Wednesday, December 11, 2024

POLITICO Nightly: The growing distrust of the American health care system

 


POLITICO Newsletter Header

By Joanne Kenen



Prescription drugs displayed at NYC Discount Pharmacy.

Prescription drugs displayed at NYC Discount Pharmacy in Manhattan on July 23. | Spencer Platt/Getty ImagesPrescription drugs displayed at NYC Discount Pharmacy.


WARNING SIGNS — Long before a gunman pumped bullets into a UnitedHealthcare executive and was hailed as a folk hero by a startling slice of the American public, the longtime head of the American Board of Internal Medicine found himself increasingly aware of — and alarmed by — the creeping distrust of American health, science and medicine.

Dr. Richard Baron had been a primary care doctor for years, in rural Tennessee and then in a racially and economically mixed neighborhood in Philadelphia. He had felt deeply connected to his community, and the word “community” comes up often in his conversations. But as president and CEO of ABIM and its affiliated foundation, he saw how Americans’ wariness about the health care system was growing, part of a growing sense of distrust and disconnection throughout the country.

“What happens to medicine when the members of the society believe no one has your best interests at heart?” he asked. “It’s a pretty tough place to be.” Particularly when the health care system was growing more corporatized — and more disconnected from communities, he told Nightly in a conversation that took place just as police were closing in on the suspect in the murder of UnitedHealthcare executive Brian Thompson.

Soon after taking the top job at ABIM, Baron had to deal with the organization’s own struggles , after an outcry over changes in how it tested and certified doctors. His efforts to restore trust, combined with his prescient pre-Covid observations about the crumbling of trust in medicine, led him to start a multi-year ABIM Foundation initiative on exploring, researching and repairing trust.

Baron worked on disinformation, which has turned into a mighty online river since Covid. ABIM has also spotlighted how racial inequity in health care — historic and contemporary — has eroded trust, which became more widely recognized during the pandemic. And he’s stressed how the fear of medical debt — a side effect of the opacity of corporate health care decision-making and pricing — deters some patients from seeking needed care.

“Patient-centered care” has become a buzzword in health but for many patients, it feels money-centered. In fact, in shooting suspect Luigi Mangione’s alleged manifesto , he decried big companies like UnitedHealthcare that “abuse our country for immense profit.”

Early on, Baron realized that relying on facts alone to push back on the damage was not going to cut it. “People were willing to give up what I’ll call a fact- based understanding in favor of a kind of emotional relationship-based understanding,” he said. “And the messengers haven’t been paying a lot of attention to their relationship with the communities that they’re trying to message to.”

If you tried to diagram distrust, it would have a whole lot of intersecting arrows pointing in every possible direction.

A big cluster of arrows would point to insurers who have merger-and-acquisitioned themselves into a handful of big firms that are the arbiters of what kind of care a patient can access — or not.

Others would point from doctors and nurses to the money-guys calling the shots at their health care system or practice. From minority communities toward providers. From patients to their doctors — particularly when the physician recommends against a treatment on solid evidence-based grounds but the skeptical patient thinks the doc is in the insurer’s pocket. Arrows would aim at drug companies that develop life saving medicines but with eye-popping prices — and to the subset of pharma firms and drug distributors who flooded communities with opioids while falsely promising that they would do no harm.

Baron retired a few months ago, but trust and communication initiatives he started are ongoing. He knows some of the challenges are unique to medicine. Others reflect larger changes in an angry, polarized country.

“Medicine swims in the same ocean that the rest of the culture does,” said Baron. Attacks on health care personnel in the workplace, both verbal and physical, have become far more common . Last week, on the streets of New York, an angry young man didn’t just point an arrow. He pointed a gun.

Welcome to POLITICO Nightly. Reach out with news, tips and ideas at nightly@politico.com . Or contact tonight’s author on X (formerly known as Twitter) at @JoanneKenen .

 

A message from American Beverage:

America’s beverage companies – The Coca-Cola Company, Keurig Dr Pepper and PepsiCo – are iconic American companies making American products with American workers in America’s hometowns. And we’re committed to doing our part to address today’s health challenges. We’ve taken real steps for more than a decade to transform the beverage aisle, like offering smaller portion sizes, more zero-sugar options and putting nutrition information right up front. Explore more at BalanceUS.org.

 
What'd I Miss?

— Biden threatens to veto bill that would have given Trump new judicial appointments : Donald Trump is eager to appoint dozens of new judges once he becomes president. Joe Biden has other plans. The president threatened to veto a bill to expand the number of federal judges because he doesn’t want to give the president-elect new appointment opportunities, one of the outgoing president’s closest allies said in an interview. The move dooms legislation spearheaded by Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.), who had spent months pushing for the creation of 63 new judgeships.

