Beyond Roe: How one heartbroken mother changed abortion law

Chronicling the next chapter in America's battle over abortion rights. By Stephanie Ebbert, Globe Staff How one heartbroken mother changed abortion law  It’s rare for one person’s story to drive policy change, rarer still when that story is about abortion, an experience many might prefer not to talk about at all in this unforgiving political environment. The deeply personal story of 39-year-old Boston mother Kate Dineen, told by my colleague Shirley Leung, has been broadly credited for changing minds and driving the recent expansion of the Massachusetts’ abortion law. “This law would not have changed without Kate,” said Rebecca Hart Holder, executive director of Reproductive Equity Now, one of the groups that advocated for the legislative changes. “Kate was the real person who suffered the real crisis, who put herself on the line.” When I first heard about Dineen’s case, I’ll admit, I was skeptical. It’s not that I doubted such sad circumstances, as so many deniers do these days (ahem, Ohio.) I thought Massachusetts lawmakers had already addressed them. The ROE Act, enacted at the end of 2020, expanded exceptions for late abortions so that a patient would not have to carry a doomed pregnancy to term. Until then, Massachusetts law had only allowed abortion after 24 weeks when it was necessary to protect a woman’s life or health; the ROE Act added exceptions for cases of fatal fetal anomalies. But as Dineen demonstrated, the exceptions didn’t always apply. Already the mother of an 18-month-old son, she was eight months pregnant when she got the devastating diagnosis: Her fetus had suffered a catastrophic stroke and, even if he survived, was likely to live a short and painful life. “How could I ever put my child through this type of joyless existence?” Dineen recalled thinking when I spoke to her on Thursday. This was not the “abortion on demand until birth” that abortion opponents like to claim is happening. This was a “no-choice choice,” as Dineen put it. “I knew a termination was the way I could protect my son from pain and suffering and it was a loving choice,” she added. “But it was a profound loss.” But Massachusetts General Hospital was unwilling to abort her pregnancy if there was a chance of survival, which they estimated was 50 percent.  So she and her husband drove 500 miles to one of the few clinics in the country that performs late abortions — contrary to what abortion opponents suggest is the norm — and spent $8,000 on the procedure. “I had all the resources I could imagine and it was still incredibly difficult for me to access that care,” Dineen recalled. When it became clear that the Supreme Court was going to overturn constitutional protections for abortion, Dineen began speaking out in the hope that Massachusetts lawmakers would give the ROE Act a second look and broaden its protections. It didn’t hurt that she was politically savvy, having worked in New York state government before returning to her native Massachusetts, where she is a trade group executive and registered Beacon Hill lobbyist. “She knew her way around politics and I think that helped,” Hart Holder said. “But it was more than that. It was a total fearlessness.” Her story, powerfully told, shifted the debate from the theoretical to the personal. “My kids were born at Mass General. That could have been my wife,” State Representative Jay Livingstone, a Boston Democrat and lead sponsor of the Roe Act, told Leung. Initially, there wasn’t much political will to revisit the ROE Act, which was passed after an ugly fight, with its sponsors accused of promoting infanticide by the Massachusetts Republican Party.  Governor Charlie Baker, a Republican who supports abortion rights and is far more moderate than his party, had vetoed the Roe Act, taking exception to certain provisions such as allowing more exceptions to the ban after 24 weeks. But after lawmakers negotiated language expanding exceptions to cases like Dineen’s — as well as a host of other measures to broaden abortion access after the Supreme Court ruling — Baker not only signed the law. He signed it twice, holding a second ceremony Tuesday where he was surrounded by left-leaning lawmakers and abortion rights advocates, including Dineen. After the event, he handed Dineen one of the ceremonial pens. “I’m not sure if somebody’s given you one of these yet,” Dineen recalled Baker saying, “But you should have it.”   Kate Dineen, second from right, in a photo provided by Reproductive Equity Now.

 

GOP gov green lights police brutality with fascist law

 

It's Our Democracy!

Today’s Action: Tell Congress to support President Biden’s new Title IX regulations!

---

Former Japanese PM Shinzo Abe assassinated, shooter in custody

Today's Top Stories:

Republican governor makes it illegal to film police at close range in Arizona
The newly signed bill literally criminalizes filming cops for any reason within eight feet in the latest, grievous lunge toward a truly dystopian police state.

Take Action: Call on Congress to ban police from using phone data to spy on pregnant people!

---

VIDEO OF THE DAY: Rudy Giuliani finally discusses asking Trump for a pardon
Not surprisingly, the disgraced former mayor just ended up making himself sound even more guilty.

---

Supreme Court takes up the SINGLE MOST DANGEROUS case yet
No Lie with Brian Tyler Cohen: OMG.

