The time to contextualize the fatal shooting of Charlie Kirk is ... not now& reflections on the emergence of a real-life Babel fish9-11-2025 (issue No. 209) This week:
Let’s pause for a moment before rushing to our partisan ramparts to opine about the slaying of Charlie KirkThe assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk on Wednesday at an event at Utah Valley University is frightening and deplorable. It marks yet another ominous escalation of political violence. All decent people must condemn it today without reservation or qualification. All decent people must at least for the moment resist the temptation to blame, contextualize or engage in whataboutism. There will be time for that later. What needs saying now is that physically attacking people for their political beliefs is always wrong, and countenancing it in any way will likely lead only to more violence. I followed social media intently in the aftermath of the shooting and was additionally sickened by the finger-pointing and fury from both ends of the political spectrum. There are hypocrites and heartless ghouls on the left and the right, but they should knock off the ululations and accusations for a bit. Now is the time to lower the national temperature and de-escalate the tensions that threaten democracy itself. David Graham put it well in The Atlantic:
Former Republican U.S. Rep. Adam Kinzinger of Illinois offered these thoughts in a video:
Chicago Teacher’s Union President Stacy Davis Gates also met the moment:
Inevitably, President Donald Trump failed another test of leadership by again driving a toxic wedge into our partisan divide rather than attempt a unifying message condemning all such violence: “For years, those on the radical left have compared wonderful Americans like Charlie to Nazis and the world’s worst mass murderers and criminals,” he said in a video address Wednesday. “This kind of rhetoric is directly responsible for the terrorism that we’re seeing in our country today.” I have some thoughts about that. But they can wait. Apple goes Babel fishin’In Douglas Adams’ late 1970s comic science-fiction novels “The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy,” the Babel fish is a tiny creature you can stick in your ear that instantly translates any spoken tongue into a language you can understand. Babel is a reference to the story in Genesis 11 that explains why there are so many languages in the world by advancing the myth that there was once just one language, but that God was concerned by the efforts of humans to build a mighty tower in Babylon and said, “If as one people speaking the same language they have begun to do this, then nothing they plan to do will be impossible for them. Come, let us go down and confuse their language so they will not understand each other.” The fictional Babel fish undid this purported divine act of confusion, and now modern technology is catching up with Adams’ vision. Earlier this year we read of Meta AI’s effort at instantaneous translation.
Other, similar efforts are underway, but Apple’s announcement this week that Air Pod Pros will incorporate an instant-translation feature when linked to the newer version of iPhones looks like it could be a game-changer, given the ubiquity of Apple devices. Two or more people with iPhones will be able to have real-time conversations even when they don’t speak the same language. The utilitarian reasons for studying foreign languages stand to dramatically recede. We all know people who studied Mandarin, Spanish, French or other language for professional reasons — including the ability to become a translator. The value will be in understanding the subtleties of other cultures and the intricate beauty and nuances of language itself. Will that be enough to sustain foreign language departments in high schools and colleges? See:
Last week’s winning quipMy wife: You need to do more chores around the house. Me: Can we change the subject? My wife: OK. More chores around the house need to be done by you. — @ThePunnyWorldI received a complaint that this quip and some others in earlier contests are sexist for how they rely on Lockhorns-like stereotypes of nagging and oversensitive women and indolent, obtuse men. I try not to use quips that punch down, and I don’t think this one does. I could have edited this to change “My wife” to “My spouse” without losing any of the bite of the punch line. Should I have? Here are this week’s nominees and the winner of the Tuesday visual-jokes poll. Here is the direct link to the new poll. News & ViewsNews: President Donald Trump again appears to be backing off his threat to send National Guard troops to Chicago.View: Predictable, really. ““We’re going to be announcing another city that we’re going to very shortly, working it out with the governor of a certain state who would love us to be there, and the mayor of a certain city in the same state that would love us to be there. “We’ll announce it probably (Wednesday), and it’s going to be something