— Time magazine to name Trump ‘Person of the Year’: Donald Trump is expected to be named Time magazine’s “Person of the Year” — and to celebrate the unveiling of the cover, the president-elect will ring the opening bell of the New York Stock Exchange on Thursday morning, according to three people familiar with the plans granted anonymity because they were not authorized to divulge the plans. Trump was also named Time Person of the Year in 2016 after he won the presidential election. He joins 13 other U.S. presidents who have received the recognition, including President Joe Biden.

WHILE THE ASSAULT IN INEXCUSABLE, REP. NANCY MACE HAS BEEN PROVOCATIVE & HATE FILLED IN HER COMMENTS...THE REST OF THE WORLD IS FILLED WITH UNISEX BATHROOMS...MAYBE NANCY MACE NEEDS TO TRAVEL MORE....

— Capitol Police arrest person in alleged assault on member of Congress: The U.S. Capitol Police have arrested 33-year-old James McIntyre for an alleged assault on Rep. Nancy Mace on Tuesday night in the Rayburn Office Building, according to the department. Capitol Police, in a statement, said they responded to an incident reported by a member’s office just before 6 p.m. on Tuesday. McIntyre is facing a misdemeanor charge for assaulting a government official, according to the department, though charging decisions are ultimately up to the U.S. attorney’s office.

 

Billions in spending. Critical foreign aid. Immigration reform. The final weeks of 2024 could bring major policy changes. Inside Congress provides daily insights into how Congressional leaders are navigating these high-stakes issues. Subscribe today .

 
 
THE NEXT ADMINISTRATION

KASH PATEL NEEDS FBI BACKGROUND CHECKS & SECURITY CHECKS....lots of issues are not being addressed!

WRAY OUT 
— FBI Director Christopher Wray, who has faced withering criticism from President-elect Donald Trump and Republican lawmakers, announced today that he plans to resign next month . Trump announced late last month that he intends to nominate former National Security Council official and GOP congressional aide Kash Patel to serve as FBI director. If confirmed by the Senate, he would replace Wray, who was appointed by Trump in 2017 and is serving a 10-year term that expires in 2027.

 

A message from American Beverage:

 
AROUND THE WORLD
Poland's Prime Minister Donald Tusk delivers a statement to the media with French President Emmanuel Macron as part of their meeting at the Elysee Palace in Paris, Monday, Feb. 12, 2024 . Tusk was traveling to Paris and Berlin in a diplomatic effort to rebuild key alliances as fears grow that former President Donald Trump could return to power in the United States and give Russia a free hand to expand its aggression in Europe. (Christophe Petit-Tesson/Pool Photo via AP)

Poland's Prime Minister Donald Tusk delivers a statement to the media with French President Emmanuel Macron as part of a meeting at the Elysee Palace in Paris in February. | Pool photo by Christophe Petit-TessonPoland's Prime Minister Donald Tusk delivers a statement to the media with French President Emmanuel Macron as part of their meeting at the Elysee Palace in Paris, Monday, Feb. 12, 2024 . Tusk was traveling to Paris and Berlin in a diplomatic effort to rebuild key alliances as fears grow that former President Donald Trump could return to power in the United States and give Russia a free hand to expand its aggression in Europe. (Christophe
 Petit-Tesson/Pool Photo via AP)


POSTWAR PLANS French President Emmanuel Macron will discuss with Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk the deployment of a postwar peacekeeping force in Ukraine when the two meet in Warsaw on Thursday, a European Union diplomat and a French official told POLITICO.

The meeting of the two EU heavyweights comes amid increasing fears that the incoming administration of Donald Trump will force the Europeans to pick up more of the military responsibilities in Ukraine.

“It is true,” confirmed the EU diplomat when asked about a Polish media report in the Rzeczpospolita newspaper claiming the two countries were talking over a potential 40,000-strong peacekeeping force composed of troops from foreign countries. The diplomat did not elaborate on which countries the soldiers might come from.

FOOL ME ONCE Emmanuel Macron told leaders from across the political spectrum he will not appoint a new prime minister whose survival depends on the far-right National Rally after it spurned Michel Barnier and voted to bring down his government after just three months, according to the French president’s office.

Toppling Barnier, Macron told his ministers today, “was a serious choice, a choice that will have consequences,” government spokesperson Maud Bregeon told reporters.

Macron is expected to name a new premier by the end of the day Thursday to replace Barnier. Several names have been floated in the French press, but the leading rumor suggests he may appoint one of his earliest supporters, centrist François Bayrou. However, representatives from different left-wing parties have already made clear that they are against Bayrou’s potential appointment.

UK BANS PUBERTY BLOCKERS — The British government indefinitely banned the use of puberty blockers by people under 18 years of age today after expert advice flagged an "unacceptable safety risk" in their use. Puberty blockers stopped being routinely prescribed to under-18s with gender dysphoria in the U.K. in March and were temporarily banned in May this year by the previous Conservative government. This prevented their prescription by European or private prescribers. National Health Service provision was restricted to clinical trials.

