-risk location for novel outbreaks.

“Where you have a huge biodiverse zone, the Amazon, and then you have an encroaching human footprint, through urbanisation, road networks, deforestation, extractive industries like logging and mining, you have all of the ingredients for a virus spillover recipe,” David Wolking, of the University of California’s One Health Institute told Greenpeace’s investigative arm, Unearthed.

Wildfires, often caused by slash-and-burn deforestation tactics, can also play a role in the emergence of new diseases.

Notably, some researchers now credit the huge fires in Indonesia in 1998 with the arrival of Nipah virus – with vast smoke clouds forcing fruit bats to search elsewhere for food, settling on trees in Malaysian orchards. Pigs eating the same fruit soon fell ill, with farmers following suit shortly afterwards.

With the Amazon suffering its worst fire season in a decade in 2019, more than a dozen international experts convened to offer a stark warning.

“The Amazon region of Brazil, endemic for many communicable or zoonotic diseases can, after a wildfire, trigger a selection for survival, and with it change the habitat and behaviours of some animal species,” they wrote. ”These can be reservoirs of zoonotic bacteria, viruses, and parasites.”

Amid these warnings, Brazilian congress could soon hold a digital-only vote – using emergency processes introduced to allow more rapid decision-making during the Covid-19 crisis – on enshrining temporary legislation into permanent law, which campaigners warn would legitimise historic land-grabs and facilitate new invasions, paving the way for further deforestation.

As a result, the 120-day Provisional Measure (MP) 910, decreed by Mr Bolsonaro in December, may now be passed as a permanent measure within the next three weeks without being subjected to typical levels of debate and scrutiny, environmentalists allege.

The Bolsonaro administration has said the new land ownership rules will grant legal titles to farmers who have occupied federal lands in a “tame and peaceful way for many years”, enabling them to “rise above subsistence farming and improve their income”.

It insists the new law in “no way” facilitates land-grabbing or deforestation, arguing that new landowners will be held strictly accountable for the preservation of up to 80 per cent of their land.

But analysts warn that the new legislation allows huge swathes of land illegally cut down and occupied before 2018 – often by criminal gangs – to be legally seized by land-grabbers using evidence of their illegal activities as proof of their occupation.

Meanwhile, a new rule called IN 09, passed last week by the government’s indigenous agency Funai, strips yet-to-be-demarcated but indigenous lands of their designation as “indigenous” in the land registry, according to Greenpeace.

Roughly a third of all indigenous land is not yet demarcated, the group says. In 2019, the BBC reported that more than 800,000 indigenous people lived in 450 demarcated indigenous territories, which accounted for 12 per cent of the country’s total land area.

These new changes will allow people occupying indigenous land – usually for the purpose of deforestation and agriculture or mining – to obtain a certificate that the land is undemarcated.

Under the proposed new law, MP 910, this certificate could then be used in support of a land-grabber’s claim to legalise property on that land, and eventually purchase for a fraction of the value without bidding against other parties.

The former head of the country’s environment agency has also warned that sections of the proposed law which supposedly benefit small farmers – by scrapping the need for official inspections of land under 2,500 hectares ahead of a potential acquisition – could be exploited as loopholes by large-scale land-grabbers.

The government says it will stop proxy ownership by larger parties – who it is feared could use small landowners to acquire it for them without official assessment - by banning the sale of newly acquired land for the first 10 years.

“With this flexibility, and without separating big landowners from small ones, this law legalises those who live from land invasion, deforestation and the sale of public land,” Suely Araujo, former president of Ibama, told Mongabay.

She added: “If there isn’t a political decision to withdraw MP 910 from the measures to be voted through, we run the risk of a serious environmental reverse during this [health] crisis.”

The 2018 cut-off date would be the second extension of an initial 2004 cut-off, which campaigners fear would embolden land-grabbers with the promise of continually renewed amnesty for past crimes.

As a result, the new law could lead to the deforestation of an additional 1.6 million hectares – an area larger than Yemen – by 2027, conservation research organisation Imazon estimates.

“If passed, it would be a hard blow against any hope that there will be any regaining control and fighting deforestation,” Brenda Brito, a lawyer and researcher at Imazon, told Unearthed.

“It will, in fact, be the end of that hope, if anyone is still hopeful that the current government will actually face and fight deforestation. Because this measure will end up stimulating even more than is happening now.”

READ MORE

---

Contribute to RSN 

Update My Monthly Donation