we will do like we did (in Washington, D.C.” Trump doesn’t want the court fight that he’d probably lose over a National Guard occupation. Any claim that there is an emergency that the Guard needs to address in Chicago grows weaker by the day. And as of late Wednesday, I’ve seen no news that Trump has announced which city he’s going to send the Guard to. News: Ald. Brendan Reilly, 42nd, announces a challenge to Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle in next year’s Democratic primary.View: Good. I don’t yet know who I’ll vote for, but Preckwinkle, seeking her fifth term at age 78, hasn’t had a serious primary challenger in the last three election cycles. Reilly, 53, who has represented his downtown ward since 2007, calls himself a centrist Democrat and will run at least slightly to Preckwinkle’s right. The debates will be interesting. News: Saudis are paying tens of millions of dollars in investment fees to presidential son-in-law Jared KushnerView: When Hunter Biden took advantage of his family name to make money from a foreign concern, Republicans lost their shit. But when Jared Kushner does it … crickets. News: City crews are removing homeless encampments in ChicagoView: I’m reminded of the Anatole France quote, “The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges.” We must give the dispossessed a better option, not just move the problem along to some other neighborhood, park or viaduct. Land of Linkin’
Squaring up the newsThis is a bonus supplement to the Land of Linkin’ from veteran radio, internet and newspaper journalist Charlie Meyerson. Each week, he offers a selection of intriguing links from his daily email news briefing Chicago Public Square: ■ TV critic Bill Carter: After five weeks away from “The Daily Show,” Jon Stewart went right for the president’s jugular—masterfully comparing Donald Trump to a classic “Twilight Zone” episode in which a 6-year-old boy terrifies a town by sending anyone who angers him “to the cornfield.” ■ The comparison proves spot-on. See for yourself. ■ Charlie Warzel at The Atlantic: Trump’s creepy “wonderful secret” sketch for dead sexual predator Jeffrey Epstein “is far from the most disturbing or lecherous of the book’s contents,” which you can see it here. ■ Public Notice columnist Noah Berlatsky: Trump dreams of making Chicago a colony … and Berlatsky’s colleague, Liz Dye, sees in the Supreme Court’s decision “allowing ICE to snatch any non-white person off the street and lock them up until they ‘prove’ their citizenship” Justice Brett Kavanaugh explaining “that SCOTUS really IS doing racism. He showed his whole hood.” ■ The Washington Post (gift link, possible because readers support Square with a buck or two): The National Guard’s own internal documents show troops’ “shame and alarm” over their domestic deployments. ■ Riding along with ICE in Chicago: A confrontational social media troll. ■ McSweeney’s ridicules those using Chicago as a talking point for the nation’s problems. ■ Also from McSweeney’s: “ICE’s training manual for determining who to terrorize.” ■ Interested in accompanying at-risk people to court or ICE check-ins? Volunteer here. ■ What First Amendment? Homeland Security says recording video of immigration agents constitutes a prosecutable act of “violence” … ■ … as Trump complained that domestic violence is counted as a crime: “Things that take place in the home they call crime. … If a man has a little fight with the wife, they say this is a crime.” ■ The only way Democrats can resist “the Trump catastrophe”: Count ex-U.S. Labor Secretary Robert Reich among those calling for a government shutdown. ■ Columnist Christopher Armitage says Democratic-led states should “cut the failed red states loose.” ■ HuffPost: What alarms docs the most about COVID right now. ■ Lyz Lenz’s Dingus of the Week: Author and podcaster Malcolm Gladwell, “whose work has been repeatedly debunked by legions of exhausted social scientists, but who somehow still gets heralded as a genius.” You can (and should) subscribe to Chicago Public Square free here. Media notesCBS is dead to me, a story in four partsPart I of my disaffection with CBS News came in July when CBS’ parent company Paramount paid $16 million to President Donald Trump’s future presidential library to settle a blatantly and brazenly phony lawsuit that the network would have won easily. That suit claimed that the news division had committed “election and voter interference” in how it edited a “60 Minutes” interview with Kamala Harris. The extortion payment — how else can you possibly frame it? — was to grease the way for government approval of Paramount’s merger with Skydance. Part II was this story: “CBS forbids editing of ‘Face the Nation’ interviews after complaints from Kristi Noem.” In response to whining from the right, the network has agreed to run every “Face the Nation” interview without the normal sorts of tucks and trims that allow them to keep segments on track and prevent guests from lobbing wildly unfounded