The Department for Health and Social Care has now received advice from the government-ordered Commission on Human Medicines and today backed its recommendation to restrict their use and supply indefinitely while further work is done to ensure young people’s safety.

An earlier U.K. review into gender identity services found that studies about treatment for gender dysphoria were unreliable and there was a lack of attention paid to patients seeking to halt or reverse the gender transition process. New legislation will make the ban indefinite and be reviewed in 2027.

 

Write your own chapter in the new Washington. From the Lame Duck Congress Series to New Administration insights, POLITICO Pro delivers intelligence across 22+ policy areas to help you anticipate and navigate change. Discover how a Pro subscription empowers you. Learn more today .

 
 
Nightly Number

$135 million

The amount in grants that the Environmental Protection Agency is awarding to California in order to help the state wean off fossil fuels and phase out big rigs that run on diesel, EPA officials announced today.

MUST READ!

EXCERPT:

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — The Environmental Protection Agency is awarding $135 million in grants to fund 13 projects in California to help the state wean off fossil fuels and phase out big rigs that run on diesel.

The money will go to the state transportation department, cities and school districts, among others, to purchase 455 zero-emission vehicles to replace diesel-powered trucks, school buses and other large vehicles. It is part an EPA program that provides a total of $735 million to 70 projects across the country, officials announced Wednesday.

The grants are paid for by the 2022 climate law approved by congressional Democrats. The law, officially known as the Inflation Reduction Act, includes nearly $400 billion in spending and tax credits to accelerate the expansion of clean energy such as wind and solar power, speeding the nation’s transition away from the oil, coal and natural gas that largely cause climate change.

The funds, to be delivered in early 2025, “will reduce air pollution, improve health outcomes in nearby communities, and advance the campaign to tackle climate change,” EPA Pacific Southwest Regional Administrator Martha Guzman said in a statement.

RADAR SWEEP

AGE APPROPRIATE — As the migrant crisis worsens across Europe, border officials are increasingly turning to medical examinations to determine asylum seekers’ age . Through a series of medical assessments, they believe they can often figure out how old an asylum seeker without proper documentation is — most notably, they can decide if they are a child or an adult. But the practice of quickly trying to guess at someone’s age based on their medical information is deeply flawed. And inconsistencies within the system are often mixing up age groups and leaving legal children at the mercy of an adult asylum process. Unaccompanied children are regularly given asylum priority or distinct treatment — but as countries try to crack down on adults claiming they’re minors, other issues begin to arise. Will Coldwell reports for The Dial.

Parting Image
On this date in 1941: Speaker of the House Sam Rayburn (rear) presides over the House of Representatives as Irving W. Swanson reads President Franklin D. Roosevelt's plea for a declaration of war against Germany. The U.S. formally declared war against Germany and Italy three days after doing so against Japan.

On this date in 1941: Speaker of the House Sam Rayburn (rear) presides over the House of Representatives as Irving W. Swanson reads President Franklin D. Roosevelt's plea for a declaration of war against Germany. The U.S. formally declared war against Germany and Italy three days after doing so against Japan. | APOn this date in 1941: Speaker of the House Sam Rayburn (rear) presides over the House of Representatives as Irving W. Swanson reads President Franklin D. Roosevelt's plea for a declaration of war against Germany. The U.S. formally declared war against Germany and Italy three days after doing so against Japan.


Did someone forward this email to you?  Sign up here .

 

A message from American Beverage:

America’s beverage companies are committed to delivering families the freedom to choose the beverage that’s right for them. And it’s working. Thanks to our innovation, nearly 60% of the beverages Americans buy have no sugar or calories.

Our commitment to helping Americans find the right balance for them includes:
· Offering more than 600 brands with less sugar or no sugar at all.
· Putting clear calorie labels on the front of every bottle, can and pack.
· Encouraging consumers to think about balance with signs on coolers and displays in store.
· Voluntarily removing full-calorie beverages from schools through our National School Beverage Guidelines, which cut beverage calories in schools by 94%. In fact, the USDA Smart Snacks in Schools Beverage Guidelines were largely based on these guidelines.

Learn more at BalanceUS.org.

 
 

Follow us on Twitter

Charlie Mahtesian @PoliticoCharlie

Calder McHugh @calder_mchugh

 

Follow us

Follow us on FacebookFollow us on TwitterFollow us on InstagramListen on Apple Podcast
 

 POLITICO, LLC 1000 Wilson Blvd. Arlington, VA, 22209, USA

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

POLITICO Nightly: The growing distrust of the American health care system

  By  Joanne Kenen Prescription drugs displayed at NYC Discount Pharmacy in Manhattan on July 23. | Spencer Platt/Getty Images WARNING SIGNS...