---

Colorado Democrats step up to protect out-of-state abortion seekers' rights
Colorado Gov. Jared Polis signed a badly needed executive order refusing to cooperate with red states’ investigations into people who received abortions or reproductive healthcare in Colorado. The order also protects Coloradans from being disciplined for performing such services.

Take Action: Join Bernie and Liz Warren and demand a Social Security expansion!

---

Sen. Ron Johnson scrambled to pull mass shooter ad after July 4th shooting
“The latest murder in America didn't involve guns,” the Republican senator said in a recorded campaign radio ad slated to appear on July 6.

Take Action: Expel Ron Johnson for trying to overturn the election with fake Trump electors!

---

Florida man gets off lightly for death threat to Rep. Ilhan Omar
A federal judge sentenced a former Trump supporter to three years of probation and a $7,000 fine for sending an email threatening to kill Rep. Ilhan Omar of Minnesota and three other congresswomen.

---

Prominent evangelical leader and anti-abortion plaintiff caught on a hot mic boasting about praying with SCOTUS justices
Peggy Nienaber, an executive director at Liberty Counsel — a right-wing, anti-abortionist group that has brought numerous cases before the Supreme Court — admitted to praying with SCOTUS justices in "totally off the record" comments.

Take Action: Demand Congress reform the extremist Supreme Court!

---

Ron Johnson admits to trying to overturn the election results in 2020.
OD Action Partner: Ron Johnson admitted to handing Pence a list of fake electors to overturn the election results. United Rural Democrats is committed to electing rural Democrats to office and voting out Trump sycophants like Ron Johnson. Democrats must win small town, main-street America to expand our governing power. United Rural Democrats is leading the charge and needs your help.

---

Gov. Gavin Newsom announces California will make its own insulin
The unapologetic Democrat announced a plan to allocate $100 million in state funding to have the state make its own insulin, stating that: "Nothing epitomizes market failure more than the cost of insulin."

---

West Virginia police gun down mentally unstable man in vicious barrage
In the video, the victim can be seen holding a gun and occasionally pointing it at his own head before being pumped full of bullets by multiple officers.

---

IRS chief refers suspicious audit of Trump foes James Comey, Andy McCabe to inspector general
The commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service has asked an internal watchdog to probe what many suspect may have been a targeted political hit from the infamously vindictive ex-president.

---

Officer who killed 12-year-old Tamir Rice quickly leaves new police job after two days
Timothy Loehmann, the former Cleveland police officer who fatally shot 12-year-old Tamir Rice in 2014 swiftly left the one-man police force of Tioga, Pennsylvania, amid intense backlash to his tone-deaf hiring.

Take Action: Tell Big Tech companies to keep abortion data away from the cops!

---

---

Red, white, and blue

Legendary actor James Caan dies at 82

San Francisco school district spends $525K on racist mural fight

8-year-old July 4th shooting victim paralyzed from the waist down

Sacha Baron Cohen defeats defamation suit filed by Roy Moore

Derek Chauvin gets 20 years for violating George Floyd's rights

Theranos exec Sunny Balwani convicted of fraud

The Daily Planet

Russian ruble drops 17% amid falling exports, rumored intervention

EU Parliament condemns US abortion ruling, seeks safeguards

Nigerian air force mistakenly bombs civilians

Nicaragua expels Mother Teresa's nuns in latest crackdown

Brittney Griner pleads guilty to drug charges in Russian court

Hope...

GoodGoodGood: 21 ways to give back to your community

TikTok users offer haven to those seeking out-of-state abortions

University of Arizona offers free college tuition to Native Americans

Scientists clone first mice from freeze-dried skin cells

Shapeshifting robots could automate teeth brushing and flossing

---

Today’s Action: Tell Congress to support President Biden’s new Title IX regulations!

Last month, on the 50th anniversary of Title IX, President Biden announced plans to reinstate critical regulations tossed out by the Trump administration. The Department of Education announced that the revamped amendments would “make clear that preventing someone from participating in school programs and activities consistent with their gender identity would cause harm in violation of Title IX, except in some limited areas set out in the statute or regulations.” The change would protect abuse victims AND transgender students made needlessly more vulnerable by Donald Trump.

A strong Title IX, which protects students from sexual discrimination in educational settings, is absolutely critical in making our communities safe and inclusive. This correction is long past due.

Biden’s announcement made it clear where Democrats stand on sex- and gender-based discrimination, stating that “millions of women and girls have benefited from the changes that Title IX helped make possible.” He’s right — Title IX has provided countless students with more equitable opportunities. The Trump administration’s peel back of victim protections prevented survivors of sexual assault from receiving justice for years. It’s high time to take that power back!

Call (202-224-3121) or write your members of Congress and call on them to support Biden’s new Title IX regulations!

PS — Please don't forget to sign the petition demanding Congress ban AR-15s and other assault rifles, and be sure to follow OD Action on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram.

     @advocacy | 1002 Hull St., Louisville, KY 40204