accusations, as Noem did about Kilmar Abrego Garcia. Part III was newly merged Skydance/Paramount’s announcement that the company had hired Kenneth Weinstein, former head of the conservative Hudson Institute think tank, to be the ombudsman for CBS news. Agreeing to hire an ombudsman was part of the merger deal. Weinstein has no experience working in a news organization and is “a frequent critic of the Biden administration, once comparing the Biden White House to the bumbling characters of the television show ‘Veep,’” according to The New York Times. Weinstein was Trump’s ambassador to Japan and “donated roughly $40,000 to Republican and pro-Trump political groups last year.” And Part IV are reports that Skydance/Paramount is close to a deal to purchase Bari Weiss’ right-leaning news site “The Free Press” and install her in a leadership role at CBS News, editor in chief or co-president of the network, according to the New York Times. Weiss, 41, preens as a free-speech, tell-it-like-it-is journalist, but her site feels more and more Trump-friendly by the day. Quoting The Unpopulist:
Jay Michaelson’s lengthy “Bari Weiss’s Remarkably Successful Shell Game —The Right's favorite reactionary centrist prepares to take over a major news organization” is worth a read:
So, once again with even more gusto, here’s me to CBS: Trib turmoilLizzie Kane quitsReporter Lizzie Kane, who was doing outstanding work covering housing for the Tribune, was laid off July 24 and rehired Aug. 11. Last Friday (Sept. 5), she posted to social media, “We thought we had reached a mutually beneficial agreement for my return. We had not. I think it's time for me to move on. I accepted a buyout and today is my last day with the Chicago Tribune.” Newsroom union accuses management of anti-Muslim bias in layoffs
“Alden” refers to Alden Global Capital, the vulturous and secretive hedge fund that owns the Tribune. From a previous union post, the laid-off employees were:
So what gives?Kane declined further comment when I reached out to her. And, as is his wont, Tribune editor Mitch Pugh did not respond to my request for comment. Four FM music stations top the most recent local radio ratingsWLIT, WDRV, WXRT and WTMZ are the top four stations in the August Nielsen Audio ratings (hat tip to media blogger Rick Kaempfer). As a former radio columnist, I can tell you that the overall ratings that Nielsen allows to be published are far less important to broadcasters and advertisers than the demographic and day-part cross tabs. Disclosure: My wife is on temporary assignment as a news editor at Chicago Public Media (the Sun-Times and WBEZ). QuotablesA collection of compelling, sometimes appalling passages I’ve encountered lately
Cheer chatUpdate on preparations for the 27th annual “Songs of Good Cheer,” the winter holiday singalongs at the Old Town School of Folk Music hosted by me and Mary Schmich. The dates for this year’s shows are Thursday, Dec. 11 through Sunday Dec. 14, with two shows on Saturday. Tickets are not yet available, but watch this space. QuipsIn Tuesday’s paid-subscriber editions, I present my favorite tweets that rely on visual humor. Subscribers then vote for their favorite. Here is the winner from this week’s contest: The new nominees for Quip of the Week:
Vote here and check the current results in the poll. For instructions and guidelines regarding the poll, click here. Why “quips”? See “I’m rebranding ‘Tweet of the Week’ in a gesture of contempt for Elon Musk.” Also, I’m finding good stuff on BlueSky now as well. Minced WordsCate Plys, Austin Berg and I joined host John Williams on this week’s episode of “The Mincing Rascals” podcast. News of the shooting of conservative activist Charlie Kirk was breaking as we began recording, and we discussed that as well as other stories in the news. Traffic lights:
Subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. Or bookmark this page. If you’re not a podcast listener, you can hear an edited version of the show at 8 p.m. most Saturday evenings on WGN-AM 720. Read the background bios of some regular panelists here. Good SportsYep“I hate that this game basically feels like every Bears game I've ever watched” tweeted CBS Sports’ social media producer Monday night as the Bears’ seemingly inevitable collapse against the Minnesota Vikings was underway. Tough business, footballThe San Francisco 49ers waived placekicker Jake Moody after he missed a 27-yard field goal during Sunday’s victory over the Seahawks. News reports said he made both extra points but was 1 for 3 from the field — unfairly blaming him for an offensive line breakdown that saw a 36-yard attempt blocked in the third quarter. True, he did miss a chip shot during the game and also true that he had a fairly rough year last season. But he did make two outside of 50 yards in the 2024 Super Bowl (and missed one of two extra points), and the Niners had decided to stick with him this season. Stray thought“Hall of Fame” is an odd term. Great athletes are famous, yes, but famous athletes are not always great. Jeremy Lin, Tim Tebow, Bill Buckner, Mark Fidrych and Johnny Manziel are some names that come to mind of athletes who were plenty famous in their time but will not be inducted into their sport’s hall of fame. Why not “Hall of Honor” or “Hall of Excellence”? Green LightGreen Light features recommendations from me and readers not only of songs — as in the former Tune of the Week post — but also of TV shows, streaming movies, books, podcasts and other diversions that can be enjoyed at home — i.e., no restaurants, plays, theatrical films, tourist sites and so on. Email me your nominations, and please include a paragraph or two of explanation and background along with helpful links, perhaps including excerpts from reviews or background articles. For TV shows, please include links to trailers/previews on YouTube and advice on where to stream them. The death Friday of Mark Volman, 78, co-founder of The Turtles, inspires me to feature the band’s signature hit, “Happy Together,” which made it to No. 1 on Billboard’s Hot 100 in 1967. I was not yet 10 at the time and just getting interested in pop music. I remember distinctly calling the request line at WAAM-AM 1600 in Ann Arbor — then a music station, now a conservative talk outlet — and asking the deejay to play “Imagine Me and You,” which is the first line of the song, not its title. The deejay wearily corrected me. I then waited by the radio for several hours until “Happy Together” came on. The lead singer was Howard Kaylan, also a Turtles co-founder and still alive today at 78. Volman sang harmony. The song is so bouncy it almost makes you forget it’s about unrequited love. The lyric “I can’t see me lovin’ nobody but you” is directed at an apparently indifferent object of affection. “Happy Together” hit the top of the charts in March 1967, knocking off the Beatles’ “Penny Lane.” It stayed there for three weeks before being deposed by Frank and Nancy Sinatra’s “Somethin’ Stupid.” * The band had several lesser-known Top 40 hits and broke up in 1970. What I didn’t know back in 1967 was that most pop music radio stations didn’t see themselves as jukeboxes — they used their request lines for audience research purposes — and “Happy Together” was simply in the rotation. WAAM was going to play “Happy Together” when it played “Happy Together,” whether squeaky, prepubescent, ill-informed Eric wanted to hear it or not. What I don’t know today is if people are still calling radio stations to request songs, and, if so, why. Just about anything they could want to hear is instantly available on YouTube, Spotify or any number of other sites. And if a song is too obscure for the internet, it’s going to be too obscure for a radio station. *Apologies if I put the excruciating “Somethin’ Stupid” in your head InfoEric Zorn is a former opinion columnist for the Chicago Tribune. Find a longer bio and contact information here. This issue exceeds in size the maximum length for a standard email. To read the entire issue in your browser, click on the headline link above. Paid subscribers receive each Picayune Plus in their email inbox each Tuesday, are part of our civil and productive commenting community and enjoy the sublime satisfaction of supporting this enterprise. Browse and search back issues here. ContactYou can email me at ericzorn@gmail.com or by clicking here: I read all the messages that come in, but I do most of my interacting with readers in the comments section beneath each issue. Some of those letters I reprint and respond to in the Z-mail section of Tuesday’s Picayune Plus, which is delivered to paid subscribers and available to all readers later Tuesday. Check there for responses. If you don’t want me to use the full name on your email or your comments, let me know how you’d like to be identified. Social media
Help?If you’re having troubles with Substack — delivery, billing and so forth — first try “Picayune Sentinel Substack help, Frequently Asked Questions.” If that doesn’t work check out the Substack help page. And if that doesn’t work, shoot me an email and I’ll be happy to help. Thanks for reading! |
UNDER CONSTRUCTION - MOVED TO MIDDLEBORO REVIEW AND SO ON https://middlebororeviewandsoon.blogspot.com/
Thursday, September 11, 2025
The time to contextualize the fatal shooting of Charlie Kirk is ... not now
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
WBUR TODAY: Risky business
❤️ Donate Friday, December 5, 2025 ☀️ Sunny, with a high near 26. Good Morning Boston, It's Friday! You may want to leave early i...
-
04 April 23 Live on the homepage now! Reader Supported News Dahlia Lithwick | Let Donald Trump Cry It Out Dahlia Lithwick, Slate Lithwic...
-
A Democrat in the Wilderness Wow! That must have really got him mad!!! I Love it! ...
-
Israel on the Brink as Ultra-Orthodox Exemption from Military Service is Set to End Oakland, Ca. (Special to Informed Comment; Featured) –...












No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.